Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Repair Project

Posts

Repair Project

#1

Repair Project

Ed Freestone

>I have cleaned up and touched up the finish on this mahogany dresser we picked up at a consignment shop. But I'm stumped on how best to repair the broken piece of carved trim on the face of the top drawer.

The shop owner suggested making a mold of the undamaged right side branches, then filling the mold with wood filler or putty. I think the resulting piece will be backwards or upside down or something. And I'm afraid my carving skills peaked at Boy Scout neckerchief slides about 45 years ago.

Any thoughts? Is there a way to make a piece from a mold? What kind of filler? Or do I just need to start whitlin' and hope for the best?

Thanks in advance,

Ed Freestone


img

Re: Repair Project

#2

Re: Repair Project

Ed Freestone

>Detail picture...


img

Re: Repair Project

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Find the three faults.......

Jesper, Denmark

>I had a hard time finding the damage. It was like one of those puzzles with two drawings, where you have to find the differences.

You should probably just not fix it. It will not be really noticed by most people, but a botched fix will shout out loud to anybody.

Re: Repair Project

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Cheap and dirty method

Dale Lenz

>It occurred to me to cut the other side off to balance the carving out. I'll probably get burned over this idea.

Re: Repair Project

#5

Re: Find the three faults.......

Dan Donaldson

>I think that I would agree with this. At least in the photo, it is really not very noticeable and a bad repair would look worse.

Re: Repair Project

#6

Re: Repair Project

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod MA

>The mold process works if you have an identical piece of carving to use as a pattern. In this case you don't have an identical pattern to copy, you have a mirror image, so forget the mold business.

Sometimes these old carvings are not really carvings, they are cast from some material so they don't take stain the same way wood does. So, if you get the missing pieces carved and installed you will have to stain match and that might be a challenge. If it's not done well the mismatch will draw the eye, more so than just leaving the carving as-is, as others have suggested. Just something to be aware of.

If you're interested in carving and want to have some fun, go for it. There might be a local carving club with members who can help you or even do the work.

Re: Repair Project

#7

one option, do it right

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Hire someone to make the repair. This is a trivial carving job for someone experienced so it should not cost much. You could hire an antique repair shop or find a carver and make the repair yourself.

http://custommade.com/ is a place to look for carvers. Or, post on the hand tool side as there are some over there, or ask at one the the schools if someone would like a job, eg North Bennett.

Re: Repair Project

#8

Re: Repair Project

Tony - Memphis

>That really looks like a casting to me. I have several "antiques" that have similar applied decoration. I wouldn't be surprised if you were able to find the same applique at one of the companies that sell those. I can't think of the name of the company, but there is one company that still offers designs from 100 years ago. I know Phil Lowe used their products on a gothic style bookcase he built (article in FWW). The article probably listed the source. I think I have their catalog at home. I'll dig around. You could probably carve the missing pieces in bass wood and then stain the whole thing and make it look good. I'm guessing the ornament was stained to match the wood orginally.

Tony

Re: Repair Project

#9

Source *LINK*

Tony - Memphis

>Mario Rodriguez (I apologize for murdering his name) also covers using comp ornaments in his book on fireplace mantels.

Here is THE source for them...


Decorator's Supply

Re: Repair Project

#10

Re: Find the three faults.......

steve mackay

>My FIRST thought also ! GOD, would I screw that up ! I'd have TWICE the mess than as is. Next I'd spend all the time in the world looking for replacements that I liked and fit. I'm not knowledgable enough to know if the piece should be "restored" rather than "preserved" but I've found most aren't historicaly significant enough to really fret over. A good, clean job of replacing might bring a better result.

Re: Repair Project

#11

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Repair Project - Source *LINK*

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I see that the other source mentioned has a $100.00 minimum order. Van Dyke's Restorers has six pages of appliques in their catalog.

None of them look like an exact match, but there a number pf 'possibles' for replacement.


Van Dyke's

Re: Repair Project

#12

Re: Repair Project

Michael Wilkins

>One of 2 options I would take:

1. Leave it alone. The missing piece is hard to detect at first glance; only upon carefully looking at it for a long time do you notice it.

2. Search the scrap pile for a comparable species of wood, and do some experimentation on carving a new piece to fit. The human eye can not detect minute differences in shape, especially since the ends are seperated. You may be surprised at what you can do.

Re: Repair Project

#13

Re: Repair Project

Ed Freestone

>Thanks, everyone, for your suggestions. I checked through the links for replacement pieces but I think I'll try my hand at a little carving and see what I get.

Ed Freestone

Re: Repair Project

#14

Re: Repair Project

charlie belden

>I only found two areas that are obvious and attached illustrates possible "fixes".


img