Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Electrical question

Posts

Electrical question

#1

Electrical question

A Wright

>I am wiring in a new air compressor, and it requires a 30A 220V circuit. I already have the wiring in the wall completed, but I need to put a 25ft cord on the compressor to reach to location of the wall outlet.

I went to Lowes and picked up a three prong 220V "dryer plug" that is rated at 30A. When I started to install the plug, I realized that the third prong was designated for the neutral wire (not ground). The wiring I have run in the wall has 4 leads (neutral, ground, and both legs of the 220), but the cable I am using for the cord is 10/3 so it only has three wires.

Do I need to get a different type of 30A plug, or just use the third prong on the wall outlet for ground (and leave the neutral unconnected)?

Re: Electrical question

#2

Re: Electrical question

Rod Peterson * Ormond Beach

>> Do I need to get a different type of 30A plug, or just use the third prong on the wall outlet for ground (and leave the neutral unconnected)?

You may get some contradictory answers, but I believe the answer to this lies in what the code requirements are for types of circuits.

In the case of dryers and ranges, the NEC was changed several years ago to require a four-wire circuit. Although those appliances had long had 120V devices working within, which need one of the 120V legs plus a neutral, the NEC permitted (now referred to as an "RV Exception" I believe) the use of the ground for the return path of the 120V devices. Now, the required four wire circuit provides a dedicated ground and neutral

Water heaters, which didn't used to require the ground (just the two 120V hots), now requires a ground.

The circuit you installed is not intended for a dryer or a range, but is for a piece of machinery, which is pretty much the same setup as a water heater. So, despite the fact that your plug says "neutral," because it's sold as a "dryer plug," its function in this circuit is as a ground. Wire the ground to the third lug.

There is absolutely nothing unsafe by doing this in the circumstances you describe. Some may argue it doesn't meet code, and although I don't agree with that assessment, I can't cite chapter and verse to support my contention. If you're seriously concerned on that aspect, check with your AHJ (authority having jurisdiction).

Again, under the circumstances you describe, the aforementioned is safe.

Rod
Addy Protocol: experienced amateur electrician

Re: Electrical question

#3

Re: Electrical question

Bill Howatt

>You have the receptacle correct with the 4 wires connected. This is important because someone other than yourself might plug in a device that expects the neutral to be present. In your case, it is there and all if fine.

I would only wire the 2 hots and the ground and leave the neutral pin with no connection. The two hots are powering the compressor correctly and the safety ground is connected. Although connecting the ground to the neutral will cause no operational problem, I would leave it disconnected because I expect grounds and neutrals to only be tied together at the main panel.

Bill, who isn't an electrician either.

Re: Electrical question

#4

Re: Electrical question

Jay Lombardo

>Leave the Neutral unconnected, land the ground on the third prong. It will be fine.

Re: Electrical question

#5

Re: Electrical question

Rick Christopherson

>You picked up a NEMA 10-30 plug, but your application should be using a NEMA 6-30. They should actually be cheaper, and the home center should carry them.

Contrary to what another poster stated, you cannot simply re-task the connections on a NEMA device to suit other needs, as they are nationally defined and labeled.

The plug you need looks like this.


The plug you already bought probably is this one.


As for the neutral in the junction box, simply wire nut it and leave it disconnected.

Re: Electrical question

#6

Re: Electrical question

Rick Christopherson

>

Rod Peterson said:
You may get some contradictory answers, but I believe the answer to this lies in what the code requirements are for types of circuits.
At the time of this posting, over 120 people have read your advise, and probably a significant number of those readers are led to believe that with the above statement that you are knowledgeable with the National Electric Code. Please be careful about leaving the wrong impression.
Rod Peterson said:
Although those appliances had long had 120V devices working within, which need one of the 120V legs plus a neutral, the NEC permitted (now referred to as an "RV Exception" I believe) the use of the ground for the return path of the 120V devices.
At no time did the NEC ever permit the grounding condutor to be used as a grounded (neutral, current-carrying conductor) conductor. When these appliances were permitted to be connected with a 3-wire receptacle, it was a 3-pole, non-grounding, NEMA 10-30 receptacle. In other words, the appliances were permitted to be ungrounded, but they were never permitted to use the grounding conductor as a current carrying conductor. If you look at the NEMA 10-30 plug configuration shown below, you will see that the upper prong is clearly marked [as mandated by NEC 200.10(B) (1) and (2)] with the letter "W".

Rod Peterson said:
So, despite the fact that your plug says "neutral," because it's sold as a "dryer plug," its function in this circuit is as a ground. Wire the ground to the third lug. Some may argue it doesn't meet code, and although I don't agree with that assessment, I can't cite chapter and verse to support my contention.
You are correct that you cannot locate anything in the NEC to support your position, because it is not supported. To the contrary, it is directly contradicted by the NEC.
406.3(D)(1) Grounding-Type Receptacles. Where a grounding means exists in the receptacle enclosure or an equipment grounding conductor is installed in accordance with 250.130(C), grounding-type receptacles shall be used and shall be connected to the equipment grounding conductor in accordance with 406.3(C) or 250.130(C).
This means that he is not permitted to use the NEMA 10-30 receptacle because it is listed as a non-grounding receptacle. Furthermore:
406.9(B) Grounding-Pole Identification. Grounding-type receptacles, adapters, cord connections, and attachment plugs shall have a means for connection of an equipment grounding conductor to the grounding pole.
A terminal for connection to the grounding pole shall be designated by one of the following:

Summary of (1) through (4): To shorten up this quote, the 4 permitted identification means are various green colored screws, green markings, or the letters "G" or "GR".

406.9(D) Grounding-Pole Requirements.Grounding-type attachment plugs and mating cord connectors and receptacles shall be designed such that the equipment grounding connection is made before the current-carrying connections. Grounding-type devices shall be so designed that grounding poles of attachment plugs cannot be brought into contact with current-carrying parts of receptacles or cord connectors.

406.9(E) Use. Grounding-type attachment plugs shall be used only with a cord having an equipment grounding conductor.
This section is what prevents you from re-tasking the grounded (neutral) connection to be utilized as the Grounding connection.

Re: Electrical question

#7

Now I'm confused!

Tony - Memphis

>I thought 220 circuits has two hots and a neutral and the ground was added "recently." I just wired an outlet for my PM200 and it has the two hots and the neutral - no ground. Are there 220 circuits that have two hots and a ground? Just trying to learn and understand here. I did the reasearch when I installed mine and had an electrician work on my panel because I was short on breakers (he just added some slims and such - but it was worht the $125 to get it all checked by a pro).

I had to get a new cord for my dryer when we moved from "old" to "new" house. That's when I learned about the 4 wire setup.

Tony

Re: Electrical question

#8

I switched to a "welder" plug

A Wright

>Since the wire in the box is #6, I returned the outlet I had bought from Lowes and got a three prong 50A "welder" outlet instead. I decided this would give me the most flexibility and allow me to use my Lincoln 220 welder on the plug if the mood strikes me.

I hardwired a 10/3 service cord into the compressor with the appropriate male plug on the end, and everything is good to go.

I do agree that there probably would not have been any performance/safety issues with grounding the neutral on the dryer plug as long as I was using it with a grounded cord, but it would not have been up to code and I would hate for someone else to come along and plug something else into the outlet and cause a problem

Thanks to all for the advice

Re: Electrical question

#9

Re: Now I'm confused!

A Wright

>Tony - I *think* the proper wiring for your Powermatic machine should be 2 hots and a ground (NOT 2 hots and a neutral)

Someone correct me if I am wrong

Re: Electrical question

#10

Re: Now I'm confused!

Rick Christopherson

>Most 240 volt circuits do not use the neutral, and I assume you were referring to a PM2000, and it would be no different. You should have two hots and a ground, not two hots and a neutral.