Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Posts

Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#1

Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Nandy

>I am in the market for a 10" contractors table saw and a 12" miter saw. I am fairly new to the game and would like to stay under $1000 for both. Appreciate any suggestions - brands, what I should look for in a saw and where to get the best price.

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#2

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Lewis Dodd

>Buy one of mine!!!!IMO---forget the contractors saw ( I have three mothballed ) and go for a cabinet saw with as much horse power you can afford and a quality fence..Biesemer and the fox are suggestions. Get the same size blade on both(10" at least) This will easily blow your $1000.00 budget but you will never regret it. A sliding compound miter can cost almost as much as the cabinet saw. These look nice but my simple Makita 10" suits my needs. Unless portable is needed, I use my radial arm saw or the cabinet saw for my serious miters. Good luck-check the pawn shops but try them out!!!!

Lewis

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#3

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Tony - Memphis

>I used a Delta contractor's saw for ten years. Sure, it had its issues, but I built a lot of projects using that saw. You can probably find a good used one. I've used and own a few Jet products and have been very happy with those. I have one Grizzly product that,while I'll never do busines with them again, I have been happy with. I've noticed that a lot of folks have been real happy with the Griz cabinet saw 1023? Not sure of the price of those, but that might be a good value. If you buy used, be sure and read up on what to look for. Even for particular models. Make sure it is a model you can still get parts for. My old saw, for example, you buy a switch at any hardware and Delta still sells all the other parts that typically fail on those (not that they fail often). Also, some of the woodworking rags have tool evaluation articles pretty often. You can probably find on on contractor's saws. You can search their databases online and maybe find the articles at the library.

AS for the miter saw, I've been using a Hitachi 10" slider for many years. Never had any issues with performance. I don't like or trust the detents, but I don't rely on stuff like that anyway. It has been a really good saw. Not everyone needs a slider (I really didn't). I use it mostly for rough cuts anyway.

Something else you need to consider is what you are going to use the saws for. I mostly work with 4/4 or less and I build furniture. I had a hard time getting real accuracy from my Delta, but some folks have gotten extreme accuracy/repeatability from them, so it CAN be done.

So, I don't think you can go wrong with any of the major brands. Maybe the Christmas sales will help you out. I bought my new saw when Woodcraft had a 10% off sale (no local dealers here).

Good luck and enjoy your new toys. If this is your first time with these tools, please do some reading, watch some videos (Kelly Mehler, for one), etc. Using these tools safely is not intuitive. Classes are a great way to learn too.

Tony

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#4

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw *LINK*

mdclor

>I agree that a cabinet saw with 3hp would be the best choice, but look at the table saws on Grizzly.com for ones that might be closer to your budget. They make good value (price + quality) products. As far as what to look for, check the books section here for The Table Saw Book, 2nd Ed. by Kelly Mehler.

It might be worthwhile to start with a good TS and get the miter saw later. You can cross cut with a TS, but you can't rip with a miter saw.

You can also watch Craig's list or estate sales for tools in your area.

Personally, I prefer to buy quality once.

HTH,

Merle


Grizzly Table Saws

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#5

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

steve mackay

>I've got a Griz G0575 after burning up three "C-word" saws in ten years. Only had it a year and noth'n but love so far. Have a small shop so hacked off the fence rails even with the top extensions. I think the biggest up-grade in it was belt drive with that big, honk'n motor hang'n out the back. Light years ahead of direct drive. Of course the cast iron top rates off the scale opposed to cast aluminum. Yes, Virginia, HEAVIER IS BETTER ! Industrial quality at poor man's prices.

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#6

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Nandy,

All good advice. Since you mentioned you are new to all of this, you may not yet know your precise needs. I do agree that a cabinet saw is most desirable, I would be remiss in saying a good contractor's saw is all I really ever needed. I built nearly all the furniture in my home with a Jet 10" Contractor's saw. I now own a hybrid--a nice saw with some features my old one didn't have. As a saw, however, it isn't any better. My old Jet 10" was perfect. Period. You may not need the more expensive cabinet saw.

As was mentioned about the miter saw, the Hitachi is excellent. I have one. Mine is the smaller 7 1/2" slider. I build mostly furniture, and seldom need the extra capacity of a 10" or 12" model.

Also bear in mind that your table saw will effectively cross cut if you employ a sled for that purpose. Shop made sleds for cross cutting and dado work are what I use. There are many opportunities to buy high quality used tools on Craig's List. If you find one, make sure you check it out with a friend familiar with that type of tool. Also, make sure that the fence is a Biesemeyer/clone.

George

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#7

Clint Searl

Hitachi 12" SCMS

Clint Searl

>

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#8

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Jim Dillon

>Andy,

I agree with much of the good advice you've gotten. I originally purchased a 10-inch Hitachi SCMS and it has been a real workhorse especially where portability is needed for home improvement projects. At the time (15 years ago) many contractors in my area used the 7-1/2 Hitachi SCMS. Nowadays, there are many good brands of SCMS available; they are not inexpensive though and actually take up a fairly large footprint (front-to-rear), something to consider if shop space is an issue. And dust collection with a SCMS can be problematic.

However, after I got my 10-inch cabinet saw, I used my SCMS much less - especially after I built several TS sleds. So, I would say use the money you would spend on a SCMS, and buy a 10-inch cabinet saw. For value, many here think highly of Grizzly and JET. If you are really hot to have a SCMS, then a 10-incher would be the max I would recommend and actually would lean toward a 7-1/2 incher. Or use the money (plus a little extra) for a drill press or bandsaw. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#9

I agree with Jim's advice

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>as well as much of the others', too.

I was with my dad the day he bought a Delta 9" contractor's saw back in 1964. It's the only table saw I've ever had, and it has been mine since 1981. It has produced most of the furniture in my house, as well as my kids' furniture, too.

About 7-8 years ago I ended up doing some custom work and as a result had some money burning a hole in my pocket. So I got myself a Makita 1013 SCMS that I just NEEDED to have. But the truth is, as good as it is, I use it mostly for breaking down lumber into manageable lengths. You can do that with a circular saw. I could easily get along without mine. Besides that, it takes up valuable space in my very small shop.

Get a good contractor's saw and build some custom sleds for the TS. Don't get the mier saw. Then take some of the money you'll save by not getting the miter saw and buy yourself a really good miter for the TS.

Bruce, getting along just fine in MN

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#10

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

Chuck in ND

>What you want to look for in a Contractor's saw, or any tablesaw for that matter is a good fence such as a Biesemeyer fence, a Delta Unifence, Vega, or a Delta T2 fence. Powermatic, Delta, Jet, General, and Grizzly are pretty well known brands, and I would look at those saws. As far as the best price, I'll leave that up to you to find. Amazon isn't a bad place to look at customer reviews.

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#11

I beg to disagree with a few others if you

North of the Border

>are a beginner and look for advice with your $1000 in mind. I'm not saying a 3 HP cabinet saw is no good but I don't think any beginner woodworker really needs it - unless money is not an issue, which isn't the case here. When I look at what projects most beginner woodworkers do, I don't even know why they need a 3 HP TS at all. It's like telling a new driver to get a 350 HP car if he has the money while his objective is mainly to pick up good driving skill. I would recommend these: Get a Rigid TS contractor saw for about $500 - $600 at Home depot and spend $200 or so on a Dewalt mitre saw (10"). There might be some money left for a dust collector. Rigid's new granite top TS would cost a little more. But the cast iron top version works just great. For a new beginner, little difference will a cabinet saw make as compared to a contractor saw. If money were not an issue, the discussion would have been different.

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#12

Re: I beg to disagree with a few others if you

Nat Robison

>I think I'm in agreement here but don't disagree with the opinions regarding the necessity of a miter saw.....it all depends what you want to do.

If we're talking about a beginner here, get a Ridgid or similar TS and find out if you like and/or are any good at woodworking. It would serve very well for at least a few years or until a certain competence was attained. If your needs warrant it, you can sell the first saw for a few hundred dollars and upgrade. Many posters here talk about how they used a $150 Craftsman TS for 30 years before they bought a better saw and I'm assuming the pieces they made with their first saw still turned out well.

As far as the Miter saw goes, I have a 10" DeWalt that cost about $200 and I'm glad I have it. I'm not a pro so I don't need a 12" or slider. I have, though, cut lots of door moldings/baseboard and finished 2 basements and wouldn't want to do that with just a TS.

Spend $400-$600 on a decent TS and use the rest for some basic hand tools, layout tools, or a router. If you're just building furniture for now, you can live without the Miter Saw. If you want to start renovating your house, get the Miter Saw.

Re: Shopping for table saw & Miter Saw

#13

Re: I beg to disagree with a few others if you

Chuck in ND

>I guess I feel this way, the guy asked about a Contractor's saw So thats the info I gave him. I've been a woodworker for close to 30 years, mostly as a hobby that I luv to do. I've had a Delta 34-445X Contractor's tablesaw ( 34-444 with a mobile base and Unifence ) since I bought it new in 1995 and it's all I've really needed. I think they key is don't throw a cheap blade in it, not that you have to throw an insanely amount of money on a blade, just don't buy cheap. I think the other thing we all need to remember is that with a cabinet saw, most people may not have access to the power they need to run one in their shop, so that can be an expense right off the bat. As far as a mitersaw goes, it's a must in my shop. I very rarely do any crosscuting on the tablesaw. I think I have better control of the board on a mitersaw, which inturn makes it safer and produces a better cut for me. Everyone has their own way of doing things.