Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Posts

MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#1

JL

MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

JL

>I usually get veneer core plywood. Why would I want MDF core? Is there any particular use where it might excel?

TIA

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#2

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Fred Davis

>The only reasons I can think of for MDF besides trimming out closet shelves is, if your planning on a lot of Veneer work or Plastic laminating, they both need the flattest possible surface.

Plywood . sadly is not what it used to be . flat wise or thickness quality control..

But for Kitchen and cabinet work , it still is the material of choice for strength to weight ratio.

For instance in my Cabinet shop there is no Particle board or MDF.

That is my own personable view of it , one not likely to change either.

FredD

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#3

I was surprised to hear

Nathan

>I asked the guys at the cabinet shop where I work about the difference between particle board and MDF. Now I know that's not exactly what you were asking about but I thought I'd share anyway, because the answers surprised me:

1. MDF is heavier (by volume) than particle board

2. MDF is more brittle (chips more easily) than particle board

3. screws don't hold as well in MDF as they do in particle board

At this particular shop, they only use MDF for cabinets that are painted. All veneering is done over particleboard. Keep in mind, this shop is in Europe, but I've found that particleboard, MDF and plywood are the same on both sides of the pond. Laminboard is more common here - never seen it in the U.S.

MDF undoubtedly does have advantages. As I understand it, MDF can be machined and shaped yet still retain a very smooth surface eminently suitable for painting. A lot of kitchen cabinet doors these days are made out of it.

By the way, I completely agree with Fred... I wouldn't make any particleboard or MDF cabinets for my own house. I intend to use laminboard for our kitchen cabinets, when I do get around to making them.

(Did I mention my wife is a saint? She's been waiting for the new kitchen for years and is still willing to wait even longer for me to finish my apprenticeship and then get my shop configured properly.)

Nathan

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#4

Well, not exactly right,

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>I can buy different weights, grades and brands of each. I can get MDF in a lighter weight, but it is a good bit softer, and the edges need more prep to paint.

There is some exterior grade MDF which is a very nice product to work with, although it cost more.

I think the industrial grade of particle-board is the heaviest and hardest in my area.

Like some of the others of you, I resisted using it, but have found there are times when it is fine to use, if you learn to work with the drawbacks.

I don't like to use either for products like furniture that is likely to be moved, like furniture. For built-in, paint grade, it is hard to beat MDF.

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#5

Bart Goldberg

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Bart Goldberg

>In some cases you may only be able to find the type of plywood your looking for in MDF core. That was my experience when I was looking for quarter sawn oak ply. The material I bought was exceptional and had great figure in it. I would not hesitate to buy it again. Of course, your application may dictate that you need veneer core versus mdf core.

Regards

Bart

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#6

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Bart, I just used some QS W Oak, which had MDF under the face, but plys for the inside core veneers. I guess that gives the best of both mediums.

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#7

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco------WebKitFormBo

>I've seen it that way too.

In the thinner grades, the MDF core is what's readily available with the nicer veneers. I use it for door panels for smaller kitchen cabinets.

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#8

Bart Goldberg

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Bart Goldberg

>Cool! - how was the figure on the veneer face?

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#9

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Some was pretty good, but some was rift. All were very narrow ~ 4" wide veneers.

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

#10

Re: MDF Core versus Veneer Core plywood

Alex Grigoriev

>Is it what's called Medium Density Overlay?