Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Finishing question

Posts

Finishing question

#1

Finishing question

Terry Alexander

>Finishing is by far my weakest area in woodworking.

I am testing some mahogany. We put red mahogany gel stain.

Then....

On 1 piece we put 2 coats of shellac.

On the 2nd piece we put 2 coats of shellac followed by a coat of poly.

We really like the look of the shellac without the poly.

So, what is the purpose of the poly over the shellac? We notice when watching DIY programs and the wisdom of this forum that the "standard" is to finish with poly.

We are "testing" on a vanity for a bathroom, so moisture will be present.

As always....TIA

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Finishing question

#2

Re: Finishing question

Ken Krawford

>Terry, I'm also far from being an expert on finishing but that never keeps me from chiming in!

I believe the purpose of the poly is for protection. The only time I use shellac as a top coat finish is if the piece will receive little wear and tear. In a bathroom, I think you really need the protection that poly provides. If you haven't already done so, consider a satin sheen. Maybe that will avoid the "plastic" appearance that poly sometimes gives.

Re: Finishing question

#3

Re: Finishing question

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Ken is right; the purpose is protection. If you like the shellac look, use an unwaxed shellac and follow with a water-based poly. The water-based poly will not add the yellow/amber color that oil-based poly will and your project will retain the hues you like.

Re: Finishing question

#4

Re: Finishing question

Fred Davis

>Terry, "poly is the standard", who told you that?

If it were me and if your using spray equipment and your worrying about moisture issues in a bath environment, Use CAB Laquer with the reccommended Vinyl sealer underneath ,rather then the Shellac,

Spraying this material is about the only acceptable way of using it for finish.

FredD

Re: Finishing question

#5

equivalence of appearance

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It will be possible to replicate the appearance of shellac with a "urethane" varnish, but not just any urethane varnish. Labeling something as polyurethane has come to mean almost nothing now days. You will need to find some varnish that is gloss, solvent based and you will likely need to thin it before application. The varnish may be more or less yellow so that effect will need to be accounted for with the stain. Actually many use a combination of a reddish stain with a yellow stain on mahogany so all could be well on that account.

In the end the varnish will be vastly more durable in the bathroom application.

Re: Finishing question

#6

Re: Finishing question

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>Don't forget that a bathroom surface will be subject to all sorts of spills.

The worst will be any alcohol based liquids such as perfumes, cough medicines etc. These will play havoc with a shellac finish.

Re: Finishing question

#7

Re: Finishing Answer

Howard Acheson

>Let me make a couple of points. First, dewaxed shellac is the most water vapor resistant one part finish you can use. Shellac that is dewaxed is the only one that should be used if you plan to overcoat it with an oil based poly varnish or any type of waterborne finish.

Second, a non-poly interior varnish is more water and water vapor resistant than a poly varnish or any "spar" varnish. A non-poly varnish is also more clear and gives nicer looking appearance.

For a bathroom item, I would use an initial coat of dewaxed shellac followed by a 2-3 coats of a non-poly interior varnish. That will give you the most durable and best looking finish.