Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

240 Electrical Problem

Posts

240 Electrical Problem

#1

240 Electrical Problem

Tomm

>Ten years ago I ran a number 10 (3 wires) to the shop for some 240 service. It comes from a 60 amp subpanel. I put two outlets on the run and have a 30amp breaker in the subpanel. I run an electric heater using one of the outlets. I have never used the other outlet but I would like to add a three horsepower saw now. The saw requires a 20 amp circuit breaker. The heater is 5 kw and draws 21 amps on high. Keep in mind that it is a 240 line. Do I have any options with the existing line or do I need to run a new line?

The subpanel is full with 110 outlets and lights. Thanks for your thoughts.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#2

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>You are WAY over loaded starting with the feed to the subpanel. You need to up its feed and the panel. Then upgrade the #10/240v for more amperage.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#3

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Barry Irby

>Assuming the run is not extremely long, you can pull 30 amps safely from a 10 AWG copper cable.

You have several possibilities. What is the running load amp draw of the saw? May be listed on the label as RLA. The startup draw will be significantly higher. The label may also list Locked Rotor Amps or LRA. It may be five times higher than RLA.

Then what is the draw of the heater on something other than high. If it has a Low setting, you may be also be to run the heart on low with the saw running.

Or you may have to turn off the heater when you want to run the saw.

You are not supposed to pull more than 80% of the rated capacity of the wire continuously. In your case, 24 Amps. But, it is unlikely in a one person shop you will run the saw in bursts long enough to be considered a continuous draw. So, If the heater pulls 9 and the saw 21 they may both run safely on a thirty amp circuit. You might have to buy a HACR breaker to get a time delay to allow the saw to start up and instantaneously overload the circuit long enough to get the saw shaft moving.

Do not install a larger breaker.

If the two units won't play nice together on a thirty amp circuit, you will have to run another circuit.

If the panel is full of breakers, you can buy mini or half sized breakers for most of them. Eventually, the circuits will over load the main breaker and you have to upsize the service. Because of the random nature of using the current, the "amps" on the breakers will add up to far more than the main, lone before it is actually overloaded.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#4

How can you tell......

Barry Irby

>the sub panel is way overloaded?

As I read it, he has a 60amp sub panel with a thirty amp feed to two outlets and some 20 amp circuits. The 30 amp circuit is the feed out of the panel, not into it, as I read it.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#5

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Chuck in ND

>Are you going to be running a dust collector with the saw ? Depending on the size, that could be another 240 circuit.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#6

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Fred Davis

>Unless it's changed the 80% rule applies to the entire sub panel for total load.

The heater because it is resistive , is figured at 100% , given that it is rated at 21 amps , you are way overloaded thinking about a additional 3 h.p. saw that could easily draw close to thirty amps on start up.

FredD

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#7

Re: How can you tell......

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>The heater, saw, and lights should be considered continuous load because that is how they could be used. Heat due to use or overload is what kills electrical stuff and starts fires. Why don't you run this past the local electrical authority. There is no lee way for anything else. Like Fred said,"what about the dust collector?" What about the air compressor when it cycles automatically? What happens when a unusally loaded saw (and everything else) trips the main to the subpanel and you are left with no lights while you push wood thru the still spinning saw blade. Is the money he will save be equal to lost fingers or no shop after the fire?

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#8

The problem with electrical questions....

John in NM

>Is that due to the wide variety of conditions, and the wide variety in individual risk tolerance, there are simply no easy answers.

Overall, I'm with Barry, if you try both on the same 30 amp circuit, results are going to depend on how you use them together. I would not expect this set up to win any safety prizes, but if used sensibly, there's nothing inherently dangerous about it (for example, one could easily turn off the heater before running the saw).

But one should not dismiss the cautious advice of Fred and Chuck, if you want to play it safe and run everything at once, including a dust collector, run another 30 amp circuit. Even with two 30's and some lights, I don't believe you will be overloading the panel, but I wouldn't want to add anything more to it.

One does often want to overbuild electrical installations, for safety margins (that are over and above what are already built into the NEC and IRC), and more importantly for ease of future expansion. From that point of view, you might want to upgrade the panel. Personally, I wouldn't do so until you need to run another large circuit, or decide that you need two 120V 20A circuits for routers and such. But you know the specifics of your shop, layout, and future plans better than any of us, so that's your call.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#9

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Rick Christopherson

>You can add the saw to the existing circuit, but you won't be able to use both the saw and the heater at the same time.

If it was a Unisaw with a capacitor start, capacitor run motor (two humps) then it will draw only 12 amps at full load (motor beginning to bog down), and half of that when idle. You could get by with running both simultaneously as long as the saw remained at a moderate load, which is typical. A less efficient saw would not fall into this same capacity.

If it was really an issue, you could install an interlock, so that when the saw is turned on, it interrupts the thermostat control on the heater with a small relay. Not only will this ensure that you don't overload that circuit, but it also reduces the risk of overloading the subpanel this circuit is driven from.

Contrary to popular belief, the saw is not only not a continuous load, but it also rarely operates at its full load rating. This is something that the NEC does not account for, because most motor-driven equipment is typically designed to operate at full rated load for as long as the motor is running. The heater may or may not be a continuous load, depending on whether it cycles with temperature/operator over a 3 hour period.

Ideally, you would run a new 20 amp circuit for the saw. However, I am less concerned about this circuit than I am about your subpanel. These two loads are consuming more than half the capacity of the subpanel, yet the subpanel has many other circuits potentially in use. I think you should be examining the capacity of the subpanel.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#10

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Tomm

>Thanks for all the help with my electrical problem. Your answers made me realize that I have more problems than just the 240 circuit. The subpanel is protected with a 50 amp circuit breaker and it is for the whole shop. Although I have never had any problems I can see that with a larger saw problems could develop. I guess I have a couple of options; either run a dedicated line to the saw from the 200 amp main panel or install a larger subpanel with a larger wire from the main panel.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#11

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Dan Donaldson

>Depending on what you end up doing, one thing that you might want to think about. I have two circuits running from the house to the shop. The heavy one runs to a distribution panel fed by a heavy breaker and the other is a 20 amp circuit directly from the house panel to the shop. I do not have any windows in my shop. The heavy distribution panel runs my heat pump and all of the equipment and the extra 20 amp circuit runs the lights. That way, if I trip the main circuit, I am not without lights in the shop. Just a thought.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#12

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Rick Christopherson

>Just a head's-up, but you cannot have more than one circuit going out to a separate building.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#13

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Dan Donaldson

>Don't know on that one. May be, but it was done by a licensed electrician with a permit and inspected and passed by the city.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#14

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Rick Christopherson

>From the NEC:

225.30 Number of Supplies.

Where more than one building or other structure is on the same property and under single management, each additional building or other structure that is served by a branch circuit or feeder on the load side of the service disconnecting means shall be supplied by only one feeder or branch circuit unless permitted in 225.30(A) through (E). For the purpose of this section, a multiwire branch circuit shall be considered a single circuit.

I also read through the exceptions (A) through (E) and they do not apply.

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

#15

Re: 240 Electrical Problem

Dan Donaldson

>I didn't say that you were wrong, just that it was done with a permit and inspected and passed, perhaps erroneously, but still passed. ;-)

There is a 60 amp 220 feed to a small panel and a separate 20 amp feed to an isolated circuit.