We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>A question for the assembled intelligence of the group.
Many of you know I am a Home Inspector. Looked at a house under construction today. Owner is upset that the custom milled mill work has raised wood grain. The trim was milled by a local company and primed and delivered to the site back in the summer. The trim is Pine. The grain is raised about a 1/32". Its as if the soft part has been removed leaving the hard parts slightly proud.
The supplier blames it on the fact that the house was hot and humid, and not air conditioned.
I think I know what caused it but I want your opinions. Can you tell me why this would happen?
>I would guess that the millwork co. is right, sort of. The wood was relatively wetter when the milled it, now it has dried out. Might have been ok if installed and finished in the summer, but probably not. I doubt having the house A/C'd would have made any difference at all, they're just passing the buck (having their shop A/C'd might have helped if the wood sat in it for long enough before milling). If the case were reversed - soft parts proud - I'd guess that the cutters were overly dull. Both those are guesses though, bought and paid for with 2 cents :)
>It could be due to a waterborne primer on the pine trim and/or the temperature/humidity conditions in the house.
The bottom line is that it is pine. The only painted pine trim packages that I ultimately liked came from a supplier that puts a very thick, sandable primer on (I think it's a lacquer primer). You can see the thickness of the primer at the end cuts.
>Why would you be inspecting a house under construction, I assume it has a building permit and maybe a contractor doing the work.
If the work is by a weekend warrior, he will get all levels of work from subs.
If it is a licensed experienced Contractor with a good track record, all the owner needs to do ,is tell the Contractor the trim is not acceptable and replace it , the cause of the grain raising is irrelevant, a satisfied client is far more important to a reputable contractor then a hassle over who is right or wrong.
He is contractually on the hook for all work, leave it to him and the client.
As for the grain raising, if the mill run Yellow Pine , then you can expect a difference in levels of the late and early wood.
It is about the same as Doug Fir when the wood is not selected.
>I inspect a lot of houses under construction. You might be astounded at soem of the things I find. Various local couties do very uneven jobs of inspectign and enforcing.
This house, the owner acted as his own contractor. And, you are right. An amteur dealing with the subs gets different result than a pro.
He hired a local company that claims to have a very good regional reputtion for their work. They provide the mill work for renovation on the Governors Mansion, The State Capitol, and even some in the White House, Etc, Etc.
They made the trim and ran it through a profile sander and primed it. Delivered it to the hsoue in the summer when according to them it was 100 degrees and 100% humidity. Their craftsmen installed it. They claim it was the excessive hat and humidity that ruined the trim.
I think it was their sander. Ever sanded floorign with dull sand paper? It sands away the soft grain and leaves the harder grain proud.
>With due all respect Barry, when I mention Building Inspections and Building Inspectors, I am talking about ICBO certified inspectors who are the ones who inspect work and sign off permits, anything else is dubious at best.
The best ones are retired building trades workers especially in the area of Carpentry and Mechanical and Electrical/Plumbing trades.
>Fred, Not arguing at all. Good county/jurisdictional inspections are the best. Locally at least, the only person that can say whether the work meets the code or not is the local Building Official. But the Code is a minimum. I would not expect to buy a upper end house that only met the Code.
But, part of the problem is political. Locally the building inspections department has to operate with in its budget. They get their funding from the fees they collect. They are under pressure to operate like a business and not over spend. They assign their inspectors as many as thirty inspections to do in a day. That means that in a 7 1/2 hour day, its fifteen minutes per inspection. They have to find the house, inspect it, write it up, and move on to the next house in fifteen minutes. If the houses are close together that helps, but sometimes they are scattered around.
Many of them have been accused of being former contractors and trades men that could not make it in the real world, so they went to work for the government. That's unfair and unkind.
Many Home Inspectors are former builders and tradesmen that could not make it in the real world, so they went to inspecting. Some of them used to work at Wendy's or if you are lucky, Lowes. I train Home Inspectors and the most common "qualification" they tell me is "they helped their father build their house when they were a kid".
I have a Degree from Va. Tech in Building Construction, worked in commercial construction, was a Class A contractor in the residential market for 13 years and when I decided to do inspections took the same training and tests the local building inspectors take and am Certified by BOCA as a Building Official. I have five other certifications with them including all the ones they give to the trades and as a combination inspector. I take the training offered by the county every year.
Incidentally, ICBO, BOCA, and SBCCI are all gone now. They merged.
So the local guys do a really good job under the constraints of time and budget, but when I go to a house, I might spend two or three hours. I have an advantage. The builder did not pay the fee that pays my salary. Teh builder is not my customer. I am not concerned he will move his operation to the next county. I am not concerned about being even handed.
Part of the problem is that there is no uniformity among private inspectors. We bring our prejudices and poor training with us. So the results are uneven. In the inspection group I am in, we do 20 hours of training for continuing Ed a year. Realtors don't have that much. PE don't either. But most of the local Home Inspectors don't either.
OTOH almost the only question anyone asks me when they are shopping for an inspection is "How much do you charge." Not "what are your qualifications." So apparently they have been lead to believe that any of us is the same as any other. (Any Realtors want to raise your hand?) In fact the Realtors know who the better more thorough inspectors are. How can the poor inspectors survive without referrals?
>Note: The 2006 International Codes are now available. However, at the time of this writing, a single, uniform building code is still not a reality in the United States, let alone in the "International" community as the name implies. Simply put, government agencies do not always work as quickly as the private building sector. Even though the three major code organizations (BOCA, ICBO, SBCCI) have all been consolidated into a single building code organization (ICC) most local inspection agencies use building codes that are several years old. Worse still, virtually every government jurisdiction that controls building permits and inspections has modified the 'standard' codes to some extent. So, be sure to check with your local department of permits and licenses to see exactly which building codes � and their respective revision dates and modifications � are applicable to your specific project.
This is old news Barry.
Getting back to your original gripe about the trim your friend got for his house while acting as his own Contractor.
A couple of facts about that , one is , if the trim left the mill and measured up to Mill standards, then that is as far as they will go because they have no control over the trim once it has left the shop.
If the trim had been purchased by a recurring customer like a Building Contractor, they would handle the problem simply by replacing it.
Having a Building Contractor engaged in your home building has the same advantages that using a General Surgeon for your operation has.
Week-end Warrior types very often find themselves at the mercy of Sub Contractors work schedules and find out belatedly that the subs are running the job.
Having you as a second opinion , bird dogging the construction people and their vendors before the house is completed only exacerbates problems easily handled by people who do it for a living.
In no way is this intended to belittle your Home inspection vocation and with your stated extensive background, you should have no trouble in resolving the perceived Trim problem.
>Fred, You said "if the trim left the mill and measured up to Mill standards, then that is as far as they will go because they have no control over the trim once it has left the shop."
That's what I am trying to figure out. If the trim were milled properly and sanded smooth and primed when it left the shop, what "forces" would have made the grain standout physically later?
In my years of building, I dealt with both primed and primed trim, most of it off the shelf, but a small percentage of it custom milled. If any of it had raised grain (not the fuzz you get form wetting wood before final sanding) it was a tiny percentage. Way less than one percent.
I did not see the trim when it was delivered, so I don't know if it had the raised grain when it arrived. The shop that made it claims it was the fact that it was delivered in summer and the house was hot and humid. I'm sure I built many houses where it was hot and humid, never had the problem.
I think it is one of two things. Either the wood was green or at an excessive moisture content when it was milled or their sand paper was dull. In talking to other mill people, they claim that if the sandpaper were dull, it would have rounded all the corners and knocked the "crispness" off the pieces. I don't have a a sample, but as I recall, the corners were only slightly rounded. OTOH, it would not take much to create the raised grain effect.
The other reason I wonder about the sanding is that only the sanded surfaces have the effect. For example, on a door facing the milled and sanded profile has the effect, but the edges and back don't.
The subcontractor in this case wants to have everything both ways. They made the doors and primed them, but did not sand and touch up the defects. They installed the trim with very few nails. There was a nail in the base board about every four feet and the door jambs basically had a nail top and bottom. They put about half the screws in the kitchen cabinets that were called for and more than half of those missed the frame strips in the cabinet or the studs in the walls. Their answer to everything was either, the painter should have fixed it or we were going to get it later.
And yes, they were subcontractors, but they made the trim and installed it. Locally, the last man that handles it is the final Quality Control guy. You buy prefinished hardwood floor, the factory grades it and does QC, but if you get a nasty looking piece, the guy nailing if is supposed to reject it or put it in a closet. These guys wanted to say they were the best of the best, but QC was not their job.
>"Week-end Warrior types very often find themselves at the mercy of Sub Contractors work schedules and find out belatedly that the subs are running the job." ;-))