Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Snowblower power rateings

Posts

Snowblower power rateings

#1

Snowblower power rateings

Chuck in ND

>Maybe this happened a year or more ago, I don't know. But what is the reasoning behind the manufacturers to now rate the motor size in CC's instead of HP. Personally I think it's just another way to mess with the consumer.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#2

I Agree

Dave's Not Here

>With the exception of the motorcycles that I've owned I've always related the particular power of something by the HP rating. With the new style rating system there is now no way to tell if I'm replacing something with a less powerful motor or more one with a more powerful motor. For instance, two years ago I bought an 8HP snow thrower, what would be the cc number to equal that? I have not clue. Is there a formula to cross reference this? They already messed with the ratings of car engines years ago, changing from cubic inches to liters, now this.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#3

Not only that but...

Dan Donaldson

>The displacement potentially has very little to do with the horsepower, torque, or anything else. You can get a one 1 liter engine with 30 horsepower and another with the same displacement and 200.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#4

I remember snowmobiling races

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>on the Heart River near Mandan, ND, being flabbergasted at 300cc engines turning out 120 hp. (temp that day was -36F)

Bruce

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#5

Louie Lovas

Re: I remember snowmobiling races

Louie Lovas

>As a (farm) kid, we had a 1958 John Deere Tractor. It 302 cubic inch displacement, 50HP but all in 2 cylinders. Darn thing could pull, push or plow just around anything though - had a 6 speed transmission. Amazing I remember this 35 years later.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#6

Re: I remember snowmobiling races

Dan Donaldson

>I believe that horsepower on tractors is measured in a different way. More like horses at the drawbar. Theoretically, a 10 horse tractor could pull the same as if 10 actual horses were attached to the same bar. Probably not accurate, but it makes a good story ;-))

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#7

What's happened with lawn tractor HP's ?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Yea, but something has changed in small engines in the past 2 decades. Remember the "big" lawn tractors had 12 or 16 hp engines, and there were a lot of 7-10 hp lawn tractors out there? Now, entry level machines of the same mower deck size have at least 15 hp and can go up to 25 hp. Guys who do Garden Tractor Pulls (like the big farm tractors) will rather pull with a 1970 vintage 8hp engine verses a recent model 17 hp engine. Have checked and bore/stroke remain similar, as do top-end RPM.

I stand confused.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#8

Re: What's happened with lawn tractor HP's ?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Just a guess, but I remember something about the HP ratings being calculated before the smog-control parts are added to the engines. My 50" mower has a 23HP engine that is clearly less powerful than the 16HP mower it replaced.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#9

Re: Snowblower power rateings LAWYERS!!!!!! *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Well I found this link to an article in the Washington post.....

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/02/15/AR2008021501732.html


http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/02/15/AR2008021501732.html

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#10

I prefer it........

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I kinda like it. At least showing both the cc and HP.

I grew up with motorcycles and engines and always preferred the solid, precise, exact scientific method of sizing engines in cc rather than horsepower.

The cc size of an engine is fixed and undisputable, while the horsepower is affected by so many things and can change and is open to interpretation, much like the 5HP electric motors on air compressors that draw fewer amps than my Blador 3HP motor on my Unisaw ;)

I don't know about other manufacturers, but the Honda GX series is a bit easier to understand since they include both the cc and HP. For instance, the

GX160 = 160cc and 5HP.

GX200 = 200cc and 5.5HP

GX240 = 240cc and 7HP, etc.

And my XR250R (bike) is 250cc (249cc actually) and 100 HP ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#11

Re: I prefer it........

Chuck in ND

>Unfortunately, the snow blowers and lawn mowers that I've seen advertised lately only state the CC, no HP rateing. So it gets them off the hook aparently about being accurate on the HP. Which is fine, but not all motors are made the same. Such as a Chevy 350, a very generic motor with different versions of HP. So in a nut shell, I don't see switching specs as any bennefit to the consumer, only the manufacturer.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#12

Re: Ask a Hardware store salesman

Chuck in ND

>I can only imagine all the different replies you would get if you asked for a motor that was comparable to lets say a 5 HP. I'm thinking some may look at you like a deer looking into the headlights of a car and speachless. I think the manufacturers could of found a better way to ease us into it. Thats what looks so bad in my opinion.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#13

Which engines?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Ya, if they are going to make it harder to understand they would loose my business in an instant.

I like Honda engines for many reasons. Besides the obvious reliability, perfomance, etc it sounds like another good reason is that they make it easy to understand the specs.

For instance:

http://www.honda-engines.com/pro.htm

or even better: http://www.honda-engines.com/gx.htm

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#14

If you think that's bad

Walt Smith

>wait 'til engine power output is expressed only in Kilowatts ;-)

1 horsepower = 0.74569987158227 kilowatt.

Found at converit.com

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#15

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: If you think that's bad

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Rating engines in KW is pretty much the standard everywhere excep North America. Been that way for years.

Jim D.

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#16

That's the way we do it at work,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>but then I make electricity :-)

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#17

Re: More HP confusion? HP measurement *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>If you really want to get confused, check out this link, which may or may not contain completely accurate information, but there are a LOT of different methods that have been, or are are used to determine horsepower.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsepower


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Horsepower

Re: Snowblower power rateings

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Really, Mark?

Jesper, Denmark

>250 cc and 100 HP? That would be 400 HP/Liter, at least twice the hot racing engines of today.

Maybe I just missed the joke.