Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Lumber Prices Rant

Posts

Lumber Prices Rant

#1

Bart Goldberg

Lumber Prices Rant

Bart Goldberg

>I am amazed at the variation in lumber prices from one retailer to another. I was recently looking to buy some 4/4 Wenge, and found prices from $13/bdft to nearly $20/bdft. Needless to say that I bought from the retailer that was $13/bdft. I complained of the 20bdft price to my local supplier and he tells me that he is not marking up his prices that much and that 13/bdft is below his cost. Now how can that be when just 30 minutes away, I can purchase the same lumber so much cheaper, and that retailer is still making a profit?

Bart

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#2

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

Chuck W

>no doubt it depends on the supplier, how much is purchased, terms of the purchase and the suppliers markup. My motto is to buy where the price is cheapest and let the other store with higher prices know why.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#3

A speculative answer

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If we were dealing with a domestic species I could speak with more confidence but I'll take a stab at this situation.

There are hundreds of producers of domestic hardwood lumber and the production volume is so high that there is never much inbalance of demand and supply. Hence, a retail business buying some sized quantities-small packs to truckload- has many competitive sources to choose from. These facts mean that the local retail price is determined by how many middle men the lumber passes through (determine by the quantity the retailer buys) and the mark-up needed by the marketing details of the retailer. So differences at the retail level reflect whether the retailer is moving board feet or thousands of board feet and whether the retail customer is picking through stacks or buying by grade and quantity.

Added to these factors, foreign lumber had additional complications- political, distance from market, scarcity. Take the case of South American Mahogany. There has been an export ban on this species in many (maybe all) countries to try to tamp down the black market. Black market mahogany is available, at a price. Before the ban some countries would not allow the export of logs. This restriction lengthened the distance from production to market. I was in a warehouse some years ago that had 5/4 mahogany stacked to the ceiling. I was told that that is what got shipped from Honduras, in spite of the fact they needed 4/4. Some species in high demand have simply been logged to commercial extinction. All these factors lead to spot, or permanent, shortages of foreign species and can lead to wild fluctuations in price. Pitty the poor retailer that buys high and needs to sell lower because the market softened.

The short answer to your question is that the $13/bdft supplier bought the inventory at a lower price as a result of some of the factors enumerated above. If you are smitten by foreign woods buy a lot when ever you find an attractive price. There is a long history of demand leading to commercial extinction of the popular foreign species.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#4

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

John McGaw

>Not nearly enough information to go on.

Example: the cheaper place was selling wood that they've had in stock for eleven years and figured that they would never move it while the more expensive place had just replaced his entire stock of wenge a week ago.

Example: the cheaper place sets prices on what the stock actually cost when it was purchased while the more expensive place sets prices on the replacement cost will be today.

I found a lumber place in western PA in a run-down almost-ghost town some years back which had an amazing stock of exotics (gaboon ebony, several types of rosewood) at wonderful prices. They probably set the prices while the town was still lively and had been sitting on it for years. But, even after cutting the stock down and packing it and mailing it to Alaska, the total price was still only 60% of what I would have paid in Anchorage.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#5

Anchorage Hardwood sources

Craig Spacek

>Hi John,

Where do go to find hardwood around Anchorage? I've been buying from Hardware Specialties and like them, but have not found any other places around town. I've heard of a place out in the valley but nobody seems to know for sure where it is or what it's called. It would sure be nice to have another option.

Thanks,

Craig

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#6

The reason imported lumber is up!

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>Look no farther than the US Dollar vs. the world !!! In the last 2 years the dollar has fallen more than 38%. If you think this bad, wait until the Chinese Yuan becomes the currency of choice for world trade

Just the Facts of Life,

Dave (PacNW)

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#7

Re: Anchorage Hardwood sources

John McGaw

>I can't really say anything about lumber sources in Anchorage any more since I drove out in October '97 and haven't been back since. My favorite source when I was there was the shop run by John Hartvigson. Down on the Old Seward IIRC. Unfortunately I've heard that John shut the store down and concentrated on the family custom cabinet shop.

There was when I started woodworking in Alaska a sort of informal private wood network. Somebody would obtain a stash of some wood and then trade/sell it with other woodworkers but that was dying out by the time I left.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#8

Re: The reason imported lumber is up!

Alexander Grigoriev

>Lower dollar =equals= US goods more competitive abroad =equal= less trade deficit =equals= more jobs in US.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The reason imported lumber is up!

Jesper, Denmark

>"Lower dollar =equals= US goods more competitive abroad =equal= less trade deficit =equals= more jobs in US."

The statement is correct in makro terms.

However, it also means that the relative wealth of US wage earners compared to the rest of the world will be reduced. Initially this will bring some hardship, as US consumers have been used to the fact that their world record consumption of energy per capita and the associated relative high waste will no longer be possible.

Short term, this will be a difficult adjustment, but good old Amurrican ingenuity will prevail.

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

#10

Re: Lumber Prices Rant

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>I got fed up with the prices (and quality) of a lot of the "fancy" woods. So I changed my ways, and along with some other woodowrkers, we started to mill our own wood. We've milled cedar (red and yellow), alder, western bigleaf maple, silver maple, yellow birch, black walnut, holly, beech and from the local university (when a tree comes down naturally), we've got english walnut.

On average, after we mill (either using our Alaskan mill(s) or renting a woodmizer), transport and kiln dry, our cost works out to approx $0.75/bd ft.

As for equipment costs, I've got about $600 into my Alaskan rig, which includes a Husky 2100 (ported and muffler modded) running a 37" bar and a 48" mill (gives me a 30" cut). With this rig, I can cut 30" wide beech at about 20 minutes per cut (8.5' long). When I run it in red cedar (14" wide) I run approx. an inch per second...not bad for a hobby saw.

It sure brings woodworking back to an affordable hobby, and the story behind the finished pieces gains another dimension.