Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

What Router?

Posts

What Router?

#1

What Router?

Lewis Dodd

>My old Sears router gave up the ghost today! What router do you recommend? The Sears was a booger to change bits on unless you almost had it in your lap!

Thanks

Re: What Router?

#2

Re:All of the Below

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Lewis,

The correct answer is "all of the below". We all have our preferences. My personal favorite is the Porter+Cable 690 series. I have three, and several bases extra. They are bullet proof. These are great in a table, and do about 90% of my routing needs. For swinging large bits, my choice is the P+C 7518 multispeed 3 1/4 hp monster. I've used them for years with almost zero trouble.

Others such as the Dewalt, Freud, Hitachi, Bosch, etc are also superlative in various models. My #3 son is a finish carpenter and loves the Milwaukee with good reason. How can you go wrong?

George

Re: What Router?

#3

JL

Re: What Router?

JL

>I've got the PC 890 series routers with the exchangeable bases (2 1/4 hp). I also have a Dewalt plunge router (2 hp or so). I like all of them.

Re: What Router?

#4

An ABS router

Dan Donaldson

>(anything but sears)

Re: What Router?

#5

I am with the Colonel

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud,Fla

>I prefer Original but the new grilled isn't bad. Oh yeah, I have been a Porter Cable man since the early 1960's

Re: What Router?

#6

Jesper, Denmark

Re: What Router?

Jesper, Denmark

>I have been very happy with my various Porter Cable routers for years, but had to buy something that worked on 220Volt for a job in Germany.

The Festool 1400 is superior to the Porter Cable, but really too expensive.

Re: What Router?

#7

Re: I am with the Colonel

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I have a Craftsman router I've had for, ahem, nearly 37 years. It is still going strong. When it dies, I will probably replace it with a PC 690 series. My Freud FT2000 is too large for freehand routing and for use on my dovetail guide. The smaller Craftsman router does a much better job.

Lee

Re: What Router?

#8

Now Dan no TLA allowed(-;

Dustmaker Mike

>

Re: What Router?

#9

Re: What Router?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I am in agreement with most here, I think many I have met and/or corresponded with on this site are happy with the major brands - Hitachi, Milwaukee - Porter Cable, Bosch etc. with the Porter Cable being the favorite. I had a couple of the cheap consumer brands - Skill and Craftsman and ended up giving them away. I gave them to a friend with all the various attachments that wouldn't work with my Porter cable units. I have the 690 series for hand held applications. I purchased the set with the plunge and fixed base. I have another 690 I use with my Leigh jig. I have the big PC 7539 variable speed plunge router (with the router Raizer) in my router table and the little PC trim router. One things I have learned - I would not use the variable speed on a hand held router, if the bit is large enough that I need to reduce speed I use the router table anyhow. The reason I was dissatisfied with the Crapsman and Skill routers is that they did not hold the fine adjustment and accuracy I require. The slippage in setting and flexing of the units allowed more movement that I could tolerate. I have been very satisfied with the PC units.

Re: What Router?

#10

Re: What Router?

Frank Mutchler

>I have experience with the following:

A Makita 3612, my first real router that I rarely use any more. It's a strong, dependable, single speed beast.

A Hitachi 612V that stays mounted in a router table. Inexpensive and dependable.

A Dewalt 625 with a quick change chuck that stays mounted in a Router Boss. Maintains adjustments, easy to adjust, dependable.

A Dewalt 624 that I've never used. NIB but not variable speed. I got it by accident...I thought I was buying a 625.

A Dewalt 621 that I use for almost all freehand routing. Maintains adjustment, easy to adjust, nimble.

A Dewalt laminate trimmer for small jobs. Awkward to adjust but very useful for small jobs.

Unlike a lot of folks, I don't care for my PC 690. I rarely use it for 2 reasons: clumsy (for me) to use 2 wrenches to change the bit and sloppy (for me) depth adjustment.

Re: What Router?

#11

Re: That Freud...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco------WebKitFormBou

>It was the first router I bought. Because I could get more horsepower at a better price, it was the best deal. It scared the shirt off of me, or something like that. Lives in a table these days, and is well respected there.

The PC 690 series is my handheld 'large' router. There are three trim routers semipermanently installed with special bases and bits that don't change much that get a lot of use, too.

Re: What Router?

#12

Re: What Router?

Jerry Nicholson

>I really like the Dewalt 621 for hand held work but it would be a lousy choice for table mounting. I have a Freud FT2000 permanently mounted under my router table. I bought a second 621 a while back and have it stashed away in case the old one ever gives up the ghost. The little Freud Colt trim router works pretty well too for work you can do with fairly small bits. My really old Craftsman still works but it very rarely gets used.

Jerry