Another direction...
Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN
>Does the blackness wash off for the most part?
Do you have trees overhanging the house?
Do you have organic material close to the house (bushes, flowers, ground cover, mulch)?
In my painting career, by far the houses in the worst shape are those in heavily wooded areas and/or with vegetation close or touching the house. East of the Mississippi, the biggest foe for exterior paint is moisture, with large temperature swings being a close second. If you have trees overhanging the house, or bushes and the like close to it, things don't dry out, and more importantly, they shed organic matter onto the paint surfaces which becomes mold/mildew food.
If the mold/mildew is in or under the surface of the paint, then you have moisture behind the paint film, and that needs to be fixed for any paint to have any shot at lasting long term. Backpriming properly dried (acclimated) wood before exterior application goes a long way in this respect.
You can add a mildecide to exterior paints, though it can cause deeper colors to fade sooner. Many top-shelf exterior paints come with some amount of mildecide in their formula.
Jason