Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Posts

Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#1

Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Doug Ring

>I am in need of replacement windows, with security actually being our primary concern (followed by improved insulation, quieter, etc). This is new to me, so I would appreciate any advise or experience with local or national suppliers/installers of windows.

TIA

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#2

DIY

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>They can be easy to replace. I did 13 in daughters house in part of a day. Ordered from Lowes or Home Depot, can't remember which. Some quality windows can be had with special ordering. Study how you will do the replacement before ordering. In daughters case it was easy and required just some caulk and a custom made trim strip for the inside.

With money you save buy a short, pump 12 ga shot gun and a box of goose loads (#2) to provide additional security.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#3

Clint Searl

Re: DIY

Clint Searl

>Winchester Stainless Police slider 12 ga 18" barrel w/pistol grip.

Clint

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#4

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Pete in Holland, MI

>Windows can be replaced by either: A) replace entire unit, or B)replace window into existing window frame.

A) Yields near original glass area. Requires removal of interior & exterior trim. Requires more work & repair of trim/paint afterwards.

B) Quicker installation. Results in slightly smaller glass area. No rework to interior surfaces. Requires old window frame to be in good shape.

I did the replacement window option. First one took me 4 hours. Last one took a half hour. Very pleased with the results.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#5

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Doug Reynolds in Seattle

>If security is of some concern, most maufactures better lines of windows come standard with two locking devices (latches)and have been tested to a "standard" out of California requiring something like 300 pounds of force in order to defeat the latches. Their entry-level line does not. In addition, you can add security film to the inside of the windows that makes the glass behave more like your car's windshield and "spiderweb" instead of shatter. Sort of like DIY car window tinting. My prefered brand is 3M Window Films (www.3M.com/windowfilm). I'd probably save that option for very vulnerable windows that are in remote locations. Around the Seattle area, the single most common method of entry in a residential burglary is kicking in the front door. The Uniform Building Security Code has standards for door installation that nobody does. I was just at a house whose new doors were installed with just two finish nails per side by a contactor hired by a government entity. Simply using an oversized security strike plate available at the Borg with 3 1/2" #8 wood screws makes booting the door very difficult.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#6

Lots of fraud aout there!

Dave Anderson (PacNW)

>I Had bids ranging from $6000 to $9000. A lot of Window Replacement Co's just cut out the old window, cut the fins off the new window and stick it in with Caulk. It takes about 3 hrs to do a whole house. I replaced my own windows for $1200 and did it the rite way to code. I spent 2 days doing the whole job!

Dave (PacNW)

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#7

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>I am in need of replacement windows, with security actually being our primary concern (followed by improved insulation, quieter, etc). This is new to me, so I would appreciate any advise or experience with local or national suppliers/installers of windows.

Hi Doug.

No expert here, but wanted to pass along what I went through.

When I did a redo of my kitchen 6 or so years ago (I built the cabinets), we wanted the kitchen windows replaced with 'really nice' ones. We went to Pella and bought (and had installed) some of their 'nice' ones - wood with internal blinds.

The installers did a not-so-good of a job installing them and the windows aren't that great. They leak cold air and are a pain to open. I should have known there would be problems when I saw the kids, er, installation men, forcing them into the openings. I should have done it myself.

In the past year I've replaced some of my upstairs windows after ordering custom sizes from Home Depot. They are better than the Pella's at a much lower cost. They open nicely and you can't feel any cold air coming though (I insulated properly in the open cavities). These were the type of replacement windows that fit into the current opening so we did lose some glass space.

Can't help in regards to security. Sorry. But if you have them installed, make sure the job is done to your satisfaction. I didn't. My mistake.

I will be doing (myself) some more windows once the economy allows me to do so.

Good luck.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#8

depends on which state you live

Howard In Toronto

>Be wary of triple-glazed windows because of the light loss.

It's made worse by adding the bug screen if you use those your area.

Many catalogues are misleading - the photos never show screens in place.

Here's a Canadian website - http://www.cwdma.ca/video/index.html.

We don't get the climate extremes you have in the US but the general info they list is very useful.

If you're in CA, check out this company - http://magic-window.com/main.html .

HTH

Howard

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#9

Re: DIY

Doug Ring

>Bill, normally I would be in 100% agreement with you, but in this specific case SWMBO will not tolerate my normally slow pace. I've got a number of companies coming by in the next week to give quotes - what I'm really interested in is what to look out for, and how to determine a reasonable counter-offer.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#10

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

Justin Szeliga

>Another thing to look out for is if you have existing windows w/sash weights. That becomes a 2 1/2" or so wide space next to the sashes that can leak LOTS of air. I did some work a my nieces last Christmas & we opened all the sash weight pockets & foamed the corners & stuffed them with insulation. When they go for new windows they'll have nice tight opening to deal with.

As was mentioned earlier, watch out who is installing, find an installation company that is recommended by someone you know & whose judgment you trust.

Security wise, that is tougher to deal with. Get true divided light casement windows made to order by Kolbe & Kolbe, & that will make entry as difficult as it can be made w/o getting a window designed for high security. What about just putting in glass block w/integral vents? Just kidding, with that. Any double hung window is going to be easier to break into than a casement, but a casement offers an easy pathway just by breaking the glass out. Just go for a more expensive window made by a reputable manufacturer & you will be as secure as you can be w/o going for a window designed to be high security.

Peace

Justin

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#11

JL

I put the Zap pack windows in my old house...

JL

>I was amazed at how much less the heating and AC bills were - and I only replaced the ones in the back and side of the house.

Re: Window Replacement - Suggestions?

#12

Don't forget to consider your tax break *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You can get up to 30% of the cost of a window as a tax credit if it meets certain energy savings standards. Doing that on the windows we're in the process of putting in added far less to the cost than the credit will amount to.

We used Marvin units that tilt into our existing wood double-hung window frames. The first one, in our bedroom, required more repair to the frame than I expected, so it took more than a day; but I hope the others will go more quickly.


some info