Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Posts

30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#1

30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Mitch from Canada

>Hey all.

I was looking at installing an overhead radiant heater in my garage/ shop. It's inside dimensions are 18'x 31'x 10'. The radiant heater has to be mounted on one short wall oppostite the overhead door to meet code.

I've contacted two heating guys...one installs radiant heaters all the time...says I'd need a 45,000 btu unit...the other guy hasn't installed a radiant heater in awhile, but according to his calculations, all I would need is a 30,000 btu unit.

What are your thoughts?

Thanks.

Mitch

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#2

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Barry Irby

>Without a lot more info we can't answer intelligently.

I can tell you that locally (Virginia) most contractors tend to recommend systems that are larger than necessary. It provides safety for them. If the heater is too big, you won't really know. It will keep the space warm the coldest day of the year with capacity to spare. It will cost more to operate than a properly sized unit, because it will cycle more than it should. When the unit turns off, there is a tendency for the heat remaining in the system to escape and then when it turns back on the heat it takes to reheat the unit and flue is the same amount of heat that was lost.

So, If the heater is the right size, or slightly too small, it will operate more efficiently. And, On the coldest day of the year, it will run twenty four hours to keep the space up to temp. Or, maybe it won't be capable of maintaining the the temp, but very likely it will be able to keep the temp a few degrees cooler than you wanted. On every other day of the year, even that heater will be too big.

Can you get a local utility to give you a heat loss calculation on your space? Locally, 30,000 Btus would be more than enough to heat an entire 1100SF ranch house.

To do the Calc we would need to know the insulation, orientation, number and type of windows and doors and much more.

By the way, do you live in a two hair dryer house? Here in the lower 48, we hear there are two hair dryer houses on the plains of Canada. One hanging inside the door knob so that you can warm the knob before you leave to keep your hand from freezing to the knob. One on the outside to thaw the lock when you return. (If so, go with the larger heater.)

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#3

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>I have a 26 X 32 X 10 shop, very well insulated. I'm in Northeast Ohio, a considerably more temperate climate than yours, but still quite cold for about four months of Winter weather.

My radiant heater is a 35,000 btu natural gas model. It'll raise the shop temp about fifteen degrees an hour during our coldest (maybe -5�F or -20.5�C) days.

Considering your generally colder climate, I'd be inclined to go with the 45,000 model.

Jim D.

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#4

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

North of the Border

>Based on Jim's experience, I'd say 30,000 - 35000 BTU is good enough for me:

a) his shop is a little bigger

b) when we work in the shop, the shop doesn't have to be hot

c) I work in my unheated shop without any heat if it's zero degree and above (I wear warm clothes (winter jacket))

d) as we work, our body generates heat

Sometimes. our temp could fall below - 25 C ... as a hobbyist woodworker, I don't work in my shop if the temperature falls below - 10 C. If I do have to, I turn on my portable propane gas heater and work in my shop for 4 hours or less. Woodworking is a hobby for me, not a job nor an endurance test!

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Forgot to mention - Yeah the shop doesn't need to be real warm. 60~65� is plenty warm when you're working.

I keep it at 50�F during its 'non-occupied' time. That way, my finishes and glues don't get too cold/frozen.

Jim D.

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#6

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Brian in Brighton

>I think your ceiling is too low. Re-verber-ray recommends 10-14' on several of their models and as low as 8' on others. I didn't go with it because my 12'-6" ceilings were going to put the heater too close to my head. Figure if your ceiling is 10' and the heater sticks down 1' and you're 6' than the heater will be 3' above your head. That was the biggest factor is my choosing a fan unit instead of radiant. I have 45K btu in a 4 car garage and it stays at 55F and takes about 30 minutes to bring it up to 70F.

I worked at a company with 24' ceilings and the radiants still left a narrow band of warm under them and it was quite uncomfortable working around them.

Brian in Brighton

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#7

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

Chris Friesen

>How's your insulation? I'm in Saskatchewan. I've got R12 walls, R30 roof, R16 double garage door, attached to the house one one side. Most of the time I keep it a few degrees above zero in the shop, then crank it up when I want to work.

According to my hvac guy, a 30K unit would have been fine but I ended up with a 45K one because the 30K wasn't in stock and would have taken a while to get in.

Assuming you've got okay insulation, the 30K should be fine.

Re: 30,000 vs 45,000 btu radiant heater

#8

forgot to mention...

Chris Friesen

>I'm in a double garage.

Also, are you sure you want a radiant heater? I've heard some horror stories about panels being warped due to the heat on the top and not on the bottom.

The point about height above your head is also well-taken...I've seen comments in other threads about the heat from electric radiant heaters being too intense on their heads.