Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Any gas water heater gurus here?

Posts

Any gas water heater gurus here?

#1

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Any gas water heater gurus here?

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I have a $@!#$#@ Kenmore Power Miser 9 gas, closed-combustion-chamber water heater (from what the local plumbing supply places tell me, it's made by A.O. Smith). What that means is that they are not allowed to cross-reference parts and sell me the appropriate A.O. Smith part.

A few weeks ago, when I noticed the water wasn't getting hot before I stepped in the shower, I went and checked the water heater--pilot was out. Odd, I thought, so I re-lit it and waited for the water to heat up so I could take a shower. A week later it was out again. After describing this to the plumbing parts stores counter guys, they both told me that I needed to clean it--there's a porcelain screen underneath the burner and a couple plastic intake screens on the bottom support ring. I did that--compressed air, vacuum cleaner, brass brush, etc. That seemed to fix it--for a few days.

So, one day while messing with it, I happened to just sit there watching it burn, when it just shut off while the burner was on--pilot and all. Playing with the thermostat knob told me that the water wasn't up to temp yet.

Anyway, does anyone have any ideas what might be going on? I have a way over-priced thermocouple on the way from Sears, but is it possible that the thermostat/control valve is bad for some reason? The heater has a build date of 1/2005, so it's less than 5 years old, and it's in really good shape overall.

Thanks,

Jason

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#2

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

John Veerkamp, Western Mo

>Jason,

sounds like the thermo couple is gone. It might still be under warrenty. Most wh have at least a 5 yr warrenty. The other possibility is low gas pressure at your house. The heaters have a pressure sensor and if it drops too low it will shut off, but the couple is the most likely problem. Those parts for the new closed chamber units are expensive. You might check with a plumbing supply house. Most of these parts are semi universal.

Good luck,

John

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#3

The new stile of WH's suck and have for 8 years

Wayne Carson

>

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#4

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I concur that the first thing to try is the thermocouple.

There's an appliance parts house around here that carries just about every brand, and for less than the factory. I've purchased a thermocouple from them for our ancient (old when we moved in 36 years ago) water heater.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#5

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

7 year warranty...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...but that's only on parts, and a tech would have to come out on a service call--$$$--no way. Like I said, the new thermocouple ("pilot assembly") is on the way. $50 shipped is cheaper than a service call.

The parts counter guy said he had those pilot assemblies in stock, but A.O. Smith won't give him a cross reference to Kenmore, so he has no way of selling me the correct one--several look identical, but with different specs.

If this isn't it, there's only one other thing to replace--the gas control valve, which would set me back about $120 shipped. Still cheaper than a new water heater.

Jason

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#6

Bill, do you still have a WH after 36 Years?

Barry Irby

>What brand is it? Only ever seen one or two that old. Tell me more.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#7

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

del schisler

>i know on the one's i remember and fixed their is a Thermocouple that has to be hot to keep gas valve working Their is a little nut on the copper line that goes to the gas valve tighten it It may be loose This used to be one thing that happen's Other than that if it has a thermocouple Replace that Should fix problum

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#8

Re: Bill, do you still have a WH after 36 Years?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I'm afraid to say too much, for fear of calling down the Murphy Valkyries. It's a Rheem, no idea what model (I could cite the model # if I felt like getting down on the floor with a flashlight...but would have no idea what it meant). As far as I know, it was here when my parents bought the house in 1968 or 69, and certainly was when we moved in. It clanks like mad sometimes, and I have no way to drain it after foolishly putting in a hose-bib type faucet for the drain, which has since plugged up (word of advice: ALWAYS use a straight ball type valve if replacing the stock: you can run a wire up an open ball valve to clear sediment that's blocking the outflow). Probably running at obscenely low efficiency, in spite of the blankie I put around it.

Our town uses wells for a town-wide water system, and the water's fairly soft, but our ancient galvanized plumbing has a lot of scale and is probably busy shedding bits of rust into the system, so the water's not exactly distilled.

I have no explanation, really; I've been ascribing it to my residual Irish luck (1/8, Kelly on my father's mother's side).

My dad put a commercial-grade water heater with a Monel tank in his house when I was about eight, and it worked until I was maybe 55, so long life is or was possible with a water heater.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#9

Those closed chambers are touchy...

John in NM

>There's a screen on the bottom somewhere that tends to get clogged with lint and dust bunny parts, then you don't have enough air to keep the pilot lit (very little positive draft with just the pilot you see). I've never found and cleaned that screen, but this was explained to me when we had the same problem with a new WH at work. There was an accessory skirt that we installed around the base to keep lint and dust out, but just the skirt was enough to restrict airflow at our elevation (10,400 feet), and snuff the pilot.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#10

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

My last house...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...from which we moved a little over 2 years ago had a WH that was installed in '91. The only trouble I ever had with it was one time I thought it was leaking, when it reality, I had just gone through all the hot water, and condensation was dripping onto the burner. The water in that town was so full of extra vitamins and minerals, that I figure the tank was no longer metal--having long rusted away, but a thick layer of scale and sediment. AFAIK, it is still in use. I don't recall the brand.

Jason

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#11

Re: Bill, do you still have a WH after 36 Years?

Barry Irby

>That's Great.

I have seen a Monel tank that was probably fifty or sixty years old. Completely uninsulated, probably very low efficiency, but still working.

I saw a Rheem electric water heater that was about as old as yours. It had strap on elements on the outside of the tank. The Buyer of the house could not find a replacement for the one that was out when I inspected it. They called Rheem and Rheem was so proud of the unit they tracked down the element and sent someone to install it Free in return for some pictures.

I agree with you. Don't touch yours, don't even look at it hard. Murphy is lurking. Your pipes are due also. Good luck.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#12

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

Fred Davis

>You will always lose when you play Russian Roulette with a water heater, if you have hardwood floors , get it replaced while they are still flat.

This doesn't even take into account the loss of efficiency , poor gas combustion /airmix or a frozen pressure release or T@P valve..

If the WH is 36 years old so is the duct vent , typically G.I. and much thinner then when it was installed.

The caveat of "don't fix it if it ain't broke doesn't apply here.

FredD

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#13

Re: Bill, do you still have a WH after 36 Years?

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>If you want to change to a ball valve it's easy to do.

Shut off the cold water supply to the water heater. Next, open the hot water side of a faucet until the water stops coming out and then shut it off. This will create an air lock in the system that will make it possible to screw out the old drain and install a new one with little or no water loss. You can do the same thing to change gas valves.

Re: Any gas water heater gurus here?

#14

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

I...have made fire!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>(To borrow a quote from the Tom Hanks movie).

Anyway, the new "pilot assembly" came yesterday, and I just installed it.

Yesterday morning, while trying unsuccessfully (at first) to get the pilot re-lit, I happened to play with the little semi-conductor disk (I assume it's either the magic behind the thermocouple, or an overheat cut-out). I noticed a tiny little crack in the resinous covering, and when I applied a little pressure with my finger, one of the electrodes separated at its weld (or solder joint). After wedging it in place so that it made contact where it was electrically supposed to, the water heater worked fine--didn't have to re-light it again, which had become a repetitious chore throughout the day.

I may have bought the wrong thermocouple, since the electric lead and pilot light gas tube were a little on the long side, but it's working, so I don't care at this point. I just coiled them into a little "drip loop" outside the combustion chamber so the guard would fit over them. There was a little part number tag on both the old and new that read "190�C", so I think I'm in the clear either way.

Thanks again for all the help and suggestions (and the little rabbit trail into water heater longevity).

Jason