Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Posts

Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#1

Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Jim in N. Va.

>I'm planning on replacing my 3hp Unisaw with a new Sawstop. I can get either a 3hp or 5hp (both single phase) Sawstop. I have both a 20A (220) circuit (which the Unisaw currently runs on) and an unused 30A (220) circuit which I assume is what the 5hp would need.

I work almost exlusively with hardwoods, some quite thick. Haven't really noticed the 3hp Unisaw getting bogged down in my work.

So, is there any reason to spring for the 5hp motor on the new saw? Is there any reason not to? (Maybe I've been missing something all along and just don't know it.)

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Clint Searl

>It only costs a little more to go first class.

Clint

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#3

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Ron Jones

>If the 3 HP has served you well with no lack of power, I see no reason to go to the 5HP. But, hey, it's your money. If there is doubt in your mine go big. Is there a reason to doubt the cutting power of the SS compared to the Unisaw? I really don't know.

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#4

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Jim in N.VA

>Thanks, but just to be clear I didn't mean to suggest that the SS 3hp might be less powerful than the Unisaw 3ph. Rather, I guess I wanted to know if I was missing anything by not having 5 hp.

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#5

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

mike from american sycamore

>I have both the three horse and the five horse Unisaws here at the school. I have one three horse set up for cross cutting and another 3hp set up with a dado. The 5hp is usually set up for ripping. I would recommend that you go with the 5hp if it is in your budget. You will enjoy the 5hp when ripping 8/4 material.

Mike

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#6

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Fred Davis

>If your going to use the 5 H.P. saw with a ten inch blade , I see no reason to upgrade to it.

On the other hand if you buy it in a 12 inch model then you will be taking advantage of the larger motor.

I currently run a ten inch Unisaw exclusively for ripping with a power feed and for Cabinet and Furniture requirements I typically make , it is plenty powerful enough.

You might ask Ellis for his views on the 12 inch model ,that is what he is using.

Naturally , maintaining a supply of ten and twelve inch blades would be more costly. ;-))

One other thought , I wouldn't want to replace a five horse motor out of warranty , if I really didn't need it in the first place.

FredD

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#7

JL

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

JL

>I ended up buying a 5 hp (it actually was less expensive than a 3 hp at the time). Does it make a difference? Of course. Is it really needed - no. I was ripping 10/4 cherry with my old Sears 1.5 hp - it just was slow. I can now rip it really fast - but I don't want to do it too fast.

If the dollar difference isn't much, go for the big guns.

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

#8

Re: Would you get 3 hp or 5 hp?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I'm no Pro so take my opinion for what it's worth. I think that the larger horsepower is only useful in a production setting where you want to continue to cut material after the saw blade has dulled somewhat. This can be important economically when you have paid personnel operating the saw continuously. However I would never allow the blade to run dull as the quality of the cut suffers. I have a 3 HP 10" Unisaw and have never seen a time - even when ripping thick exotics - where I couldn't feed the saw as fast as I was comfortable. I run Forest WWll thick kerf blades 90+% of the time (and keep them very sharp). That said, if the cost was the same or just slightly higher I would probably go for the 5 HP.