Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Saw Stop Miss fire

Posts

Saw Stop Miss fire

#1

Saw Stop Miss fire

Dwain

>I'm about to make a TBS purchase and I've narrowed my choice down to two saws. The new Delta and Saw Stop. In calling around one thing I was told is that there is the situation of some Saw Stop TBS's that fire off the safety stopping device in error.

I know every process has it's inherent error. I'm wondering if anyone else has heard of this or seen any hard stats on the issue.

Thank you,

Dwain

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#2

Re: Search the threads

Brian in Brighton

>Dwain, this has been discussed quite a bit here. You might get even more answers if you do a search thru the archives.

I have not heard of any misfires or any failures yet.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#3

Re: Search the threads

Dwain

>Thank you Brian

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#4

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I would contact SawStop directly as well as the CPSC. Remember, the system was offered to the main toolmakers who all turned their backs on it, so the inventor went out, raised funding, and started his own company. The result being he's kicking some serious ass in the saw market, so there is a clear incentive for any number of parties adversely affected by his success to start false rumors of defects via the Internet.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#5

It's a feature, not a bug!

Neal in San Jose

>I'm the happy owner of a Saw Stop, and am familar with the feature you are talking about, at least what I think you are talking about. There have been mis-fires reported with very green pressure treated wood that apparently has enough conductivity to fool the saw into thinking it's touching skin, altho the saw is smart enough to know what is happening, and will simply turn the motor off and give you an error without firing usually. It is possible it would do this with very green wood, but I think the wood would have to be still growing for that to happen, LOL. There have also been mis-fires reported sawing siding that has aluminum foil on the inside as well as other metal in the wood like old nails. It is important to remember that the metal must touch both the blade and either another part of the saw (top, for instance) or the operator for it to fire.

Saw Stop recognized this, and made it possible to turn off the brake so that it doesn't fire accidentally. If you are unclear if the wood you are about to cut might fire the brake, all you have to do is: without turning the motor on touch the material to the blade and the table top (normal sawing position) and see what error code you get. If it doesn't show an error code, you are good to go. If it does show an error, you can defeat the brake for that cut, but the saw will default back to normal operation (brake on) the next time you turn it on, so you can't forget that you turned the brake off.

HTH Neal

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#6

More error codes to have to look up?

charlie belden

>As if desktop, laptop and now netbbook computer hardware and software Error Codes aren't enough - now you have to have an Error Code Look Up Table for a table saw? Tricky enough with some of the lathes that are out there. Now the table saw as well?

Wonder if the Safety folks include ulcers, high blood pressure, strokes, migraine headaches and other stress related consequences of a Safety Issue Solution in their analysis?

Now where did I leave that phreakin' Error Code Look Up Table - this time? I had it in my hand out in the shop. Then I came in to use The Head - and then went in the kitchen to get some coffee - and checked the mail - answered the phone and then went to the kid's soccer game - then to the pizza parlor (g r r r r r r r o a n).

Pizza Parlor janitor:

Oh oh - someone left their Saw Stop Error Code Look Up Table. Poor bastard. Now he's REALLY screwed. I guess he'll just have to download a copy off the Saw Stop site. No wait, that might lead to a computer error - and an error code. Looks like he's screwed. Oh well.

How come no one has come up with a fool proof way of protecting us from our kids. "Catch daddy!" - yelled as the thrown object strikes the back of the father's head.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#7

Nice post... rotflmao

Victor Parisian

>

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#8

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>We just installed a Saw Stop in our carpenter shop at work. If memory serves right, the manual indicated that when sawing Wolmanized or other "wet" materials, the user was urged to disable the brake mechanism to prevent an accidental trip. There also seems to be some kind of memory device imbedded in the brake cartidge and if it tripped, the cartridge could be sent to the manufacturer and they could some how tell if the trip was due to a wet material or human.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#9

Re: More error codes to have to look up?

steve mackay

>Sorry, I know I'm cheap and petty but . . . I didn't even know that thing HAD error codes, passwords and access majic words. If you DID loose the manual and instructions I wonder how long it would take to get back to cut'n wood.

OK . . . fire the heat rounds !

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#10

Re: It's a feature, not a bug!

Barry Irby

>It Seems Neal has explained it well.

I don't own a Sawstop, but if I were buying a saw today and could afford it, I would. The Sawstop feature may be the only Game Changer in the ts world in fifty years.

To avoid getting hurt on the TS, you have to be right every time. Get it wrong once, and you could be seriously injured. Many people here have had TS accidents ranging from minor to very serious. I have.

There does seem to be the potential for a PITA with the Sawstop. For example, if you are cutting wet wood and choose to disable the brake, you would have to do it over and over if you turn the saw off to adjust it between cuts. I can see myself forgetting the disable step after about a few dozen cuts. Also, I think you have to change the shoe in the saw when you switch to a dado set, and then change it back when you go back to the regular blade.

From a different perspective, it seems there is another misfire possibility. That is, it fails to fire when it should. I wonder if there are any of those cases. The machine sits there years on end and has to react instantly when you make a mistake. 99% would not be good enough here.

The Delta saw is a fine tool and it has a riving knife, something not on the Sawstop saw. OTOH, The Delta saw is never going to fire when you make a mistake.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#11

Um, Barry

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Every SawStop I've seen has a euro-style riving knife (rather than a "splitter") installed and part of the design.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#12

SawStop Status Codes

charlie belden

>So you don't have to download the SawStop PDF format manual, here are the Status Codes for the SawStop - Green and Red lights, each with three display modes - on, on blinking slowly and on blinking quickly - for a total of TWELVE combinations. The next to last two seem to be important - if they mean that if you use the saw in "normal mode" - the cartridge will fire - and you'll need to replace it and the blade - before you can use the saw again. Note that you CANNOT use the saw without a working cartridge installed. So if you get a SawStop - make sure to order and extra cartridge or two - just in case.

Now given how quickly things become obsolete and and parts often No Longer Available after some period of obselesence - are any of these current model saws going to be working or restorable 10, 15 or 20 years from now - like 50 year old Oliver or Rockwell saws are.


img

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#13

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

Jesse Cloud

>The community college where I take classes has 4 saw stops that run pretty much all day six days a week, and some nights. Though we get good instruction, newbies are likely to abuse the machines often.

We have had very few 'errors' over the year they have been running, only two that I know of and its hard to be sure there wasn't some user error involved as well. I know for sure that one appropriate fire saved a student's fingers.

Given those numbers, I wouldn't hesitate to have one in my shop. They said it costs about $75 to replace the firing mechanism and you will probably have to replace or repair the blade as well.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#14

My Bad......

Barry Irby

>Since I am too broke to afford a riving knife or a splitter let alone a SawStop or a new Delta Unisaw, I have not examined either closely. All my major tools are Delta and I like them. I have a contractors saw and If I had known I would be sitting in this house after thirty years, I would have had a Unisaw. I thought there was a riving knife or splitter on the new Unisaw that was not on the Sawstop.

My point was that I read that the new Delta saw is a fine upgrade to an iconic saw but still based on fifty or hundred year old technology. I read the Sawstop is a fine saw based on the same technology and matches the performance of other saws in this class, but it has this additional feature that may/should/has saved the absent minded, inattentive, careless, unlucky, among us from sawing off a finger or worse.

Having cut myself on the TS, I can tell you that $75/100 for a new cartridge and $100/125 for a new blade would be cheap. Really Cheap. And much less painful. Oh, and there might be the cost replacing my underwear.

Other than those minor inconveniences of turning the feature off to cut wet stuff and changing the shoe for a dado set, I don't see any down side to owning a Sawstop. It would function as well or better than my existing saw and I would never know if the Delta saw might have done some function slightly better.

I can't believe I am "pro" new technology. I am an old fuddy duddy and reluctant to change. I don't need no stinking laser sites on my tools. But I like my fingers attached to my hands.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#15

Still Got

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>All ten although the bone in my left thumb is a bit (or bite) shorter than it was originally.

Even though insurance paid most of it, I, like you, would have traded the "experience" for a matched set of SawStop machines.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#16

Re: My Bad......kind of

Fred Davis

>Barry ,

Your respect for Delta tools is well placed and here is one reason why I think that.

I purchased a new 8" D J 20 jointer in about 1999 or 2000 and it performed flawlessly until last year when the eccentrics holding the front and back tables co-Planar moved..

Overland tool in Lenexa , Kansas had the only Millwright in the state that could readjust this problem to specs.

Six months after the first visit , another became necessary for the same reason at a total cost to me of 604.00.

Though Overland tool didn't sell me the Jointer, they talked to the District manager of Delta (now owned by B @ D ) and he has authorized the replacement of the machine with a new one and Overland tool will install a Shellix head for about 450.00.

That impresses the hell out of me and Overland tool has a new customer and my faith in Delta tools is still alive and well.

About your post on SawStop, I have often wondered how replacing a fucntion of your brain with a expensive gadget would work for all of the other machines that will cut anything you stick into them in your shop, like a Shaper , Router , Chopsaw, Jointer, Planer and so on.

Even inattention to the use of nail guns and staplers will hurt you .

OTOH I wouldn't mind owning the company that makes the replacement cartridges for SawStop. ;-))

FredD

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#17

Re: My Bad......kind of

Barry Irby

>Fred, I would like to think that adding the Sawstop feature would not make me any less attentive and that I would still work with the care and attention to detail I do now. I don't think I drive any sloppier than I did when I did not have air bags. I certainly don't think having a Sawstop would reduce my care around my other tools. But, when I hurt my hand on my Delta Contractors saw, Its safety mechanism did not fire, because it does not have one. Fortunately, what I got was some rather serious abrasions and whatever happened was so quick I don't know what I did wrong. It was just a flesh wound as they used to say in the old cowboy movies.

Come to think of it, I had a car accident and was going just fast enough to fire the air bag. The air bag hurt me more than anything else. I was breaking hard and blowing the horn. The air bag put an enormous contusion on my arm. had it not been for that, I would not have been hurt at all.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#18

Re: My Bad......kind of

Fred Davis

>Barry ,

here's one for you , I hit a 450 pound bull cafe last Monday a week ago with my 3/4 ton pickup at night , overcast and on Blacktop and the cafe was a Black Angus who was trotting down the highway away from me and I didn't see it in near enough time to stop.

Neither of the Air bags went off, 5 grand damage to the front end , no damage or sheet metal , just destroyed the Bumper , Grill , lights , condenser for the AC and will need a wheel alignment.

I was lucky that my friend who owns Belaire body shop had a Ford Ranger with 24,000 miles on it , when he bought it from a tow company for charges unpaid after a year.

He fixed the damage to it caused by a roll over and it looked and drove like new.

Last Tuesday night coming back from Bowling like the first time a week previously, the engine started making a racket and the oil light came on. In a quarter mile I found a driveway to get off the road and called Dunlaps tow service again and said , John , guess what?

Ruined the engine.

Another example of a gadget replacing a gauge .. A pressure gauge regularly observed by the operator would more then likely headed off this mishap.

Keep your wits about you in a shop environment, rely on common sense to warn you of a booby trap and enjoy your wood working.

FredD

FredD

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#19

Re: My Bad......kind of

Barry Irby

>So, How did the calf make out? Was it tasty?

When I was a kid I drove at night past the local stock yard. There was an on-coming tractor trailer and out of nowhere a black cow standing in the road. My Step mother was with me and she never saw the cow. To this day she insists I ran into the ditch for no reason at all. Even after the local cops herded the cow back to the stock yard.

This time I was driving home in the rain and a turkey crashes into the windshield and broke it. There is an amazing amount of poop in a turkey. The wipers smeared it. Then cleared enough of it for me to see the car in front of me had stopped to make a left. I was already slowing, but it was too late.

It was big fender bender for me. The state has some rule that if the damage exceeds a certain percentage of the value of the car they withdraw your title and issue you a Salvage Title. Its to keep body shops from buying junked cars, fixing them and selling them without revealing it was a junker. So, to add insult to injury and to protect me from me, they have reduced the value of my car to next to nothing. No discretion, no thought, no consideration to the fact that there was no frame or system damage, just boom. More Nanny State. And they were astoundingly difficult to deal with. Always difficult to deal with the pious and righteous, because they know they are dealing with criminals and low-lifes and God is on their side. OTOH, it was fatal for the turkey. One less marauding turkey in the world.

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#20

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

Brian in Brighton

>I have been told at trade shows that the blade and cartridge will both need to be replaced as they are wedged together and you will have comprimised the metal in the blade. $100 for a blade + $75 for the cartridge is still a lot less than $50,000+ for finger surgery. Heck, the pain alone without any costs would not be worth having my fingers cut off.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#21

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire *LINK*

Edward McCormack

>Check out my website to see what the Saw Stop can prevent. I bought a saw stop as soon as i could. www.sweatynubwoodworking.com


my web site

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#23

I know of one...

Grant in Iowa

>Guy I know has a SawStop in a multi tenant industrial building. he is one of the first tenants and the building is still under renovation.

He was using his Sawstop to cut lumber in a rip configuration and wasn't even in contact with the saw table yet (still well behind the table feeding stock in). The lumber was one that is Sawstop compatible, though I do not know what species.

He was sawing away with the DC also running and the Sawstop fired. At the same moment his DC quit and tripped its breaker (different circuit on the same panel). All signs point to a voltage sag or similar electrical event, given that the DC tripped its breaker.

He sent off his chip to the sawstop people for analysis. No word yet on what they have to say.

Woodworker II blade warped and useless. Sawstop cartridge used up.

No skin contact with the table nor blade.

A definate misfire, though one may be able to point to an electrical issue of some sort. If the thing can fire when there are such electrical issues, that could get pricey quick around my place where power fluctuations are a common occurrance...

Yeah, I know it is worth its weight in gold for the one time you do come in contact with the blade...

Regards,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Saw Stop Miss fire

#24

Sorry, should be under SawStop misfire.

Grant in Iowa

>