Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Posts

Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#1

Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Why is wiring the shop such a not-fun job? I'm sure I'll be happy to have more circuits and outlets, but it's always kinda miserable putting it in. I decided to do some temporary wiring to use until I add some windows and then drywall into the shop. I'm using the BEX Armor Wire as it's pretty easy to put in and easy to remove if I decided to move things. Ultimately, I want to move to conduit, but since I'm not drywalled yet, seems like a waste to put it all up since it doesn't move very easily. However, there must be a skill I don't have for hooking up recepticles and pushing all that wire into the box.

I decided to put outlets every 4 feet along my main tool wall. I know it's probably a bit of overkill, but I shouldn't need any extension cords, which is helpful. Wiring is 12 AWG 2 wire with ground wire in the aluminum sheath. I'm using 20A breakers and plain old 115v recepticles. I have a 60A sub panel in the shop which I can kill at the main panel to make working in it safe.

The good part of wiring is that I can also re-arrange tools into a better configuration.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#2

Box size *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of my slow, late lessons is that bigger boxes are MUCH nicer to stuff. I'm using the basic 2-1/4" boxes now for terminal simple outlets only - that is, one wire set coming in and a regular duplex outlet or a switch. For upstream wires, with two or more cables coming in (and going out), or for GFCI outlets, I'm using a 4" square box and plaster/mud rings (also known as "raised covers", see linky; I believe you can get these for plastic boxes too, but I'm strongly biased in favor of metal boxes, which will still be usable in 50 years, something I'm skeptical about with plastic boxes), which gives enough room to push the wires back without having to grunt, scream, or curse.

When doing switches, I buy the deepest boxes I can, and am happiest when I've got a switch bank of two or more switches, because the extra width gives more finger room.

This approach is safer, too: over-stuffed boxes can overheat, causing fires. In fact, I doubt that a conventional 2-1/4" box even meets code with more than one cable and an outlet in it - not that thousands of such boxes aren't installed every year.

A note on the mud rings: the nominal size of a ring is measured from the face side; the folks who set industry standards apparently didn't notice that the flat part, the part that goes against the box, has thickness. I buy 5/8" mud rings for 1/2" sheetrock and set the box on the stud with the mud ring on, lining up the flat face of the ring with the edge of the stud (when I use nail-on boxes, this requires modifying the nail-on flange to flatten the little indexing fingers, or hammering them back into the stud a bit. This finishes out quite nicely with 1/2" sheetrock.

This adds a little expense, but adds FAR more speed, grace, and peace of mind. Unless you're doing this job from your penny jar - and, really, even if you are - it's worth it, in my opinion.


An example

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#3

Re: Box size

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>If you will be inspected, better check code. Code actually determines how many conductors/connections of a certain gauge an electrical box of a certain size can accomodate. When I wired a new addition with 12 ga. years ago, I had to replace a number of boxes with deeper or special drywall boxes that had an extension (a side car) behind the drywall.

Many state and local codes (possibly the NEC, too) frown on using the outlet screw terminals to daisy-chain wire the outlets. In such cases you need to join the incoming and outgoing wires and short pigtails with wire nuts, then connect the pigtails to the outlet terminals. All that quickly fills up the box and maxes out the number of conductors/connections.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#4

Clint Searl

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Clint Searl

>You might want to consider an independent hookup with its own meter and a 200 amp panel. Think of all the 240v doodads that you'll be able to run simultaneously, including a heat pump for year-round comfort.

Clint

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#5

Re: Box size

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>I actually am using the pigtail method for connecting recepticles in a series. And yeah, it does fill them up and make them hard to work with. I'm pretty sure I don't need to have an inspection for my own work, though I try to do everything as near to code as I know of. I need to pick up some more half inch straps to hold the wiring tighter as a few places can sag, which I don't like. Cheap and easy to do that, though.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#6

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>Oh, I think thats more of a dream for me. I'm only working in a 1 1/2 car garage. What I put in should hold me over quite well. I did have a 100A line run into the 60A sub panel, so if I ever need to upgrade in the future I can. The sub panel is on the opposite of the house, so if I need any new electrical work over there I don't have really long runs.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#7

Re: Box size

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>You know, I have to get some more straps to hold down the cable, so maybe I'll grab the bigger box and ring and see how that works. If it's nice and easy, I'd consider replacing the 3 I already wired up. I like things that make my life easier. I don't mind over killing when doing electrical work.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#8

Grounding boxes

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Locally, some of the inspectors are calling for the line ground - that is, the one coming in from the power side - coming into a metal box to be looped around the box's ground screw directly, then connected to the fixture either directly (if it's the only item in the box) or through a pigtail from a wirenut or crimp connector (if there are multiple fixtures in the box, or if the box is partway through a circuit).

This results in one fewer wire* in the box, and is a sensible practice, as the box is then grounded even if the wirenut/crimp connector fails. Most fixtures - outlets, switches - are grounded through the frame when attached to a metal box, so it also serves as a secondary path to equipment ground of the fixture itself, although I'd never trust it to ground actual equipment, as it depends on too many screws maintaining their tightness.

It does mean that for cable (NM or BX, for instance), you have to waste some of the length to get a long enough ground wire to do all that, but only about another 6" per box. I tend to overdo the wire length at rough in anyway, figuring that it's easier to cut it shorter than longer when I install fixtures.

*I've always been puzzled that the code used to - and still may, I'm no way current - consider all ground wires in a box as one wire for purposes of counting wire fill in a box. They do take up space, and in particular in a complex box, the clump of wires and wire nut take up space; and a bare wire is not much smaller than an insulated one. I suppose it is/was a holdover from the days when insulation on wire was a lot thicker than it is now, so that a number 12 wire might be three times its actual diameter with its insulation. But then, in every area of law/regulation with which I've ever had contact, there are puzzles that make no common sense at all.

Bill, not an electrician but I've done enough on my house to think I know more than I do

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#9

Re: Box size - I agree with Alan

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I'm a licensed NJ Bldg. Inspector (it feels good to say that :-)) and in my travels, I've seen many an inspector squash the install approval because of overcrowded boxes. One of the biggest hits on the inspection. Second is overcutting of structural members. This is becoming a HUGE item because of the bigger use of TJI's and "engineered" lumber. My observations of course.

I'd advise anyone doing wiring, please check with your local and NEC codes.

Ray

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#10

Re: Box size

Fred Davis

>The reason for pigtailing outlets is to keep down stream outlets on that circuit powered up if a outlet fails.

Daisy chain wiring will kill all of the down stream outlets on that circuit if one outlet fails.

I used Commercial Electricians when doing remodels in their spare time and off days and individual houseing units because they do this pigtailing as a matter of course which is required or used to be for commercial jobs.

FredD

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#11

In addition to all that......

Barry Irby

>One thing that helps is to plan the work in the box, keep it neat, and purposefully fold the wires so they fit inside the box. Keeping the wires as nearly parallel to each other as you can helps. A neatly done box "appears" to have fewer wires than one that looks like spaghetti.

Using the biggest boxes you can helps too.

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#12

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Pete in Holland, MI

>"Plain old" 115v outlets are only rated for 15 amps of power. Might want to upgrade to the more expensive 20 amp guys.

Also, mount your outlets so the bottom is 50" off the floor. Easier to reach, and will still tolerate a few sheets of plywood leaned up against the wall.

I have 1 120v 20 amp circut, and one 220v 20 amp circut in my shop haven't looked back. DC, table saw, shaper and lathe all draw 220 volts, but never have more than 2 on at a time.

Pete

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#13

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Fred Davis

>So, if that single 240V circuit fails , all of the machines are dead to , instead of having each on a dedicated circuit.

FredD

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

#14

Re: Electrical Fun! - OK, not so fun

Jay Lombardo

>You could mount 4" square bracket boxes recessed in wall and either run your BX temporary or you could run the conduit now putting both in the wall. Install your outlets with 4" sq. "Garvon" covers now and then when you go to install the drywall just change the Garvons to mud rings and you are all set.

Good Luck,'

Jay