Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Posts

Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#1

Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Douglas Bram

>Refinished an interior antique stair case and looking for advice on best finish for top rail. The top rail is a dense wood (cherry or maple??) that now has a dark (Ebony) color. What is best choice for a satin finish, oil or polyurethane? If oil which oil, Danish or Tung? If poly, is Minwax wipe-on poly an adequate choice?

Thanks for your help.

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#2

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Tony - Memphis

>Well, its hard to know what exactly is in a given product. Most of the "oils" are really oil varnish blends. Those offer a decent amount of protection, but for something that is used as much as a handrail, I'd go with a poly. I've used the MinWax products and been very happy with them. I can't vouch for the durability over time, but they are easy to apply and I assume they will last. Another consideration is what is already there. Another poly that I really like is the Rockler Gel poly. There have been some articles in FWW recently about the wipe on poly's and I belive the MinWax has gotten some good nods. And, you can buy it at any big box, so that's a plus.

Tony

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#3

Clint Searl

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Clint Searl

>Waterborne poly, especially floor finish, works well.

Clint

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#4

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Douglas,

I would wipe poly on it, and buff with steel wool. Stairs and banisters receive constant wear and you need tough stuff to protect it.

George

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#5

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Douglas Bram

>Thanks George, with poly, what is your thought on chips and nicks over time vs. an oil like Danish or Tung?

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#6

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

Douglas Bram

>Thanks Tony,

With poly, what is your thought on chips and nicks over time vs. an oil like Danish or Tung?

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#7

I wouldn't worry about it.

Nat Robison

>I wouldn't worry too much about chips and nicks on a railing....they don't generally get the abuse (from things that nick and chip) that floors and furniture do. I would go with wipe-on poly. It will dry relatively quickly and provide good protection. You could probably do 2-3 coats per day depending on your drying conditions.

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#8

Agree.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#9

Re: Agree.

Douglas Bram

>Hey George,

OK, so I can't go wrong with a poly wipe on the stair hand rail. To be true, I was hoping someone would talk me into the Danish oil or Tung oil since I already have them handy. If I do use the oil rather than the polyurethan wipe on, are there problems down the road. Can the homeowner maintain with a wax, furniture oil or polish. I sure do like the hand rubbed oil finish I use on my other furniture. This is the first stairs I have refinished and the house is 100 years old with beautiful old wood.

Thanks for your input.

Re: Stair rail, oil vs. polyurethane

#10

Re: Agree.

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Douglas,

Sure you can finish with oil. Its going to require more maintenance because it won't stand up to constant handling. The finish will wear and becomne dirty. Of course, you can remove the grime with a mild detergent, scotch brite or steel wool, and re-oil. With poly you get something more wear resistant and also easy to clean. You won't have to do more than clean it for a long time. I favor poly--but you CAN use oil: its your choice.

George