Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

Posts

Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#1

Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Hopefully, a few of the things I picked up can help others.

I had my brother, who is much better at all things eletrical, come down to help me wire up some new circuits and receptacles. We discovered a few things:

1) I had 20A breakers but only 15A receptacles - while not the end of the world, it is a potential problem. If I would pull 20A through the receptacle, it could catch fire.

2) A garage is considered a wet environment, so I needed to add some GFIs. Put it at the start of each run and it can protect 3 downstream items. Alternate solution is to use GFI breakers, or make the 100A breaker to the sub panel GFI (nice, but very expensive)

3) I wasn't leaving enough spare wire in the sub panel - didn't need to fix right away, but good reason to junction with longer wires in the future. Very useful in case you need to move a breaker.

4) Larger boxes, plus receptacles with clamp connecters are way easier to wire up.

5) Klein makes electrical tools that will really simplify your life - the screwdriver that can bend a perfect loop is sweet.

6) Have a good working plan, such as mount all boxes, then run wires, then hook up each receptacles, then wire into sub panel. Makes the work go fast. Can help with the purchasing and limit extra runs to the home store.

So, I now have 4 new circuits, a 220 for the jointer with it's own special plug, a 20A with 3 receptacles (first being GFI), then 2 more 20A GFI circuits and receptacles mounted right off the sub that will serve as the start for future runs. It's enough for now. I also went around to all my tools and grabbed the volts and amps off each so I can make a chart which I'll leave in the shop to easily identify what things I can run together. After doing that, I'm amazed I haven't tripped breakers or fried any receptacles.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#2

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Stuart Johnson

>1) I had 20A breakers but only 15A receptacles - while not the end of the world, it is a potential problem. If I would pull 20A through the receptacle, it could catch fire.

I don't follow this one. A 20 amp plug (5-20P or 6-20P) will not fit a 5-15R or 6-15R receptacle. I don't think you have a problem if the wire is correct for the breaker.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#3

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I have to admit I can't quote the type numbers, but there are twenty amp duplex receptacles that are identical in appearance to the "cheepies" at the local home center and Wally World. Close examination will show that they are a little beefier, but other than that anything that will plug into an 89 cents receptacle will plug into them as well.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#4

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Rick Christopherson

>


1) I had 20A breakers but only 15A receptacles - while not the end of the world, it is a potential problem. If I would pull 20A through the receptacle, it could catch fire.


The NEC permits 15 amp receptacles on 20 amp circuits, which is why you rarely even see 20 amp receptacles outside of commercial work. It is not a fire hazard, as the internal components of the outlets are the same. The only difference between a NEMA 5-15 and 5-20 is the horizontal blade (resulting in the sideways "T") on the 5-20 receptacle.

Also, you made is sound as though you were limited to having no more than 3 GFI protected outlets downstream from the GFI device. I am not sure if this is what you meant, but you can have more than 3. On a similar note, while you hadn't mentioned it, the NEC does not make any limitation on the number of outlets on the same circuit.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#5

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>The problem here is that the receptacle was rated for less than the wire and breaker could carry. So, if I plugged in 2 tools each with a 10A draw, I could pull 20A, which the receptacle can't handle, but the breaker and wire are more than happy to send. In other words, the receptacle could fail before the breaker would trip. I will often run a router and shop vac together, and their combined load is near 20A.

I just wanted to say that the lesson I picked up was to size everything on your runs appropriately. I could have also fixed the problem by switching to a 15A breaker in the panel.

Hope that helps!

Steve

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#6

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Thanks! I did not know that about the 15-20 receptacles. I guess I just went a little higher than I needed, which is not really a bad thing. That does explain why my existing setup was fine, even though I determined I was pulling more amps than the recpetacle could handle.

As for the GFI protecting just 3 circuits - that was what I thought. If it can protect more, that is good to know in case I want to add anymore downstream receptacles.

When I decided on the number of receptacles and layout, I tried to make sure I wouldn't put too many tools on any one circuit. In a one man garage shop, it's not really a big deal (how many routers can I run at once?). I went with receptacles at 4 foot intervals just to limit the amount of extension cords or power strips.

Thanks again. Good stuff here.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#7

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You won't be harmed by having 20 amp receptacles, which were probably also a higher grade of receptacle. Shop outlets get tools plugged and unplugged a lot more often than household receptacles get lamps, etc. plugged/unplugged, and the higher grade of receptacle will probably last longer.

I just rewired my shop, and the cost difference between 20A receptacles and spec grade 15A was all but nonexistent.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#8

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Hey Stephen,

I like the fact that you went with the 20A receptacles and especially the GFI's. Well done.

Also, having the right tools is great, isn't it? I've learned from the help from others that that simple advise can be half the battle.

Probably the biggest item is your plan of attack. A well executed plan such as yours probably saved hours on install. I learned this as well from my brother-in-law. Place your boxes, rough wire taking care to check your cicuit loads, wire in receptacles....and lastly, into the circuit box.

Congrats!!! Sounds as though your happy. :-)

Ray

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#9

Nothing wrong with that....

John in NM

>At least in a residential situation. I thought it was a fairly well known aspect of electrical codes that you can use multiple 15 amp duplex outlets on a 20 amp circuit. Kitchens, dining rooms, baths and laundry rooms are all places this is typically done. I will go hunt down the chapter section and paragraph if someone insists.

Home shops are always a little funny, as they are a cross between light industrial an dresidential. When in doubt, or even if it just makes you feel better, use the 20 amp outlets.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#10

About the 3 recepticals...

John in NM

>Could be some confusion over applying a rule in the IRC that limits kitchen circuits to 4 recepticals. May be in NEC too, I don't know, my local authority uses IRC, which has some rules not in the NEC. Just a guess, word of mouth and the internet tend to garble these things.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#11

Configured not the same as "rated"

Rod Peterson * Ormond Beach

>> The problem here is that the receptacle was rated for less than the wire and breaker could carry. So, if I plugged in 2 tools each with a 10A draw, I could pull 20A, which the receptacle can't handle, but the breaker and wire are more than happy to send. In other words, the receptacle could fail before the breaker would trip. I will often run a router and shop vac together, and their combined load is near 20A.

Stephen, your post to which I'm responding was written within minutes of Rick C's response which addresses your concerns about the 15A receptacles. However, I saw expressions similar to yours several places in the thread, so I'd like to reinforce what Rick said as well as recast the wording a little to make it clearer.

A 15A receptacle isn't "rated" for 15A as in "only capable of 15A". It is configured for a NEMA 15A plug, in other words, two parallel vertical blades. It is configured that way to prevent a 20A device (with an appropriate 20A configured plug) from being plugged into what might be a 15A circuit (14 gauge wire, 15A breaker). In fact, however, that circuit could legitimately have been wired with a 20A breaker and 12 gauge wire.

The NEMA configuration for a 20A plug (one vertical, one horizontal blade) prevents a 20A device from being plugged into a NEMA x-15 receptacle, even if it is a 20A circuit. In household wiring, it's typical to see a hybrid receptacle on 20A circuits which will accept both NEMA 15A and 20A plugs.

As Rick said, the internals of the 15A and 20A receptacles are identical. They are essentially sized (rated) for a 20A load, but are configured differently to prevent a properly plugged 20A load from being plugged into what might be a 15A circuit.

One more way of saying all of this is that you can't visually tell from looking at a 15A receptacle whether it's fed with 14 gauge or 12 gauge wire. Either would be legitimate, correct, and in accordance with the NEC.

By the way, the NEC exception which permit the "15A receptacle on a 20A circuit" also applies, I believe, to both 120V and 240V circuits.

One final thing, you can also get 20A receptacles with the NEMA 20A configuration only (again, both in 120V and 240V devices).

Rod
Addy Protocol: experienced amateur electrician

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#12

Re: About the 3 recepticals...the IRC and NEC

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>Unfortunately I'd have to agree John. I've read some of "conflicts" between the IRC with the NEC code. It amazes me that everybody can't agree on the same thing. One thing that cracks me up is the term, International Residential Code. :-)

Most often the NEC is adhered to because it's a more detailed code. An good electricain will use both codes. :-)

Ray

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#13

I think its International in the same way as...

John in NM

>The International House of Pancakes ;)

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#14

One federal definition of international

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I used to do the immigration paperwork for faculty at my old university. One of the procedures to get to a green card involved demonstrating that someone had an international reputation in the particular discipline. It was understood among those of us doing these applications that "international" in this context meant, "known inside and outside the U.S." Being well-known in, say, Europe and South America wasn't quite enough; I was always careful to get about a 50/50 mix of reference letters from U.S. and non-U.S. scholars.

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#15

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Richard Jones

>One key thing not touched on here, at least directly, is that the breaker in a panel is sized to protect the wire, not the appliances or the tools or whatever you plug into a receptacle. If you plug something(s) in that is in excess of what the wire is designed to handle, the breaker is supposed to trip. There's nothing in any code, whether it's IBC, IRC, or NEC that can make someone NOT plug in two 20a shop vacs on one 15a circuit. In essence, code can't regulate stupidity, at least after the fact. In this case, the breaker trips, which is what it's supposed to do.

I had a light circuit (15a w/14 ga. wire) at the store that kept tripping. My wife told my delivery driver/weekend sparktrician to put in a bigger breaker (I had a 30a in a drawer) so that the "nuisance" tripping would cease. Luckily, I found out about it before the plan was implemented, and averted a possible disaster. Problem was a wire in a fixture that was nicked, would actually move a bit from the vibration of the ballast.

Rich

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#16

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things!

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Very good addition!

Re: Electrical Update - Learned some good things! long

#17

Re: I think its International in the same way as..

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Only way I'm wired there is due to the amount of coffee I drink!