Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

Posts

Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

#1

Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

Bob Lang

>A week or so ago we were talking about a detail on Stickley glass paned doors where the mullions and muntins join with miters. I've just posted on the Popular Woodworking blog about the project I'm working on. You can read about it and see some photos of the joints in progress at the link below.


img

Mitered Mullions on the Pop Wood Blog

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

#2

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Bob, very nice write-up and execution!!

Another technique, that while likely not as authentic nor as rewarding to do well since it is easier, is to make your mullions in two pieces- a wide mitered front part and a narrower back part which is glued to the fronts. Since the glue up is long grain to long grain it arguably results in a mullion grid that is just as strong, but considerably quicker and easier to execute. In my mind I haven't decided which is better to have full length- the horizontal or vertical mullions. To reduce flex, full length horizontals which are shorter and pieced verticals, might be best.

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

#3

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions

Bob Lang

>The two part solution was considered, but it seemed like cheating. And in that scenario, I think I would have wanted to half lap the back pieces and tenon them in to the outer stiles-still a lot of work.

I went round and round about which parts should run the full length. Photos of originals looked like the verticals ran continuously so that's the way I did it. Given the small sizes of the openings (about 6" x 6 1/2") it's stiff when assembled. The openings would need to be much larger for flexing to be an issue.

Bob Lang

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

#4

Ellis Walentine

The only thing...

Ellis Walentine

>... that surprises me is that the muntins aren't tenoned into the mullions, even if only with a stub tenon (although you can certainly conceive of the half-lapped points as tenons). That seems to be a break with traditional divided light construction.

Also, if you want to optimize the stiffness, wouldn't you want to make the shorter members run through, as you first suggested? That would be the horizontals, right?

Ellis

Re: Stickley Mitered Mullions *LINK*

#5

Re: The only thing...

Bob Lang

>There isn't much room back there, after the rabbets the piece that is left is only 3/4" wide. I didn't think the teeny tiny tenon would add enough to make it worth the trouble.

Ideally both pieces would run full length, but I think it's a coin toss as to which way would be stronger or stiffer. As I said earlier, looking at the grain on originals lead me to making the vertical piece full length, and I think that made it easier to keep everything lined up.

Bob Lang