Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT - house wiring question

Posts

OT - house wiring question

#1

OT - house wiring question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>We have a light above our back door that is currently turned on and off with a three-way switch loop. While we have our roof open is an ideal time to add a motion detector that will turn it on, when we've forgotten to do so before going out at night, as we walk in the back gate.

It seems to me that I can wire in both the motion detector and the existing switch loop, without confusing either one. The schematic is below; am I correct that this should work?


img

Re: OT - house wiring question

#2

Re: OT - house wiring question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>No.

The sensor goes between the light and the switches. Your drawing puts it such a way so as to defeat the switches and the detector will be powered at all times. Plus if you actually turned on the switch and then the detector came on with the second hot leg, you'd be in trouble. You'll have to wire the detector into what should be the red (hot) traveler out of the second switch.

Detectors need a switch upstream with the load (your light) downstream. You'll still have to remember to power the light and detector, but the light won't come on unless the detector smells something.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#3

Re: OT - house wiring question

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Hi Bill.

What you have drawn will work electrically, BUT I would not do it. By using the photocell switch as shown, you have bypassed the 3-way switches and have an unswitched circuit. Why not just run a second hot wire from the same source as the 3-way with a wall switch in series with the photocell. That way you have a positive on/off control of the photocell path. I worry that some malfunction of the photocell would lead to a fire, and without a switch you would have to go back to the breaker box to cut the current flow.

But,,,, I worry a lot, and tend to over build things.

Good saw dust,

Ken

Re: OT - house wiring question

#4

Thanks, but

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>if I wire the detector in series with the switches, as I understand you're suggesting, then both have to be on for the light to be on - which would mean that, for the light to work, I'd have to turn on the switch, walk out to the gate in the dark, and wave my arms around. I want to be able to turn the light on by way of the switch OR have the motion detector turn it on.

Maybe that's not possible, but it seems like it should.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#5

yes, but

Dan Donaldson

>It will work except for two possible problems. You may (probably will) need a neutral for the motion detector. The other, which may or may not be a problem is that if the motion detector triggers, the switches will be non-functional until the detector turns off. Having the detector powered all the time should not be any problem.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#6

What You're Looking For

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>is a detector built on a 3-way switch base which would replace one of the switches in your drawing. That way the light could be turned on either by one switch or the detector. Would work in a 4-way system as well.

You'd best ask a good supply house on that one.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#7

Fires?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Thanks, but I'm confused and concerned. Are motion detectors any more prone to causing fires than, say, dishwashers or fridges, for which the circuit breaker is usually the only switch?

Re: OT - house wiring question

#8

Good point

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'll have to look at the motion detector schematic again for our existing motion detector*, which powers the gate light; you're probably right about the neutral. Oh well - 3 wire instead of 2 wire NM.

As to having it on regardless of switch position when the motion detector's on, that's fine. The issue is that coming in the back gate and going out into the backyard are different directions, about 25 feet apart; and I want to have the back light on before I step out of the house, for reasons explained in the next paragraph.

A couple of years ago, we went on vacation and, foolishly, left dry cat food out in the back entryway, which is converted from an old porch and thus outside the house proper, although it has its own back door (which we left propped open while we were away). After we got back, I was letting one of the cats out in the middle of the night, and opened the door to find three raccoons, sitting and wondering when the cat food restaurant would be opening (we've never again left cat food out overnight). The cat didn't see them either, until he was out the door, and managed to rush between two of them before they could react. I'd like to have a light shining when I open that door, so I know who/what I'm greeting.

*which might just as well be called a "raccoon detector." It goes on almost every night, sometimes a couple of times a night, due to passing critters - something I know thanks to my insomnia.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#9

Re: OT - house wiring question

Ken Krawford

>I'm probably out in left field here but my outside flood lights have a motion detector built in. There are 2 ways to turn it on - obviously with motion or a quick on/off toggle of the switch. Couldn't you just buy a motion detector flood light and use your existing wiring as is?

Re: OT - house wiring question

#10

That was my thought.

Barry Irby

>Assuming you work out the "neutral" question for the motion switch, the only disadvantage I can see is that the motion detector is the master circuit and would negate the switches until it turns off.

How about going the other way? Eliminate the switches and just rely on the motion detector?

I had a motion light. Noticed it coming on periodically during the night. The neighbor's dog, apparently bored would walk over, circle a few times until the night came on and then go home. Maybe he was scared of the dark.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#11

Re: OT - house wiring question

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'll look into whether there are motion detectors that can get inspired to work if the switch is jiggled.

Ours is an old (1895) house, and there are precious few lights with built in motion detectors that work. I'm hoping to match the existing light at the gate.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#12

To clarify

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>"...there are precious few lights with built in motion detectors that work AESTHETICALLY."

A flood light, while it has its virtues, wouldn't look right on our auld haus.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#13

Re: To clarify

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Ken is right.

Check the instructions first, but most motion sensor lights are designed so that if you quickly cycle the power switch from on, to off, and back on again (in less than 2 seconds) the light will stay on without needing to be tripped by sensing motion.

To reset to the sensing mode, you turn the main switch off for five seconds then turn it on again. It will briefly turn the light on then the light will go out as the sensor reverts to the motion triggered mode.

They were designed to be used with no special wiring to solve the exact issue you have.

As to your diagram- if you need to control the light from two locations put the two 3-way switches upstream as you have them, but add the sensor downstream (in series, NOT parallel) from the switches.

As to appearance- you can get lights with stalk-mounted sensors that have adjustable sensitivity and on-time (usually for flood/spot lights) or wall and light pole mounted lights with internal/low profile sensors (adjustable?), or you can buy a separate sensor only unit which would be wired in series between the switch and the light unit. Also, most of these sensors have day/night modes so they don't turn on during the day (unless you override that mode)

Re: OT - house wiring question

#14

Re: Fires?

Ken Garlock, Collin County Texas

>Bill, I can't speak to the quality of photocells. I have one on our lamp post light in the front yard, and the lamp is on its own circuit back to the panel. The lamp post is about 20 ft. from the house and a malfunction would only cause a problem in and at the lamppost.

As I understand you plan, your photocell will be near the soffit, and I would be afraid of the possibility of a fire, be it ever so remote.

Your household appliances have been stress tested for possibility of starting a fire, and have been found to safe (UL.) I don't know if that is the case with photocells. Another consideration is the current rating on the photocell. I would look for one that can stand a 200-300 watt continuous load. Here again, a safety factor.

Last, what would your homeowner insurance say about your plan? Check it now, rather than after a problem.

Good Luck,

Ken

Re: OT - house wiring question

#15

Re: OT - house wiring question

Rick Christopherson

>What you are suggesting is just fine. You have the sensor in parallel with the switches, which is OK too. There is no abnormal risk of fire. The switches will turn the light on and off, and if the sensor is triggered, it will override the switches and turn the light on. That is doing what you want.

I had one of the types of lights Ken mentioned where turning the light on triggered the sensor to think an object was in front of them. I can't remember the details now, because I rewired the light to override this function. If memory serves me, after I turned the light on, it would turn itself off after a few minutes. This became frustrating when shoveling the driveway.

If you wire it the way you show, you might also consider putting in one more switch (standard switch) that can disable the sensor for times when you want to maintain manual control.

Re: OT - house wiring question

#16

Re: OT - house wiring question

Jay Lombardo

>The way you have it will work just the way you want it to. There is no more fire danger there than any other type of switch. If I understand you needs correctly you have it right.

Good Luck

Jay