Re: How is a band saw resaw guide used?
charlie belden
>Have taken the liberty to break up William's response into what, for me at least, is an easier to read and understand form - with my comments between ==========.
While his well thought out and explained answer got into just the blade - it understandably, given all the other factors that can result in what he calls
"a mythical concept and it's used to explain certain magical properties attributed to band saw blades to folks who can't (or won't) use micrometers to dig deeper into the physical, real composition of them."
referring to the term "drift", specifically bandsaw blade "drift".
The rest of his response, reformatted, is at the end of these comments.
referring to "drift".
But there is another factor not included in his analysis that was overlooked - the crowned "tire" between the bandsaw wheels and the blade.
On a table saw that's set up so the blade and fence parallel the miter slot, changing the saw blade doesn't require resetting the saw arbor so the blade parallels the miter slot. Things ain't that easy on a bandsaw. Even if you've set the fence to absolutely parallel the new blade you just installed, normal wear and tear will - is likely - to change things - in a noticeable way (1/8" thick on THIS end, 3/16ths on THAT end). Change the blade and you probably should "recalibrate".
Attached is an annotated illustration of another factor that can cause a bandsaw blade to not be parallel to that miter slot in it's table top (the purpose of which alludes me other than a place to hold a feather board), and for it not to "cut straight" when using a rip fence that parallels the miter slot - rather than the angle - whatever you want to call it - that the blade wants to cut at.
=============
Williams post broken up to make it easier to follow - at least for me
=============
I'm glad to see you parenthesized "drift", indicating you doubt its existence in real life.
"Drift" is a mythical concept and it's used to explain certain magical properties attributed to band saw blades to folks who can't (or won't) use micrometers to dig deeper into the physical, real composition of them. It's not magic and there's nothing about them that can't be explained, measured, and analysed to predict how they'll perform when pushed through a piece of wood.
For instance: if you have a blade .032" thick with no set it will cut perfectly straight.
=======================
But It probably will burn one or both sides of the cut just due to the heat friction between the sides of the blade and the sides of the cut can generate. To reduce this frictin, most saw blades �set� the teeth sligthly off center and provide a small space between the sides of the blade�s �body�and the sides of the cut. And to reduce the amount of sawdust in the cut, blades also have space between the teeth (gullets) for the sawdust to reside while still in the cut, removed as the gullet exits the cut a the bottom.
========================
Whether the fence is in alignment with the blade is another question, but the blade is contolling the path of the cut. If the same blade encounters a hard knot inside the wood it might try to deflect side-to-side to avoid it, creating lattitudinal bowing, because you can't apply enough tension to overcome the blade's intrinsic elasticity and it started to twist internally. Wider blades have more beam strength and are more resistant to internal twisting in this regard.
=========================
You can of course control the feed rate to the blade. Slower feed rates, while perhaps increasing heat build up due to friction in the cut, can get around changes in density and grain following tendencies.
=========================
Therefore: resawing thick material with blades lacking appreciable set makes it necessary to use wider blades with more tension and require more HP. And you still have to align your 24" long fence exactly parallel to your 3/4" blade, which can be quite difficult without precise instrumentation.
I guess it is possible to find a blade whose teeth have been somehow damaged on one side and still sharp on the other. Close examination would show this (at these microscopic dimensions you either need a microscope or do like I do and just feel it with your fingertips) and if you hold a blade straight out on your bench you can see the set under a good light. You can measure set by sandwiching the blade between two feeler gauges and subtracting the feeler thickness fom your readings on a micrometer. You can compare one side to the other visually by using the same feeler gauge against the flat portion of either side also.
Based on this kind of inspection you can predict which way a blade will turn, if it turns at all. It's quite possible a machine at the blade factory could improperly set a whole batch of blades, but I've never seen it on the TW blades I use. On the other hand; a 1/2" blade, .032" thick with a set of .016" on either side, produces a kerf of .064" and allows .032" of "wiggle room" for the blade to adjust its own path as deflection occurs or to compensate for a fence that is not in perfect alignment with the flat of the blade.
You can cut perfectly straight veneers 18" wide with a 1/2HP motor and never adjust for drift, tracking, tension, or feed rate.
Or you could cut a 3" circle that same depth. There are narrower sets and wider sets, all of which have a good use if your application allows it. With all the different styles of saws out there it's no wonder you get confused but what's important is that you understand how blade dynamics work and base your cutting solutions on what your own saw can do efficiently.
Deep, smooth cuts come at a price. Deep rough cuts are quick and dirty and get you to the planer in style. Planers are great but if you have to plane away 1/8" of good wood to get flatness you're probanbly using the wrong blade.
If it takes a half hour to set up a cutting solution you're either working with unobtaniawood or your time is free. $.02
