Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Posts

Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#1

Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

John Aniano in central NJ...

>Hello All,

I usually post on the hand tool side, but this is more appropriate here...

Any suggestions or recommendations on the different brands of dust collection remote power switch units? "Long Ranger" is one of them and Woodcraft sells a different one. Are there any other types of these units sold and if so, what is the opinion of how they perform? My system is a 2 HP - 240 V unit. The dust collector is within 30 feet of the shop space, but located one floor down. The building is sheathed in steel (a pole barn) but there is no metal between the collector and the shop space.

TIA,

John

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#2

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Nick Tuzzolino

>I have used the Long Ranger for about seven years with no problem (220v unit).

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#3

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Joe Pack

>I have the Long Ranger in a basement shop, so distance is not a problem. It has worked fine for me. I sometimes wish I had a second remote.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#4

Wired or Wireless

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My shop's in the basement but the DC is placed out in the garage. I therefore set up a pair of 3-way 110 switch leg in the shop controlling a 220 contactor in the garage. Been bullet proof for more than 15 years.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#5

If I had it to do over again...........

Randy Johnson Connersville IN

>I would install two three ways, with a generous collection of four ways in between in several convenient locations, around the shop. Like Mark said, it�s bulletproof.

What I have is the wireless system that came with my Oneida cyclone. Originally most of my overhead lights were the el cheapo two tube T-12s that sell everywhere for ten bucks or less. There were four two tube T-8s. I found out that when the T-8s are turned on it causes interference that keeps the remote from working. Simply put, if any of the T-8s are on, the remote might not work. If all four are on, it definitely won�t work. Since I would like to eventually have 100% T-8 fixtures I am a little concerned that the remote will no longer work at all. This wouldn�t be a concern with a mixture of three and four way switches. I can still go that route, but I was really hoping to never have to pick up an EMT bender again.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#6

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Jim Dillon

>John,

I've had rotten luck with both the 220V Oneida wireless, as well as the 220V "Long Ranger" purchased from Highland Hardware. Both worked well for a couple of years, then died. My DC is only a few steps away, so I just use my on-off switch adjacent to the DC (which I fortunately installed when I bought the Oneida DC - just in case). Plus, I get some exercise walking to the switch 8-). Sounds like others have had much better luck with their wireless setups, so I would go for either one - and cross my fingers. And yes, I tried changing the batteries each time, but still no luck 8-(.

Jim

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#7

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

del schisler

>i have the long ranger and it works great Mine is 110v but the 220v should work as well It will trigger the unit over 50 feet i have tried it

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#8

Re: Remote dust collector switch recommendations?

Barry Irby

>I use the Long Ranger Blast Gates that have the micro switch on them I went to a lot of trouble to locate the gates in convenient locations so that it becomes second nature to open and close the gates. The unit comes on when the gate opens. Since these are wired on low voltage switches, I think they would be immune to interference form the lighting or what ever. Had mine for about five years and had to replace one switch because something fell on it and smashed it.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#9

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Tom

>I got the Long Ranger from Grizzly this summer, the 220 version. It works great in an admittedly small shop. The very first time I used it I kicked myself in the head and asked why I waited years to buy it.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#10

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Doug Ridley

>Wish I was agile enough to kick myself in the head.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#11

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Fred Davis

>When I got a Onieda Industrial cyclone, the remote units they sent were furnished by a outside vendor I have tracked all over the USA.

They are presently sold by a firm in CA and they work well , at least the little transmitters, the recievers located at the Cyclone and midway in the shop burn out in a about two years and I have never had to pay for a replacement.

In word or two , get Remote unless you enjoy trotting around your shop.

FredD

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#12

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations? *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

>I've been using a 110V version of this one for several (3 or 4?) years now, no problems and I always seem to be able to find one or the other of the remote transmitter units.

http://grizzly.com/products/220V-Remote-Dust-Collector-Switch/H5397


http://grizzly.com/products/220V-Remote-Dust-Collector-Switch/H5397

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#13

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I have a completely automatic shop-built DC system- individual machines cause their gates to open, any gate opening causes DC to turn on. Turn the machine off and the gate closes, DC stays on to limit cycling). This may be more than you want to do. However, I turn the DC off (and can also turn it on) by any one of a half dozen "3-wire" low voltage start stop switch stations located around the shop. They allow the DC to be turned on at one location and turned of at that or any other location.

The "3 wire" low voltage system is really a good way to go for a manual system since you have full control from anywhere. If you leave a gate open you don't need to go back and close it to turn off the DC like you do with gate switches. I got some cheap Delta button covers from an auction site that make the control stations look professional. The 24V transformer and 30 amp contactor were from that source as well. The switches (from Radio Shack) behind the buttons are momentary, one normally open ("START") and one normally closed ("STOP").

Here is a schematic of a "3 wire" circuit to control a DC I added a high dust alarm of my own design)


In the lower left of this collage of my DC system is a pic of a manual DC control station (the button below the outlet manually controls the mitersaw blast gate.)


Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#14

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?h

Jon Weisenbach

>I've used the Lone Ranger 220 remote for the last 10years and it's worked flawlessly. I think I've only replaced the 9v battery in the unit once in all that time and then only because I thought I really needed to put a fresh one in because it had been like 8 years of use! By the way that was daily use for all that time.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#15

X10

Tony - Memphis

>I've been using the X10 stuff with mine for 11 years. I sucked up the remote in the dc and found three replacements on ebay for $10. I have the remote, receiver, and the wall outlet. Not sure if they have 220 stuff, but they probably do.

Tony

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#16

Just be sure you can buy a cheap separate remote

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#17

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations? *LINK*

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>I use a current sensor to turn my DC on and off automatically. Every time I start a dust producing machine, the collector is started and it shuts off with the equipment. It was easy to install and cost about the same as a Long Ranger, although the parts costs may have changed over the years.

The write-up on the system is in the August, 2000 issue (#143) of Fine Woodworking on page 66, in the article called Dust Detector. It has been republished in the Best of Fine Woodworking Series, Small Woodworking Shops book if I remember correctly.

Robby Wright

San Marcos, CA


Best of FWW Series, Small Woodworking Shops

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#18

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Fred Davis

>Check these guys out John , just noticed it in the Cabinet Makers Market place catalogue today.

Automatic blast gates.

http://www.nordfab.com/

FredD

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#19

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I hope you installed a time delay. If not you stand the chance of overheating and damaging your DC blower motor due to cycling. For that reason I intentionally designed my system so that I had to manually shut off the DC after an auto-start.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#20

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I would be interested in the Norfab prices. Based on what EcoGate charged (charges? Are they still around?) for their autogates (>$200 for a 6" gate) and what Norfab charges for their ductwork, I'll bet Norfab autogates are VERY, VERY pricey.

For anyone who is interested, I will be posting a link to a video of my autogates in operation within the next few days. Like the Norfab gates, mine are electro-pneumatic, but were probably much cheaper to make. If one of the WW mags would step forward, I would do an article about my system and how to build various control systems. My DC setup was featured in the WoodCentral Top Shop Contest.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#21

Use 3 and 4-way switches

Steve Silca

>This has been mentioned in this thread, but I used a total of 6 3-way and 4-way switches. See my website and go to the Wiring section for further explanation and rationale. I chose this over a remote or blast gate switches because I thought it would be most convenient. I love it.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#22

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

Robby Wright in San Marcos, CA

>Actually, I didn't install a time delay. The system has been in use for 9 years now and my DC motor is doing fine. I do tend to batch the cuts when I can for longer run time, but I have had many sessions of measure and cut one joint at a time. I admit that I don't do commercial work.

I have thought of a time delay, and someday I may install one, but so far, it hasn't been an issue. In case anyone is wondering, I have a 2 HP Seco DC with a Taiwanese motor. The ductwork is ABS drain pipe and the filter bags are the Rockler felt bags, which work great.

The main reason I went this route is that I don't have to think about turning the DC on or off at all. All I have to do is have the blast gates open on the right machines. My tablesaw and bandsaw tend to have the gates open all the time unless I am using another machine that needs the suction, so it is pretty painless.

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations?

#23

Re: Remote dust collector switch recomendations? *LINK*

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>To get max suction at each machine I focused on the gates instead of the blower. My automatic gates are only only open when the attached machine is on. When any gate is manually or automatically opened the DC turns on automatically too, but it must be manually turned off. See the link in the post below for a video.


DC Post