Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

offshore machines created equal

Posts

offshore machines created equal

#1

offshore machines created equal

mike mcnerney

>Are offshore machines created equal? I am probably going to buy a thickness sander 13 to 25", 800 to 1500 bucks. For example General international is more expensive than king or craftex, is it any better just because it has the'general' name?

MM

Re: offshore machines created equal

#2

Ellis Walentine

Not really

Ellis Walentine

>I can't speak to the decision you're trying to make about a thickness sander, but there can be major differences between machines, even ones that are made in the same factories. I had the privilege of touring a couple dozen factories and assembly plants in Taichung, Taiwan -- then the capital of eastern rim machinery manufacturing -- in the late '90s, so I've seen how they operate. Since then, much of the production has moved to mainland China, but the same principles apply.

It all has to do with the level of control a "manufacturer" (e.g., Steel City, General International, Delta, Jet, Grizzly, etc.) have over quality control at both the parts production and assembly levels. Companies that maintain a ground presence at the source are better able to demand an acceptable level of quality all up and down the production process. Often, the parts for different manufacturers' machines are made in the same factories. Many times, parts --even entire machines -- are identical and interchangeable, just with different color paint. But, the quality indicators, such as metallurgy, accuracy of machining, tolerances, etc., are not easy to see or enforce without having qualified QC personnel there to keep a close eye on things.

So, the answer is yes; there can be a difference and often is. The trouble is that it may be hard to notice without getting quite technical. In the absence of good technical tool reviews, you have to rely on user satisfaction reports, which often point out a lot of good information that you might not have thought of. And, of course, there is the manufacturer's reputation. These guys have a lot invested in their brands, and they are serious about giving you good quality and good service after the sale. It's usually a good idea to buy from a reputable company.

How's that for a non-answer? I hope somebody else can weigh in with specific experience with the brands you're considering.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: offshore machines created equal

#3

User reviews

Rod Peterson * Ormond Beach

>> In the absence of good technical tool reviews, you have to rely on user satisfaction reports, which often point out a lot of good information that you might not have thought of.

While it's certainly true that user reports can produce good data from the field, I tend to discount them as measures of quality as the probability of "owner's bias" is too powerful to ignore. Someone who has just spent $1K on a tool wants that tool to be everything he had hoped for. He does not want to learn he has made a mistake (particularly after a considerable amount of research of user reviews in his own quest). I've found user reviews to be far too influenced (however subtly) by the fact that the user owns the equipment.

Similarly, I've found a great deal of negative reviews to be from users who appear to be habitual gripers (thus not reliable reviewers), users who had bad peripheral service not directly related to the product (shipping problems, vendor problems), or misguided purchasers dissatisfied with the sander they thought would joint or the saw they thought would shape. A large grain of salt is needed when sorting through user reviews. So much so that, in my view, they are the least reliable of the research tools.

Rod

Re: offshore machines created equal

#4

That leaves only one surefire method

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>That leaves only one surefire method.....

Buy the machine, use it and make your own judgement.

I've been doing that for decades ;)

... and have run out of money and room in my shop :(

Happy Woodworking!

Re: offshore machines created equal

#5

Re: Culture Conflict

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The Asian factories are capable of making any level of quality. Their outlook is that quality is the responsibility of the customer, and thus, they will work to the customer's specifications. If the customer orders "cheap" that's what they get. If you want the highest quality, you write your specifications accordingly, but be ready to pay the higher price. This is very different from US/Canadian plants, where quality is a base line, and competition is on features, design, and service.

Companies who have built their reps on IQ and service will be the ones to look for because they, regardless of where the iron is poured, have a vested interest in quality.

Just remember, "quality don't come cheap" so shop price at your own risk. A few hundred bucks can (but not necessarily will) make a big difference.

Re: offshore machines created equal

#6

Re: offshore machines created equal

Dick Coers

>I had always wondered how the quality reports from different users could range from great to horrible on the same Chinese product. I then read a report on high factory employee turnover. Once an employee reaches a good skill level in one factory, the best way for them to get a raise was to then quit and get a better job in another factory. There are many people waiting for a job, so the plant owners just hire another person, but they are not skilled. So the quality goes down until they are trained, then the process repeats..........That's what the report said.

Re: offshore machines created equal

#7

Re: offshore machines created equal No!

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>Simple answer, No, offshore look a likes are not all created equal.

You have to know what you are buying.

If you can buy it from a known local distributor who will stand behind his products you are way ahead of the game, and I think that is worth probably 15% or more on top of �the lowest price on the web, also for machines the shipping costs need to be considered, pickup or delivery from a local distributor is a lot easier than arranging with freight haulers and so fourth, so depending on your location this can be more or less of an issue.

Talk to everyone you can who has any experience with the particular machine you are looking at.

You need to be able to qualify the opinions of the �reviewer� too.. A strangers review on the internet is not the same as a trusted friend, consider the source of the information.

Research the particular machine, try it out if you can arrange it, and search the web for any and all info.

The bottom line is only you can decide what a particular machine is worth to you.

I have had good experiences with Delta machinery, but I would also expect good service from Delta because it is built into the price of the machines.

I have also had good experiences with Grizzly, but I took a ride out to the Grizzly store to look the machine over before I bought it. Grizzly also maintains a US inventory of spare parts, and I�ve spoken to knowledgeable service reps over the phone at Grizzly as well.

I am very happy with a YorkCraft machine, but it was purchased from Wilke Machinery, at the time a very reputable company, who is sadly is no longer around.

My take is that only you can evaluate a machines suitability for the tasks you will use it for.

It also depends on your abilities and tolerances for tuning adjusting and even modifying a particular machine to suit your needs.

Caveat emptor.

Re: offshore machines created equal

#8

Buy ON shore *LINK*

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>The folks at Wood Master in Kansas City MO. USA have been having some deep discount sales due the recession.

ALL Wood Master machines are made in Kansas City, even their spiral-head planer heads. They also use Baldor motors that are also made in the USA.

You can find sanders from 26" up to 50 inches. Their combination planer/sander machines range from 12 to 25".

It only takes a couple minutes to check them out,

Ken....


Wood Master