Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

torsion boxes

Posts

torsion boxes

#1

torsion boxes

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>Does anyone know of a good overview on how (and when) to make torsion boxes?

I have a few different projects where I think they'd be a good idea, but most of the information I'm finding is all about building torsion boxes for specific projects, not an overview that would help me decide whether to use them or how best to build them.

Thanks!

Re: torsion boxes

#2

Re: torsion boxes

Don at Central Illinois

>I picked up a book on making office furniture from Taunton Press by Jim Tolpin. Had a good section on torsion box as a desk top but it had a lot of good general information on torsion boxes.

Re: torsion boxes

#3

Re: torsion boxes

Bill Howatt

>I have only done one to make a floating shelf about 8' long and say 12" or so deep. Looks nice without any supports underneath it.

I made a frame out of 3/4"x1-5/8" on edge with a long (8') piece front and back and short pieces connecting them on around 16" centers. I then glued on 1/4" ply skins top and bottom with each overhanging one side by 1-1/2" along the length. I fastened a 2x4 to the wall that had been ripped to 1-5/8" wide to match the thickness of the shelf between the overhanging ply. I then mounted the shelf by screwing the top and bottom overhanging ply to the ripped 2x4. I then wrapped the shelf edges with clear pine.

Bill

Re: torsion boxes

#4

Ellis Walentine

Kirby was the major proponent

Ellis Walentine

>I give Ian Kirby a lot of credit for promoting torsion boxes in this country. He wrote a fine article for us at American Woodworker (Issue #63, December '97) about the process. It tells you many of the hows and wherefores you're asking about. In a nutshell, one of the salient lessons of that article is not to make the rib spacing any more than about 12 times the thickness of the skin. this helps prevent the skin from sagging, which isn't much of an issue anyway unless you're using really thin plywood, such as doorskin. The construction pattern is a butt-jointed grid, held together with staples while you roll on the glue and clamp the box together. It is the glue lines between the top and bottom edges of the grid and the skins that are important.

I used to make torsion boxes frequently in my custom interior work. You want to use them whenever you need rigidity and dimensional stability that exceeds the ability of an ordinary shelf or tabletop to span without sagging.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: torsion boxes

#5

Why don't you describe what you are Planning?

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>You can get advice which is specific to your need, if you don't find the information you are after.

Re: torsion boxes

#6

Kirby in FWW #32, too...

David Barnett - SW FL Gulf Coast

>Although most build torsion boxes for rigidity, light weight and savings on materials, it's sometimes useful to add infill mass and/or damping before gluing the top skin, especially if your end use is a work surface where percussive effects are involved.

Torsion boxes are so strong I think most are overbuilt. Very thin core lattices with thin skins can support amazing weights, especially when such loads are well-distributed. My platform bed must support in excess of 45 stone, of which over 35 is me. It's overbuilt with hardboard core. Corrugated cardboard or styrofoam would still easily intercede for gravity.

Re: torsion boxes

#7

have about four different possibilities

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>from a 4x8' base for a lumber cart to a 12"x24" shelf to support some heavy items.

Thanks!

Re: torsion boxes

#9

Your answers are so vague, it is hard to visualize

Keith Newton------WebKitFormBoundaryV6MZb+tiOpocz6

>what you are planning. If you are going to make a cart to transport and or store plywood flat, I would suggest that you re-think that idea.

I have a couple that I use in my shop which have an A frame where the panels lean against both sides of the A. The base comes out about 12" to each side, then I have stake pockets along the sides, where I can insert a couple of pipe, to lean panels against when I want to get the first panel on the inside out first. If you stack flat and want the one of the bottom, you will need to unload the whole cart.

When I build a torsion box otherwise, I normally rip the grid parts from 1/4" ply, then crosscut the dados on the TS sled while the parts are taped together in a tight stack. A loose fit on the width of the dado makes for easier assembly at glue-up, with no loss of strength in the final product.

When gluing up, I like to use thickened epoxy rolled onto both panels and edges of the stacked grid parts. If you are relying only on glue, remember that, if you are gluing onto plywood, the strength of the finished piece depends on the first ply of those panels to be really well glued on. The glue-lines of lots of plywood can be poorly glued on.

I use a vacuum bag to pull it all together while the epoxy cures.

Re: torsion boxes

#10

Rick L

Re: Torsion Box Official Manual *LINK*

Rick L

>Go to page 208 on Ken's Book. He takes up where Kirby left off. It's the bible for torsion box info. All his books are a great read.


Ken Horner, More Woodworker, Essential...

Re: torsion boxes

#11

Rick L

Re: I couldn't believe you use dados...

Rick L

>to make torsion boxes. Read Ken's book on torsion box making. Torsion boxes are quick,strong and can be very ight. Dados are sloooooow...and add time to a simple thing. Torsion boxes are great for curves and such if you stick with the original formula.

Re: torsion boxes

#12

Rick L

Re: Four possibilities....?!?!?!?!

Rick L

>The ones you mention don't need torsion boxes based on the little info you posted. Wish folks would be more definitve in their questions and they would get better answers. Often the answer would be in a total different direction. What you think you need and what you really need are often two different things. I deal with this everyday as a problem solver at work.

Re: torsion boxes

#14

Sometimes questions are broad

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>because plans are still very rough.

I have a lot of ideas that could use torsion boxes, but was seeking an overview in large part to figure out if they're the right answer.

I'll be perfectly happy if I find that torsion boxes aren't the right answer. However, they seem like a right enough answer to a lot of problems that I'd like to find out more about them along the way.

Thanks for the book reference - that looks like the right direction, for this and a lot of other questions!

Re: torsion boxes

#15

Thanks

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>No, I'm not crazy enough to want to store plywood flat. Some kind of frame is definitely part of that project.

The reason a torsion box is appealing for that one is that the area where the cart will normally sit isn't flat, in strange ways only understood (maybe) by whoever built this house. I've already twisted enough carts there to think I need something stronger than your average board. I'll post more on it when I get it built, hopefully over the winter.

Beyond that, in the farther future I have a few projects that may or may not benefit from torsion boxes. I'd like to learn what I can to be able to evaluate and possibly build those, but the details just don't exist yet. For that, general information on torsion boxes is a lot more useful than detailed plans for specific ones.

Re: torsion boxes

#16

Re: torsion boxes

Chris Friesen

>Torsion boxes are useful when you want to build something that is strong for its weight.

For a given amount of strength, a torsion box will always be thicker (exactly how much varies) than a solid beam of the same material. However, it will be lighter.

Like any beam, the stiffness of a torsion box goes with the cube of the thickness--make it twice as thick and it's 8x as strong. However, with a torsion box it's relatively easy to make it much thicker as the box is mostly hollow space.

On a torsion box, the bottom skin will be in tension and the top skin will be in compression. It's important that they both be well bonded to the ribs. The ribs act basically as spacers to keep an even gap between the two skins.

Re: torsion boxes

#17

thanks

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>The combination of stiff and lightweight is what I'm looking for, yes.

Thanks!

Re: torsion boxes

#18

Re: thanks

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Ian Kirby's article is a great overview. The torsion box chapter in Ken Horner's book is good at providing an engineer's perspective. He gives you information, mathematical analysis and and even formulas. Torsion box math can get very complex and involves a lot of variables that are not commonly available. The math he provides is used for comparative illustration only. He does not provide a cookbook for building torsion boxes. There are a few places where his information can be misinterpreted, also. In my article in the next (Dec/Jan 2010) issue of American Woodworker, I try to step back and provide some general guidelines for woodworkers.

Different applications require different torsion box construction- a work bench or assembly table will require a different structure and materials than a decorative wall shelf. The characteristics of the materials play an important part. As an example, in my article there is a photo of a 8'L x 18"W x 2.5" thick torsion box I made from 3/16" hardboard and yellow glue. I supported each end on saw horses and loaded it with over 300 pounds of bricks, stacked at mid-span where there was only 1/2" of deflection! It is strong and rigid. Would this be good for a workbench subjected to point loads like hammering or clamping? Probably not.

Re: torsion boxes

#19

great to know that's coming!

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

>I'll watch for the magazine - suspect that'll be out soon.

Thanks!