Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Electric Shop Heaters???

Posts

Electric Shop Heaters???

#1

Electric Shop Heaters???

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Push has come to shove. My shop is an addition that I built to my garage. They share a common wall. I've come to the realization that my 500 sf shop is just a little too "cozy" to build furniture without using every tool surface in the shop for laying out parts. So I am finally kicking the cars out of the garage for good and taking over the garage for additional work space. Well, actually 1/2 of the garage will be lumber storage.

I live in Illinois....that means winter. The current shop is heated with a vented natural gas shop heater. Unfortunately the flex gas pipe is undersized to feed two gas heaters. So I will probably need to go with electric. Because the new space will be supplemental work area I won't have to heat it all the time. But when I do need to heat it I'll need to get it to about 50 degrees or so.

I'll be heating about 500 sf of mostly insulated space. I have a 40 amp double pole breaker with 10ga. wire that is currently available. Can anyone offer good suggestions for heaters?

Thanks!

Tom

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#2

How About

Jim Shaver - L6H 6Y0, Canada

>Hi Tommy,

Since the two area's share a common wall how about running a vent through the wall with an electric fan/motor to pull in some heat as required, simple solution.

take care,

Jim


img

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#3

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Gerry In North Surrey

>I used a construction cube heater hardwired into a wall thermostat to heat a 2 car garage sized shop. It worked for me.

Gerry, who's now shopless in Surrey.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#4

Re: How About

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Thought of that but the heater in the shop is not sufficient to heat both areas.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#5

Re: Electric Shop Heaters??? *LINK*

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>Hi Tom,

Several years ago, I bought model # BRH562 for my shop, and my dad bought a couple for his pole barn. It heats 2/3 of an attached 3 car garage to 60 degrees or so in the winter, so I think it would work for you.


Portable Contractor Heaters

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#6

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Jim Shaver - L6H 6Y0, Canada

>Thanks what I use Paul,

take care,

Jim

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#7

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Bill in in

>A 40 A breaker should have a #8 wire....

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#8

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Jesper, Denmark

>Hi Tommy, I Le razoir meant taking heat from the house system, which might have enough capacity. I doubt if the 40 Amp will do you much good other than draining you pockets.

If it is only the flex line for the gas heater that is too small, it is easy to fix. depending on where there is a bigger gas line available, it woould be no big deal to run a 1" line.

It would also not be a big deal to use a propane heater, vented through the wall. Since you will not heat the space all the time, the cost of propane would not be significant.

A non-vented fired heater would give you some undesirable condensate after you turn it off. I am glad to be away from IL winters, but do miss the nice fall weater.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#9

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Norm-Knoxville

>I have the 30amp unit, purchased when it was advertised as a greenhouse heater. Keeps the Tennessee 3 car toasty.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#10

I wouldn't

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi Paul and Thomas

I've used those portable construction heaters for several years to heat my garage/workshop. They put out a lot of heat, have low capital cost (but high operating cost), but in my opinion are not worth the risk.

I'm on my fourth heater now...this one seems a bit better and is addressing some of the safety issues, but these things are way too unreliable to find a permanent home in my shop. If I was not hoping to move to a new house, I would get rid of the things and put something permanent (and safer) in.

The current model of the heater has an upgraded plug that may address the melting around the plug prongs that I've seen on several of the past heaters I've owned. The plug on two heaters degraded until I thought it was a safety hazard and got rid of them.

One heater element failed completely. To me it looks like maybe the fan failed allowing the element to overheat, but the fan still worked.

The failure sprayed some scale from the heater element onto the workbench below. Nothing was scorched, but the potential for disaster is there if some of the scale were to land in a garbage bag full of shavings (which I used to store below the heater). Anything combustible is now stored well away from these heaters.

Here's a picture of the failed element:


Now the strage part, but pehaps explainable - my company has used these construction heaters at work for many years. Some have failed (mostly fan failures), but have never sprayed molten metal around. However, at work we wire them up to 208V, not 220V. At home I've got a full 220V at the plug. I suspect the full 220V shortens the life of these heater elements.

There's been talk in Canada about regulating these things (on the manufacturing side) as numerous failures have occurred.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#11

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Michael Wilkins

>Check with the folks at Grainger. They have several ceiling mounted heaters that are 230 volt electric, with fans and thermostats. I got a 230 volt heater that was sold by Lowes; not sure if they still carry this one, but worth a look. Mine heats my 400 square foot shop with enough heat to allow shirt-sleeve comfort, even though my shop does not have enough insulation.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#12

Re: How About

Brian in Brighton

>My 4 car garage is heated fine with my 45K btu gas heater. Are you sure you would not be better off upgrading your gas heater? I put in a 3 inch vent pipe for it to meet Colorado codes. Electric heaters can suck up an amazing amount of power to heat a large space. I'm talking about $75-100 a month in winter and they take forever to get warm. You might also look into a full burning "blue flame" vent free style wall heater. You would have to run another gas line, but you might not have to vent it. We can't have them in our county, but your's might allow it. You would have to call the county code enforcment to see what is permitted.

I really like my gas unit, it keeps the garage at 55 and can get to 75 in about 20-25 minutes. The only reason it goes as low as 55 is that the thermostat only goes that low.

My gas unit: http://www.northerntool.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_6970_200307959_200307959

A vent free unit: http://www.northerntool.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/product_6970_200332735_200332735

Brian in Brighton

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#13

Re: Electric Shop Heaters??? *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Thomas,

Around 15 years ago I installed two Markel "Bulldog" heaters in my 800 square foot (10,000 cubic foot) garage/shop. The shop walls and ceiling are well insulated with R30 insulation. I did the heat load calculation based on keeping the garage at 55 degrees when it is zero outside. The heaters have worked very well and I like the built-in thermostat. I blow them out at the start of the heating season, but they don't seem to attract much sawdust. This link to the heater is to the updated design (round instead of square, otherwise the same). I don't remember where I purchased them. Hope this helps.

Jim


Markel Heater

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#14

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Rob Lee

>Hi Tom -

We start mailing an email promo on them tomorrow.... so check the website!

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#15

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

Fred Davis

>Electric heat is inefficient and costly compared to Gas.

Look at the gas heaters that mount on top of a Propane bottle , cheapest way to go and fast .

Like the guy said , a 40 amp breaker is rated for #8 wire.

FredD

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#16

Re: I wouldn't

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

>I'm glad nothing serious happened when your heater failed. Thanks for the info - I'll be sure to keep combustibles away from the heater.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#17

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

mdclor

>I used a 3 burner Mr.Heater in a barn shop at one time. I would light one, two or all burners depending on the temp in the barn. It worked well, but beware of the moisture from the propane. It will condense on cold metal surfaces causing rust issues.

Re: Electric Shop Heaters???

#18

5000W wall hung fan unit.

Dale Sherman, Manlius, NY

>Grainger carries a nice one, but you should be able to find it for less elsewhere. You'll only need it to bring the space up to temp quickly, the gas unit should be able to sustain the temp on most days.

If you're well insulated and airsealed, you could probably heat the shop just fine with the gas unit alone and use the electric for supplemental heat only for the bitter cold days.

What size is your gas heater?

Dale