Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Broken sanding belts

Posts

Broken sanding belts

#1

Broken sanding belts

Dave Klear

>Hello to everyone. I've lurked off and on for years. Finally have a question.

I have several sanding belts that I bought some time back. The glue joints have failed. Since the breaks are clean I was thinking of re-glueing them and pressing them back together. Is this possible and what is the best glue.

Thanks

Re: Broken sanding belts

#2

Re: Broken sanding belts

RobV

>I have tried everything from Elmer's glue to epoxy to polyurethane to silicone to super glue all with zero success.

What I have been told is that manufactures use a heated silicone adhesive that contains fibers in it, applied in an ultra thin layer with intense clamping pressure - I don't know how true that is, but whatever they do there seems to be some secret ingredient that I as a hobbiest don't have access to.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#3

Re: Broken sanding belts

steve mackay

>I've tried it also. Several times with several glues . . . zip. After the last attempt I looked at how much effort and time I had put into it against the eight or ten buscks for new ones . . . ( 5 at HF ! ) hand me the new ones. Going further . . . I even tried cutting up the failed ones to use on the sanding block. Not much good there either. Rob is Right . . . they make 'em with some kind of mo-jo that I ain't got.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#4

Re: HF ? Now thats a disturbing trend

Chuck in ND

>Lately I've noticed in another forum that the HF threads are geting an amazeing amount of attention. You'd think people would get tired of buying junk.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#5

Re: HF ? Now thats a disturbing trend

Bill White

>As we used to say when I was motorcycling---"$10.00 helmet for a $10.00 head."

Ya gets what ya pays for.

Bill

Re: Broken sanding belts

#6

Re: Broken sanding belts

BilWil

>I don't know what brand yours are; however, I had a similar experience with Klingspore belts - the high end ones and called them. They explained that the glue they used would age and get weaker with time. Therefore, I shouldn't buy more thatn I was going to use over the next 6 to 8 months. I have followed that suggestion for years now and not had any more problems. As an aside, they did send me some belts at no cost to me - may explain why I still do business with them.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#7

The Lemons Principle

Scott Crumpton

>In a market where the consumer is either unwilling or unable to make a quality judgment between competing products, they will on average choose the cheaper of the two. The inevitable result of this is that quality products are driven out of the market, or relegated to a high priced nitch, leaving only lemons for the mass market. A quick Google search on "The Market for Lemons" will yield a nice Wikipedia article along with the original paper from The Quarterly Journal of Economics.

Consider what has happened to some of the "old line" quality names in the tool business. It's become quite difficult to shop for quality based on brand name. The result being an attitude along the lines of "It's all crap made in China and I don't need the best anyway, so I'll save what money I can."

Corporate America has brought this upon us in their relentless quest for MORE PROFIT (greed).

---Scott.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#8

Now they tell me.

Basil

>I bought a "LOAD" of their belts a few years ago at a bargain. I can attest to the facts stated in the above post....as soon as the "old" belts get a little warm...they fly appart.

Sometimes a bargain isn't a bargain.

I still buy their belts and use them. I just buy 2 or 3 at a time now.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#9

The Technology must have changed

Barry Irby

>I have a drawer that I stuff used belts into. I use them again for nasty stuff that would quickly ruin a new belt. (OK, I'm a packrat and cheap) Some of those belts are twenty years old. They are the old style that can only be run in one direction. Almost none of them fail at the seam, but the newer ones do. Not sure this is a big improvement.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#10

Flawed conclusion

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>You wrote:

Data: "... the consumer ...will on average choose the cheaper of the two [products]."

Conclusion: "Corporate America has brought this[cheap products] upon us in their relentless quest for MORE PROFIT (greed)".

Do you see the error in your conclusion? The correct conclusion, if the premise statement is correct, is that consumer choice has resulted in lower quality of some products.

On the other hand I prefer my modern car, computer, heat pump, chain saw, etc. to the ones I owned 30 years ago. Which wood working suppliers do you think are making unreasonable (greedy) profits? Most of the companies I follow are struggling to make any profit.

And while we are on the sanding belt topic, the adhesives and techniques available for assembling sanding belts are much better today than 30 years ago. I like Klingspor's "thumpless" belts. Ditto for the abrasive on this belt, as we now have available zirconia and ceramic abrasives that last much longer, materials developed because Norton, and others, had profit to do research.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#12

missed the other part of the premise

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>"In a market where the consumer is either unwilling or unable to make a quality judgment between competing products..."

Klingspor's belts are better because there were customers willing to make a quality judgment, and pay for the difference.

In markets where customers treat products only as commodities, markets where not enough people understand the quality difference, cheap rules all. This isn't a situation likely to make craftsmen, who often value quality more than profit, very happy.

Profit motives can drive markets to quality or away from it, depending on the customers. Right now, I feel like we're coming off at least fifty years where the scale has tilted to cheaper products for customers the manufacter hopes don't know any better.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#13

The good old belts.

Basil

>I know what you mean. I have a Delta 4x36? stationary belt sander with a worn out 15 year old belt on it. I don't know who made the belt but I'd sure like to know who made the glue.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#14

HF belts . . .

steve mackay

>I get five belts for 'bout eight bucks. While I'm right there I pick up two snot blocks for a couple more bucks. For about ten or twelve dollars I'm fixed up for four or five months. This is WAY longer than if I'd bought more expensive belts. A ten dollar belt from Sears didn't last any longer than a HF belt. Probably made in the same place. I also get a big box of chip brushes that will last me a year or more for under ten dollars. HF expendables ? Big yes. HF tools or equipment ? No.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#16

Re: Flawed conclusion

Scott Crumpton

>The cause is open to interpretation. I'm no economist and was only attempting to paraphrase the principle as I understand it. The effect, whatever the actual cause, does appear quite evident in commodities (as mentioned by another) and a lot of people consider tools commodities.

Myself, I've bought some of the best tools, some crap, and a lot in between. It all depends on the use to which the tool will be applied.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#17

Re: Broken sanding belts

Scott Crumpton

>I also use Klingspore belts. I always store them in zip lock bags in a cool location with as much air squeezed out as possible. I suspect that it's an oxidation effect or reaction with other airborne chemicals that weakens the glue. I've had good luck so far.

I wonder if it would help to fill the bags with argon from the welder? Or CO2? I know it helps to preserve varnish in the can to spray in a little CO2 or argon before closing it up.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#18

Re: Broken sanding belts

Yonak

>I use helium. That also solves the storage problem. I always know I can find them up between the rafters.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#19

Re: The good old belts.

RobV

>The old belts that could only be run one direction used half-lap joints - the new belts are done with butt joints with a cloth glued to the back side.

I too have some that are 25+ years old that work fine, but anything I bought within the last 5-10 years is falling apart.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#20

Re: Broken sanding belts

AZ, Colorado Springs

>HF ? Please fill me in ...

Thanks

Re: Broken sanding belts

#21

HF = Harbor Freight

Al Kapocius

>

Re: Broken sanding belts

#22

Or, as we call it in my family, Horrible Fright

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Broken sanding belts

#23

Re: missed the other part of the premise

Tom MacGregor

>I can buy superior quality Kingspor belts for about half the price of the Craftsman belts a Sears. If you can access products from a company with a professional/commercial/industrial customer base they may be manufacturing in large enough quantities to sell a quality product at an attractive price.

Re: Broken sanding belts

#24

Re: missed the other part of the premise

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>If you're a customer who knows enough to find Klingspor belts in the first place, you're not the under-educated customer Scott was talking about in the first place.

It's also not just the supplier's scale that matters. You're also likely willing to buy ten or more belts at a time if you really want the cheaper price. (At least on the 6x48 belts I was looking at.)

Yes, it's possible to find deals that are genuinely better stuff at lower cost if you know where to look and especially if you're willing to buy in bulk. Cheaper isn't always worse and more expensive isn't always better quality.

However, in the big picture, when price is the main driver and customers don't know the details, Scott's description is accurate.