Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

OT What do we eat??

Posts

OT What do we eat??

#1

OT What do we eat??

Barry Irby

>I saw some animal rights person say we should not eat animals and that perhaps we should not eat plants either. He thought we should manufacture our food.

My question is: Do we eat anything that is manufactured? I was thinking about salt. Its a chemical that is mined or dropped out of sea water. Other than that, what else is there? Non Dairy creamers?

Is there any beneficial food we eat in any quantity that is not plant or animal based?

Re: OT What do we eat??

#2

Aluminum Foil

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>For his hat. Then sit him/her down in front of Star Trek reruns featuring a "replicator" machine that makes food using hydrogen atoms as the basic building blocks.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#3

Re: OT What do we eat??

AndiWolfe

>Very strange ideas from that unnamed "activist."

Plants are producers in the ecosystem and the base of the nutrient cycle. Carnivores are at the top of the food chain, herbivores are in the middle. That's basic ecology 101. . .

Humans are omnivores. Our modern diet is mostly poisonous to our bodies - we are not adapted to high sugar, high salt, high fat, processed carb, and over-processed foods. I shudder to think what "manufactured" food would do to us. . .

Re: OT What do we eat??

#4

McStuff

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I pretty sure "McStuff"....... the playdough like substance that they press into shape to make all the food at McDonalds (french fries, burgers, buns, milkshakes)..... is man-made and is not derived from any plant or animal matter.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT What do we eat??

#5

Basic Ecology 101

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I always wondered why they bothered to teach us this in school.... I mean, it's pretty self-evident, no? I think I figured out most of this myself walking through the woods as a child.

Apparently not, because this guy Barry is talking about must be the result of skipping this course in elementary school.

I think plants and animals are rather tasty. Some more than others, mind you.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT What do we eat??

#6

Soylent Green?

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

>No, wait. We can't eat that either because..........IT'S PEOPLE!

Re: OT What do we eat??

#7

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Very simple rule....

Jesper, Denmark

>In the order of living organisms: Eat or get eaten.

There are no other choices.

Whether you want to be a carnivore, omnivore or herbivore is up to you, but omnivore is likely to be the best strategy.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#8

JL

Re: OT What do we eat??

JL

>There is a doctrine/religion called Jainism. The people who practice it are called Jains. The basic Jain belief is that everything has a soul or souls. The more organized the organism, the more or higher the souls. Thus, a rock has a simple soul, a plant has a more complex soul and an animal has an even more complex soul. A Jain won't kill an insect because it adds to his/her karmic burden. A Jain will often become a vegetarian. In extreme cases a Jain will starve himself/herself to death.

Sounds like your friend should go that way :).

Re: OT What do we eat??

#9

Reminds me

Dan Donaldson

>I was reading a weblog once that was talking about hunting. One of the comments on the thread was something to the effect that we should not hunt, but get all of our meat from the store so that no animals are harmed. ;-) Not sure where they thought the meat in the store came from.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#10

Re: Reminds me

Barry Irby

>Reminds me of the guy who said "Get your government hands off my Medicare!". Except he probably said "gummit hanes".

My problem was I couldn't think of anything that was "manufactured" that we eat. Salt was as close as I got. Still not sure what some of those Non-dairy things are. They may be made of things derived from other food products, just not dairy. Maybe some of the sweeteners would qualify. I just can't think of anything that was not plant or animal based in some fashion that qualifies as a main food stuff.

McDonald's did apply for an exemption to be a manufacturer rather than a food processor. Some tax thing. They were denied, I think.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#11

urea, if you are a cow..........

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Urea can be made from non-living materials. It can be used as a nitrogen supplement for ruminants. Most, if not all, of the vitamins can, and probably are, made synthetically. Any of the amino acids can/are be made synthetically but I don't know if any are used as supplements in human diets. They are in animal feed, especially lysine and methionine. Carbohydrates can be made synthetically but it is not practical to do so.

But, the raw material for these synthetic materials is oil or coal, which could be argued is, or at least was, a plant source.

I am reminded of a bill board that said "make room for animals" (there was a picture of Bambi or something similar).....right next to the mashed potatoes.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#12

Mushrooms

Curly Smith

>are neither plant nor animal based.

Manufactured foods would include: bread, beer, wine, cheese, yogurt (all with harvested produce plus yeast and the harvesting doesn't damage the base plant/animal) plus butter.

If you add eggs and honey that can also be harvested without damage to the base animal then you can have a very tasty and satisfying diet... if you add some beef, pork, fish, chicken, and vegetables.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#13

Jack La Laine says ...

Mike Farinella

>If a human has touched it, don't eat it. Stay away from "engineered" foods. I tend to agree.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#14

Re: OT What do we eat??

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>Become a food label reader. If it has four syllables, or you can't pronounce it, or you have never seen the word before, you probably do not want to eat it. Ingrediants are listed in order of quantity. That is why you see four/five different sugars listed. That way it doesn't look like 50%+ sugar as the main ingrediant. Several years ago, Frito-Lay came out with a new chip: Applewood smoked, bleu cheese potato chips. Ingrediants: potatos, oil, salt, bleu cheese, smoke, and the last seven (all dyes from petroleum). The bag stayed in the store. Discontinued in less than a year. If there was really some smoke and cheese in them, what were the dyes for?

Re: OT What do we eat??

#15

Re: Soylent Green?

IEW

>Yes We Can!!!!!

Re: OT What do we eat??

#16

Re: Soylent Green?

IEW

>Tastes just like Grandma!!!

Re: OT What do we eat??

#17

Re: urea, if you are a cow..........

Alex Grigoriev

>Urea was the first "organic" substance ever synthesised from "inorganic" substances. That took a mystery out of "organic" chemistry concept.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#18

MREs . . .

steve mackay

>Well, the first ones at least. They were manufactured on Mars from things not of THIS Earth so should be in the running. No animal or plant products.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#19

And they Came With Little Bottles Of Tobasco Sauce

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: OT What do we eat??

#20

And the irony is...

John in NM

>That most wild animals probably live a better life (and perhaps longer) than the average factory chicken or feed lot cow. Cows around here do at least spend most of their lives out in the field, only go to a feed lot when they get sold to a meat processor or middle man. Chickens and pigs though.... less cruel to shoot a deer IMHO, too bad there aren't more available.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#21

Re: And the irony is...

Barry Irby

>Locally, the wildlife people tell us there are more deer now than in Colonial times. Local farmers are often thrilled when responsible hunters will take some of them. My cousin raises nursery stock and there was so much deer damage that she got a permit to harvest the deer. She can take as many as she can. Turns the meat over to people that will use it. Some of it goes to a Hunters for the Hungry type program.

Re: OT What do we eat??

#22

That's good to hear!

John in NM

>

Re: OT What do we eat??

#23

The people who complain about MRES

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>never had the pleasure of dining on C-RATS

Re: OT What do we eat??

#24

Re: McStuff

Bill White

>The alternative to "processed" food is eating the animal alive which is very messy and noisey.

Don't get me started on the foodniks.

Bill

Re: OT What do we eat??

#25

Re: The people who complain about MRES

Glenn Madsen

>I did a computer network consult, years ago, for the owner of a plant that made MREs in McAllen, TX. They flew me in from California for the gig, after I did their CA headquarters. It looked like a reasonable place to make shrink-wrapped, durable foodlike stuffs that could be dropped by parachute anywhere in the world on short notice.

They wanted me to take over the IT operation. McAllen, TX, though, had no appeal at all for me or the family.

We still eat pretty well. ;)