Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Posts

Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#1

Bart Goldberg

Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Bart Goldberg

>Hi Fellow Dust Makers,

I don't know about you all, but I have found that I increasing use epoxy for many of my projects. I typically buy 2 part epoxy, like System 3, in gallon sized containers. This stuff never goes bad like Yellow glue can, although I sometimes need to warm the containers up a bit if they start to crystallize.

Some of the reasons I like epoxy:

1) Long open time - the System 3 brand I'm using has a 20 minute open time.

2) Strongest glue you can use.

3) Does not require significant clamping - Blue painters tape is all that is needed.

4) Does not require tight fitting joints - it will hold your joints together whether they are tight or loose fitting.

5) It acts a a gap filler. Related to item 4 above. In fact, I prefer it over wood fillers. I usually add some saw dust or dye to it when filling in gain, tear out etc.

6) Water proof.

7) Once fully cured, it can be milled and worked just like wood.

One question I have is - does anyone know how various types of epoxy products differ? I recently purchased from Lowes, some Locktite brand 5 minute, 1 to 1 ratio epoxy. While this stuff is great for quick fix use, it does not seem to have the strength of the 2 to 1 ratio, System 3 epoxy I typically use.

Regards

Bart

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#2

I've never much liked the 5 minute varieties...

John in NM

>They seem to stay rubbery and are not as good as some of the longer cure types. Best I've found in 5 minute is from Pacer Technologies (they make a lot of super glue), I buy it at HD.

A mesquite shop I worked for used a lot of West System 2 hour. Great stuff, works well for laminating, vacuum veneering, void filling, etc. Another I've used is Miller Stephenson 907. White, comes in tubes, overnight cure, and about the strongest epoxy I've come accross. Hard to find though, mostly carried by laboratory suppliers. Transtint dye also goes right into this stuff with no ill effects (might even accelerate the cure a bit).

Lately I've been trying to make some cast parts with a urethane resin. Not sure it would work as an adhesive, but it would work for filling voids. Tougher than epoxy, but only has about a 6 month shelf life - less in humid places like FL.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#3

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>You are correct in that it's a great product. A staple of the boat-building industry.

Stay away from the 5 minute epoxies, my experience. They are worthless if you have a pint of the real stuff on-hand. There's some instances where it's worth it, but not many, my opinion.

I think that the best brand is West System. Probably the best product and many many variations for all applications.

I have nothing against System Three, or some of the others, but living off of Lake Erie, and having plenty of boat-building friends, that's the brand that they stake their livelihood on.

Of course, the downside is cost. There are plenty of applications where wood glue will do the job, and there's no reason for expense of epoxy.

Most of the time wood glue is all that you need, but it's really really nice to have a pint of good epoxy on-hand

(same goes for a beer - always nice to have a good pint on-hand)

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#4

Dale Lenz

Re: Most of the 5 minute....

Dale Lenz

>epoxy does dry to a rubber like consistency. Devon 5 min. epoxy dries almost rock hard, sands, files and scrapes great. Use Devon for filling defects most of the time.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#5

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Doug Ridley

>I've been using the 5 min. epoxy for about 15 years and it has always dried to a rock hard finish. It is much stronger than the wood itself and requires no clamping, just hold it together for 3 0r 4 minutes.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#6

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Justin Szeliga

>Epoxy is nice, but the Gougeon Bros. web site lists resin @ $93.00/gallon, & hardener for that size @ about $40.00. Yellow glue is a bit cheaper & plenty strong for so many applications & can be cleaned out of the spreading brush w/soap & water. I've got some of each in my shop.

I keep a tube of 5 minute epoxy on my work truck for small wood repairs, great for a sliver of wood that gets knocked off a piece of trim, & especially to glue a bit of filler wood into a screw hole. I just mix the epoxy on the lid of that mornings coffee cup w/a sliver of cedar shim & jam it in the screw hole, break it off, wait a couple minutes, trim the wood sticking out w/a chisel & drive a screw home. Fixed many a hinge that way.

Peace

Justin

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#7

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Jim Dillon

>Bart,

I am not an epoxy chemist, but suffice it to say that there are likely many variations in the two components that make up the general-use epoxies. These variations include molecular weight (chain length) of the components, chemical structure of each component, number of reactive groups per component, chain branching, etc. Additionally, the exact stoichiometric ratio (the chemical balance between components) of the two components can influence the final properties. Only the manufacturer (or purchaser) of the raw ingredients likely knows what goes into the bucket (and maybe they don't even know); that's why polymer chemists fondly call epoxy chemistry "bucket" chemistry.

Regarding the differeence between "5-minute" epoxy and the "better" stuff, I suspect in the case of the rapidly curing epoxy, the ratio of reactive groups on one component is in slight excess to the other component, thus increasing the likelihood of the second components reactive groups reacting with the first component. Other scenarios are sure possible. The downside to this fast curing reaction is decreased srength - although it may be good enough for the intended purpose. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#8

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Dan Donaldson

>My only real issue with epozy is that I wonder what will happen if any of the joints need repairs in a few years?

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re:One drawback.......

Jesper, Denmark

>It is very sensitive to UV light. The visible part of any epoxy must be protected with paint or?.....

To answer Dan's un-doing statement, it can be "unglued" with application of heat, but that is not so practical with wood joints.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#10

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Doug Ridley

>Forgot-- I only use it for small repairs. I use Titebond for most everything else.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#11

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>Bart, I am a strong believer in epoxy as well. I started out using West brand, then switched to System 3, which I liked better, then went to FCI about twenty years ago, mainly because of price. It is ~ $30 per gallon. I like the fact that the one I use is a 1 - 1 ratio. Rather than dealing with pumps, I keep cheap cups of various size around to measure and mix in, and the ratio is not very sensitive.

I would not make the claim that epoxy is as strong as strong as yellow glue for edge gluing, because it doesn't penetrate the cell walls like water born adhesives do. It needs some physical texture to grab onto.

Here is a link to my source. http://www.fgci.com/

Just because it is cheaper, doesn't mean that it is not as good. They probably just don't spend as much trying to advertise to small users, but are geared more to large industrial users.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#12

Epoxy - The Speciality Product

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I use it on occasion for special situations, some of which you enumerate. I like the 5 min stuff for quick hold-in-place of things that will later be permanently fastened with screws, etc.

Vastly cheaper, quick to tack, stronger than wood, "yellow" glue ( or hide for the traditionalists) performs adequately, to more superior, for most wood working applications- gluing panels, mortise and tenon, dovetails. If one finds these operations difficult with yellow glue a better solution would be to learn better gluing technique than searching for a different adhesive.

For filling I find cyano acrylate adhesive better mainly because of the quick cure and its ability to wet and penetrate the wood dust used for filling.

I was at a repair shop recently where the owner faced dealing with a drawer in an 18th century piece that some one had "fixed" by drowning all the joints, including those meant to be floating, in epoxy. The drawer was unfixable and the value of the piece substantially degraded by its new drawer.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#13

"Soft" Epoxy

Ken Krawford

>For those who mentioned that their epoxy was rubbery after curing here's a tip. I also had the same problem which I solved by mixing the resin and hardener for a longer period prior to working. I now take at least 2 minutes of constant stirring and the mixture seems to set quicker and cure rock hard.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#14

Bart Goldberg

Re: "Soft" Epoxy

Bart Goldberg

>Hi Ken,

I agree with you here. I have found that if I do not thoroughly mix the epoxy, it can get rubbery. I always mix thoroughly for at least 2 minutes, including scraping the sides to ensure complete consistency.

Bart

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#15

What's the deal with epoxy putty

Jesse Cloud

>I'm an occasional user of epoxy. Always wondered about the sticks of Epoxy 'Putty' you see in the hardware store. Anyone use that stuff? Is it any good? Seems very convenient.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#16

In our shop we....

Howard Acheson

>... used two part, slow set epoxy for many repairs and for all new chair construction. When used for repairs, the old adhesive did not need to be completely removed to get a secure joint. Also, epoxy is gap filling.

Most epoxy is somewhat flexible. This means it works well in a joint that is being flexed. Chairs fall into this category. We made a line of semi-custom dining room chairs for a well known interior designer. We funded some tests of chair joint strength and epoxy was the clear winner. The joint could put up with a small amount of flex without the adhesive or joint failing.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#17

Re: What's the deal with epoxy putty

Doug Ridley

>I use epoxy putty quite often. Wonderful stuff.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#18

Re: "Soft" Epoxy

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I had that problem with those little self mixing squeeze tube ones. Even if the tube says it mixes, you want to put it on a scrap and mix for another minute or two.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#19

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I love using epoxy for all sorts of shop work and repairs. My main use is when making my own knobs for jigs and such. I make handles out of some scraps, drill a hole and then epoxy in a bolt. Works great and I make the knobs any size or length I want. I think I have a 2 part marine epoxy I picked up at Ace - dries rock hard over night.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#20

Re: What's the deal with epoxy putty

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I believe the putty's got some compatible filler to bulk it up.

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#21

Bart Goldberg

I only use it when I knead it.

Bart Goldberg

>

Re: Epoxy - The Wonder Product

#22

Re: What's the deal with epoxy putty

Jim Dillon

>Jesse,

I used the stick epoxy once to fasten a toilet flange bolt into old concrete that had broken off. Twenty years later, the bolt is still solid in the concrete.

Jim