We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>The problem: In the 60's in a Chicago subiurb, an addition put on the house with a furnace in the attic. The attic is blazing hot in the summertime, but, perhaps more importantly, very warm in the wintertime. As a result, we have huge ice dams at the eaves of the house.
The solution: My plan is the following:
1. Install larger gable vents
2. Install larger soffit vents
3. Install several of those square attic vents (passive air flow) near the ridge of the house.
4. Seal all ductwork and insulate from the outside with duct insulation - both return and supply ducts.
5. Blow or roll more insulation in the attic itself to build up the barrier to the living space below (being sure not to block the air flow from the soffits to the ridge of the house)
6. Install an attic fan.
The 3 questions:
1. Should I install the attic fan on a thermostat, a timer, or both? I want it to be on in the wintertime too. Solar powered attic fan is not an option - huge oak tree covers the southern exposure.
2. Should I consider installing a fan in the gable end as well to move more air out that way?
3. I am trying to keep the attic as cool as possible, but should I consider installing insulation in the roof rafters to prevent that warm air from melting the snow and then producing those awful ice dams? Would insulating the rafters help reduce this phenomenon?
I know there are many websites about this topic but I was hoping to get some advice on those 3 specific questions. Thanks!
>I'm not familiar with snow country issues, but I would recommend your attic fan be on a thermostat rather than a timer - if you're trying to keep your attic below a threshold temperature, you want the temp to be your determining factor.
What's the condition of your roofing? Is it close enough to replacement to justify a new roof, with ice dam membrane running up several feet?
>Well I'm in Decatur and in an 85 yr old house. I would suggest starting with #3 on your list, make sure to get all the hot air you produced down into the living space. Get some screws, tape and mastic and seal those ducts up! Then insulate them and isolate the living space better. You shouldn't be losing enough heat to warm the attic. Air should come in to your combustion chamber, be transfered or exchanged as efficiently as possible, and shoved down into your living space.
I've been going through the hell of insulating my kneewalls the last couple of days, so all I've been thinking about is efficiency and insulation.
>To address the specific problem you are trying to solve, you might consider wiring the new attic fan to come on when the furnace fan is blowing. This will help exhaust any warm air coming from the furnace whenever it is operating.
1. Should I install the attic fan on a thermostat, a timer, or both? I want it to be on in the wintertime too. Solar powered attic fan is not an option - huge oak tree covers the southern exposure.
I am a Home Inspector in VA, near Richmond. So my climate is somewhat milder than yours in winter and probably hotter in summer. I am not generally an advocate of fans. It's a long story, but he short version is that fan manufacturers know that the public won't put up with a lot of noise and a noticeable amount of electricity use, so they make the fans small and quiet to avoid both. In summer, the sun can deliver about 1000 btus per square foot. So If you have 500 square feet of roofing, you could be receiving 500,000 btus per hour. Most fans can remove about 25 to 30,000. That's why, when on a thermostat, they come on in the morning and cut off after dark. They are whistling in the wind, waiting for the attic to cool down. Also, a significant percentage of attic fires are associated with attic fans, I believe I remember that the Fire Dept. in Chicago encourages a smoke detector in the attic if you are installing a fan.
2. Should I consider installing a fan in the gable end as well to move more air out that way? (See Above for my opinion of Fans)
3. I am trying to keep the attic as cool as possible, but should I consider installing insulation in the roof rafters to prevent that warm air from melting the snow and then producing those awful ice dams? Would insulating the rafters help reduce this phenomenon?
I would consider installing Icynene spray in foam insulation. This seals the under side of the deck and prevent humidity getting to the wood and condensing. I would be reluctant to use batts like fiberglass because humidity will find its way around it and rot the roof sheathing. In addition to insulating and sealing the ducts, this is the most direct route to stopping the ice damming. This would keep the warmth off the underside of the deck.
I have no personal experience with the Icynene. Ice damming is fairly rare in my climate. I agree with Bill. Use Ice and Water Shield under the roofing when you replace it. I have seen several poorly insulated deck fail because humidity got around it to the sheathing.
You could go to Joseph Lstiburek web site (BuildingScience.com I think) for more info. He is one of the best building scientist's in the country and there is an overwhelming amount of info on his site.
If you want to play, why not Insulate the underside of the deck, Improve the ventilation, Seal the ducts, and shunt the waste heat into the crawl space? A small thermostatically controlled fan and some ductwork might save you some energy. Be Careful.
The Icynene will keep the attic cooler in summer and should reduce your AC bill. It may make the deck operate hotter and cook the shingles, accelerating their demise. Clearly some sort of trade off. Insulated decks are becoming more common because of SIP's (Structural Insulated Panels) It is unclear how much effect this will ave on the shingles.
>Check your flue/vent for the furnace. The output of a gas furnace is about 18% steam. If the flue gasses are leaking into the attic, that could be a serious problem.
>1) Do what can be done to keep the heat in the house. You pay for it daily thru the winter and thru the summer with AC bills. This should be your first priority. This is a one time cost. This involves insulating properly, and venting the attic. Soffit & ridge vents to promote thermosyphon air flow, and when done properly, work well without mechanical assistance.
2) If a roof is in the future, and color isn't a major decision, lighter colors of roofing do not absorb as much radiant heat from the sun.
3) Fans would help, but still need areas to draw make-up air from, thus soffit & ridge vents are still needed.
4) Without attempting to keep the heat/cool in the house, you'll be paying for those heat/cool losses, AND operation of a fan.
5) You will do better insulating the house from the attic than insualating the underside of the roof surface. Overall, makes a smaller volume you are trying to heat/cool, and makes it easier to keep the underside of your roof (with proper venting) the same as the outside temperature.
6) Once you insulate as best as you can, there are contractors out there that will do a thermal-imaging of your home to see where the rest of the heat leaks are.
>If you're anywhere near needing the new roof others have mentioned, consider a second deck ventilated top and bottom to keep the actual roof whatever the outside temperature is.
Insulate the attic space as thoroughly as described by others.
A major contributor of heat to cause ice at roof edges is head\t from the walls. You might consider improving the insulation in the walls.
>Airvent makes some nice powered cooling units. They have some with not only a thermostat, but also a humidistat so that they can run in the winter too. Check them out, pretty inexpensive. Larry