Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Computer failure question? (OT)

Posts

Computer failure question? (OT)

#1

Computer failure question? (OT)

Barry Irby

>I posted some of it before but I want to know.

Took my computer to the shop because it said ConfigSys file could not be found. Tried to fix it myself but failed. The shop returned the computer after two days, but Internet Explorer 7 would not work. Back to the shop. Three or four days later they returned it, but declared the hard drive had fialed progressivly while in the shop. They replaced it under warranty, because it was less than a year old. The tech was complaining bitterly that four other computers had had hard drive failures sitting on the bench because they went to Microsoft to get software updates. Another had suffered a mother board failure.

I had also taken in a laptop that Said "can not find operating system". When they tried to replace the harddrive, the screen failed.

I am not a happy camper. They seem to think it falls into the "stuff happens" catagory. I am ticked that I took in two computers and both failed worse while there. I can not imagine that four hard drives failed simultaniously. Unless there is something going on in the shop itself.

Anybody got any thoughts?

(PS. The tech thought it might have something to do with the launch of Windows 7)

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#2

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Sounds hinky to me. I can't imagine software updates causing a hard drive failure like that. I would think it would take a pretty malicious, targeted virus to do that--one that goes far beyond just erasing the contents, boot sector or file allocation table.

As for the laptop, if the screen went dead while they were messing around inside, I would say it likely falls on them. I would wonder if they don't have some sort of electrical issue in their building, or aren't properly grounding themselves (wrist straps, touching the power supply after opening the case, etc.) before working on the units.

Jason

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#3

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>I am not a computer expert by a long shot but sounds to me like a case of not being able to dazzle you with his brilliance so he will baffle you with his BULLS--T.

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#4

Sounds like BS to me

Dustmaker Mike

>I have been working around computers for a little while. What I do know is each Hard Drive MFG has it's own self test to see if the hard drive is good or bad. Did the shop use the MFG test to check the drive? If not then I have seen a lot of software cause problems but the hard drive is still good. I use the MFG test to reformat the drive and then reload the software. Windows is a crappy program but I have not seen it kill a hard drive.

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#5

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

Chuck W

>That story sounds fishy to me. How many computers does he repair weekly?

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#6

Sounds perfectly reasonable

Curly Smith

>I'm in the minority but when I read the second sentence my thought was "pending hard drive failure".

The progression of problems is what happens when a drive slowly fails. The drive has a bad sector, corrupts a file, you fix the problem, something else goes wrong, you fix that problem and keep going until the drive either fails or you recognize the real problem.

The four drives didn't fail because of the MS updates, they were failing anyway. The updates simply wrote data in bad areas of the drive.

The shop needs to invest in some drive diagnostic software, collect serial numbers and contact the drive company about manufacturing defects.

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#7

Whoa! Happened to me this week... and to others.

Scott in Montana

>My laptop had just finished downloading Windows updates and asked to restart to complete the updates. I let it restart and it came up with an error message of "can not read from drive, press control, alt, delete to try again", or something to that sort. I took it into the computer repair shop along with my copy of XP thinking they might need it for the repair. I was called yesterday and told the my hard drive was "toast". When I picked it up another young tech told me that they had experienced a run of bad hard drives after updating.

Now I'm not the conspiricy type, but after reading this I will investigate the condition of my old hard drive further. While I don't think Microsoft, Adobe, or any of the other companies who have frequent updates would intentionally install a bug, they might have. If the hard drive upon further formatting and reinstallation is not corrupt, then they must have changed something in the addressing.

This will be interesting to track down.

Scott in Montana

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#8

Re: Whoa! Happened to me this week... and to other

Curly Smith

>One thing that I neglected to mention above is that sometimes the updates will result in a catastrophic operating system failure because the update is incompatible with the BIOS or you have an incompatible driver. It can look like a drive failure but the remedy is reformatting the drive and reinstalling the operating system with the proper BIOS and driver updates. However, if you're running a repair shop there's no money in that fix since you can't sell a drive and you risk getting the PC back if the drive actually does fail.

Microsoft is aware of the problem and always advises you to backup your system before installing the update. It's in the warning that virtually nobody reads and even fewer heed (the only times that I follow the warning is when installing the Service Packs).

Have the shop partition the drive as two drives. Put the OS and programs on one drive and your data on the second. By doing so you can reinstall the OS without loss of data. It also makes your backup scheme a lot easier.

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#9

I agree with Curly... but more information...

Scott in Montana

>I have just returned from Staples to get a Blackberry cable and looked at the empty shelves where the SATA hard drives normally sit. I asked the resident computer geek if they were having a run on hard drives and he confirmed that the number has been way up but didn't know if it was out of line since he didn't know about the number of laptops sold over the last couple years. A reasonable answer.

He checked their service shelves and saw that there are four laptops in with the same symptoms. An epidemic? Who knows. I think most likely it ties to the fact that laptop numbers are up and quality is down. A conspiricy would be much more fun!

In most BIOS there is a drive section where you select which drive to boot from; some people's problems could originate here. One of the options is to reset to factory specification and that should solve most peoples boot address problems.

Scott in Montana

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#10

Ellis Walentine

Possible connection

Ellis Walentine

>My wife's one year old Dell somehow "lost" the hard drive (SATA). We thought all her stuff (not well backed up) was gone. The short story is that I bought a little SATA/USB conversion box and the new drive read all the content of the old drive without a hitch. That was a revelation to me.

Ellis

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#11

SCSI Rules, SATA Drools ;-)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#12

Re: SCSI Rules, SATA Drools ;-)

Alexander Grigoriev

>My $150 2TB SATA drive (sustained transfer rate >120 MB/s) can run circles around your $300 0.3TB SAS drive with >100MB/s STR.

Re: Computer failure question? (OT)

#13

Re: SCSI Rules, SATA Drools ;-)

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Well Alexander, you may be correct. The last time I installed a SCSI card it was a 160 MHz Adaptec. That was because the Intel motherboard couldn't handle the 320 cards.

I have used SCSI for 15 years and and never had a disk or card failure. I am quite happy with my current config, and for what I do, it is just fine.

Enjoy your toys,

Ken