Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Filling tear out in Walnut

Posts

Filling tear out in Walnut

#1

Filling tear out in Walnut

Dan Mitchell

>Here's a pic of a table leg I shaped on the router table. I got a couple minor areas of tear out, this one being about the worst. A bit hard to tell from the image, but I'd say at its maximum depth, the defect is maybe 1/16" below the desired level, about 3/16" wide and about 1/2" long. I have mixed sawdust with yellow glue in the past to fill some defects, it can work fairly well, depending on the wood. This is my 1st experience with Walnut. Also, at this point, I'm not sure how I'm going to finish the coffee table, which may be a factor. Any suggestions as to the best approach to filling these small defects? Piece at the point of damage is ~ 1 1/8" x 1".

TIA

Dan


img

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#2

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

Fred Davis

>Dan ,

I have had this happen with router tearout a few times over the years and I would flatten the area with a sharp chisel as much as possible, choose a grain and color match from the same Walnut and glue it in place , it will stand proud of the surround surface and you run in back though the shaping or routing operation.

If you do this as close as possible, you may avoid wood putty altogether which is what you want to do.

FredD

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#3

Ellis Walentine

Depends

Ellis Walentine

>Dan, every question requires some judgment to answer. In this case, I'd have to ask if it matters if you simply reduce the size of this part a bit to get past the tearout. It looks like some kind of slat. Will it be noticeable if you rip 1/16" off and try that round-over again? (Be sure to keep the grain problem in mind when routing. You can probably avoid a repeat performance by changing the orientation of the wood on the router table.)

Or, you could work the face and edge and radius with a sharp plane to make the divot go away.

Otherwise, if it really needs to be perfect, make a Dutchman as Fred suggests. Wood filler will look like a uniform blotch, but a real wood repair will look almost invisible.

Ellis

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#4

agreed

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>The problem with filling walnut is that walnut bleaches lighter with age. So if you match the color now the filler will stand out darker later.

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#5

Re: Depends

Barry Irby

>I agree with all of the above. Who says the legs has to be exactly that size and profile? I would probably Plane, Sand, Scrape, or whatever that defect into submission. If it is a straight leg, I might rip 1/16" off the offending edge and round it over by hand with some sand paper on a block or even my ROS. What ever I did, I would do it to all four legs if I could see the difference in them after I fixed this one. My first attempt might be to increase the round over form 1/8 to 3/32 to see if it would go away.

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#6

Interesting point

Dan Donaldson

>In these times of computer controlled machines and other automation, we are used to seeing exact duplication of all parts. In earlier times, when everything was made strictly by hand, the probability of two spindles or two (fill in the blank) being absolutely identical was unlikely, and yet some of this furniture is regarded as classic and timeless. As long as there is some level of separation of the parts, it is hard for the eye to determine that they are not identical. Sometimes we can get too tied up in minutia and lose track of the overall look. (This is not to say this is the case in this thread, just a general observation)

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#7

Re: Depends

Barry Irby

>I happened to standing in a friends commercial shop when a fellow walked in and was nearly in tears over the fact that his lathe broke down and he would not be able to finish turning four table legs before Christmas. I was volunteered to finish turning them for him. He was ecstatic. He gave me four partially turned legs. It would have been hard for them to be more different. Beads were at different height off the floor, they were different diameters, There were vase shapes in them, but they appeared to be from different schools of design. There was a half inch difference in the length of the legs. I was astounded. He wanted them to match, but not be any more slender. I cleaned them up, sort of pushed the details up and down a bit, matched the diameters as best I could, sanded them and gave them back. They looked like somebody turned them from memory on four different days without the benefit of a plan. He was thrilled. I couldn't bring myself to charge him.

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#8

Sounds like my Dad where the words close

John Lucas

>enough is just a mild resemblance of what he does. He enjoys building things but isn't worried about details likel, is it square or do the legs match.

As far as the walnut damage. I've used the glue in patch many times and it is the way to do. Just carve out a simply to replicate angle and glue in a matching piece. It will be almost invisible.

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#9

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

Tom Rex in TX

>I just completed a hall table for my daughter.

My excellant finisher (LOML) used tung oil as a finish.

Really brought out the grain and looks beautiful.

She always makes my mistakes look good.

T Rex

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

#10

Re: Filling tear out in Walnut

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. I've done the "Dutchman" thing before too, I'll take look & see if it seems doable in this case. Here's a pic of the table assembled (actually, just "stacked together" for the pic). The long sides are a bit more rounded then they appear in this image, see my previous post http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/messages3.pl?read=400293 Notice the edges are tapered, as well as curved. The tear out (as if it isn't OBVIOUS!) is at the foot end of one of the legs. DON'T TELL ME YOU CAN'T SEE IT!!! ;-)


img