Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Router Fence - Build or Buy

Posts

Router Fence - Build or Buy

#1

Router Fence - Build or Buy

Bob Pierce

>I am at the point where I need a router table (or a shaper, yeah, right...) The two choices seem to be to build or buy. The under cabinetry seems to have build as an easy choice, the surface and fence is a tougher choice.

What have you done, why and have you been happy with your choice?

TYIA

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#2

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Pat Evans

>I received a Jessem table and fence as gifts. Made my decision easy. All I had to do was build the under cabinet. I'm 100% satisfied with the table and 90% satisfied with the fence. I think a split fence would be more functional.

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#3

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Chuck in ND

>I put together a stand and a 1 1/4" top, then bought a Freud fence and a Woodpeckers aluminum insert with ringset. The reason I went with a portable type stand is I don't have the room for a floor model, and mounting one in the tablesaw extension wing I was afraid would get in the way of sawing operations occassionally. I'm very happy with the outcome, it's fairly heavy and solidly built.


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#4

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Barry Irby

>Mine is home made. I took two plastic laminate covered sink cutouts (free from a friend in the cabinet business) and laminated them together back to back. I would think most any counter top shop would give you a bunch. They tend to warp, but laminating them balanced the construction and mine came out very flat. While is was at it, I installed some bolts in one edges so that it bolts on to the edge of my table saw in place of one of the wings. The angle iron rails for the fence help support it. I made a cutout in it and a homemade rectangular base for the router. I use the TS fence for the router also. So, its a pretty crude setup, but it works well for me. I have never had a lift or a split fence, so I don't know what I am missing. I have noticed that about time I get the router setup, I need to rip something on the TS, so I may be getting or making a router fence next. Actually, for a lot of routing, I just clamp a straight edge across the table and use that. Since the router is omnidirectional, the fence does not have to carefully aligned as it does on the TS.

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#5

best place for router item's

del schisler

>here is the best place for router item's I been doing router's for yrs and built the router table and stand here is the site click on the view usa cataloge on the right Than click on the left side as to what you want to view I have been with them bob and rick for a long time They are the best at the router's and supply's

http://www.oak-park.com/index.html

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#6

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Tom Pilsbury (Chicago)

>By all means build it! It's great experience and it will give you a great deal of satisfaction knowing you did it yourself.

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#7

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Jim Dillon

>Bob,

I built my router fence 10+ years ago based on one I saw on the New Yankee Workshop. Here are several pics. The top is 3/4 inch MDF supported underneath by 1x4s on edge surrounding the router opening. It has met all my needs. Hope this helps.

Jim


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#8

Picture #2 

Jim Dillon

>


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Build, Build, Build....

Jesper, Denmark

>I built mine based on the New Yankee Workshop model, mingelated along the way and have been very happy with it.

The dust and chip removal works very well and there are lots of possibilities to modify this as you go.

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#10

Done It Both Ways

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Bob,

My second router table is pictured. My first was patterned after Norm's and featured a successful split fence. It is still used professionally by my #3 son, who is a contractor. When I upgraded, I chose a cabinet with the same basic design as the first, but had a glued-up maple desk top which was dead flat and good looking. I decided to invest in an after market fence from Penn State Industries. It is of extruded aluminum, and has all the necessary features. I bought it because it was readily available, was well designed and had a high fence, would satisfy my needs at a modest price. Never a hassle about wood warping with moisture, never a need for shims. I am delighted. Both work, and work very well. Coupled with a JessEm Mast-R-Lift and a 7518 router, I have precision, reliability, capability and versatility. In my opinion, you can have the same performance in a home made fence, but you'll fuss with it occasionally to keep it that way. Your choice.

George


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#11

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy *LINK*

charlie belden

>Do you want Quick and Dirty - and semi-adequate

or

Well thought out, versatile AND precise?

A router table isn't just a flat surface with a hole in it, a router attached under it and a straight, flat, square to the table fence you can move closer to or farther away from a router bit sticking up out of the table.

Let's start with the table, the router plate and inserts around the opening for the bit. Those three HAVE TO BE in the same plane - if you want good results and to keep control of the stock being routed. You may not absolutely NEED the latter two, 'til you think about it a bit.

You WILL at some point need to be able to remove the router, without detaching it from the table top - hence the need for a removable mounting plate. And if and when you want to use a 3" diameter panel raising bit, a half inch or smaller hole in the mounting plate ain't gonna do it for ya. But if you start with a 3+" hole in the mounting plate, and you're using a quarter inch bit - you've got a GAPING HOLE to get your part acrossed - safely.

Which brings us to inserts in the mounting plate. You want a large enough hole in the plate for the largest bit you may use - at some point in the future. But you also want to be able to put inserts into that Gaping Hole when using smaller diameter bits. Ideally, you want to keep the space around the bit to a minimum - say 1/16th inch clearance around the bit. SO - you'll need multiple inserts to cover a range of bit diamters. And each one has to be able to a) be mounted flush with the table top and mounting plate and b) STAY THERE. Not a trivial problem to solve.

Now about that fence. You WILL have situations which require that some, or most, of the bit is BEHIND the face of that fence. Which means you need to be able to create a gap in the fence for the bit, and some room BEHIND the fence face for the back of the bit. BUT - you want to keep the gap to a minimum - a part being pulled in behind the fence as you begin feeding the stock is NOT a pleasant experience. So you need a fence that basically has an "infeed" side and an "outfeed" side - the face of which must remain coplaner both horizontally and vertically. And both need to be able to move left/right in order to get the minimum gap around the bit.

Oh - and you'll need to move the two parts of the fence together, closer or farther from the bit, sometimes in very small increments - safely.

Getting the picture?

The alternative is to bite the bullet and BUY something that comes with the minimum that's required PLUS a whole lot more - a System.

Two systems that come to mind are from JoinTech and Incra. All the parts of the system are well thought out and well integrated to work - not quite Right Out of the Box - but in a lot less time than you'd spend buidling a minimum system - and then modifiying or rebuilding it - over and over again.

I'm of the Buy Once, Cry Once school. Buy more than you think you'll need and grow into it rather than start with the minimum and either keep modifying it - or grow to hate it. I chose the JoinTech Cabinet Maker System and built a cabinet to go under it. I've used it for routing grooves and rabbets/rebates, edge treatments and the like PLUS - graduated finger joints, dovetails, both through and half blind - with variable spacing - panel raising, cope and stick, . . .

It comes set up to handle featherboards, stops, dust collection - and replaceable, cut to the bit zero clearance inserts, independently adjustable infeed and outfeed fences - AND - precision fence positioning - that all work together with lots of options. Did I mention that it comes with paper "templates" for finger/box joints and dovetail joints.

You can find more about the JoinTech systems at

www.jointech.com

They've got a great line of products and they're very good at customer service. Other than being a very satisfied customer, I have no connection to JoinTech.


My JoinTech set up

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#12

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

Fred Davis

>I bought a basic well made table from Woodpecker and put a drawer box underneath and a Incra fence made for that purpose on the top.

The fence has a Micrometer dial adjustment that is extremely handy.

FredD

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#13

Your table

Bob Pierce

>Very nice. Do you remember the episode number or name?

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#14

I agree

Bricofleur

>I agree, Oak-Park is great for router parts and bits. I built a router table using their design and made my own cabinet. The best feature of their plate insert in that you can use guide bushings (their own 1-1/2" size though) for table mounted router pattern. I love that feature and their size since I can get more depth from the router bits. And the customer service is also great.

Best,

Serge

http://www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#15

Inspired by Norm & American Woodworker Mag.

Bricofleur

>Of course, I built a full size router table inspired by Norm and one I saw several years ago in American Woodworker magazine. The fence is my own design featuring a split fence.

Goo luck

Serge

http://www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


img

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#16

New Yankee Workshop Episode #... *LINK*

Bricofleur

>TADA !

Bob,

The episode number for the latest version of Norm's deluxe router station is 0301.

Check his webside below and watch a 1:52 minutes video.

My opinion: Built it yourself. As already mentioned, you'll be glad and proud you built it. And it should last a lifetime.

Best,

Serge

http://www.atelierdubricoleur.spaces.live.com


New Yankee Workshop Deluxe Router Station

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#17

Re: Your table

Jim Dillon

>Bob,

Thanks Serge for posting the link. Actually, IIRC, I was watching Norm use his router table, liked what I saw, and quickly drew a sketch from memory, then went from there. Later I became aware that he had a plan for his router table and fence, but I have never seen it.

One more point. George mentioned using a "high fence". In my woodworking ignorance at the time, I did not realize how important a higher fence is, both from a functional and safety standpoint. I now realize that it is a good feature to have. The higher fence also allows room for clamping an even higher temporary fence if needed. I have done this several times, and that ability was appreciated.

Bill Hylton's book "Router Magic" was helpful to me as well. Despite the rather lame title, the book contains a lot of useful stuff - like all his books do. Hope this helps.

Jim

Re: Router Fence - Build or Buy

#18

router fence

del schisler

>Most of the time i dont use a fence I like the open top where you can use the top beiring for rounding over a piece But you can make a fence out of anything and put it at any angle Just be sure you are on the right side of the bit Or pushing into rotation Just put a clamp on the far side and than adjust I cut out a circle for the bit to just fit the opening I like the oak park with the vaccum plate underside for chip removel I made all my unit but the top Which i wanted to get started Been in wood stuff probly 45 yrs or so I gues i am like the first cutting or orignal still standing I am done my 2 cents worth

this is the vac and fence oak park style

http://us.oak-park.com/catalogue.html?list=BYOT-