We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I've been working on this prodject for sometime now allready, I thought I would share the progess I made. Cuting the hole into the side of the steel drum had me a bit worried, but with a little patience and brainstorming, I think it's comeing along pretty well.
>Cyclones are nice, I'll give you that. I had one, but it wasn't practical for my small garage/shop to have a stationary system, so I decided to scale down before I spent a bunch of money on ducting. A compact and portable unit is all I really need, and this is the best solution I could think of without spending $1300 on the JDS 2100-ck.
>You can improve the efficiency a bit by cutting off the inlet pipe inside the can close to the wall of the can and install a vortex finder in the lid.
A vortex finder is just an extension of the outlet tube to just below the bottom of the inlet tube.
>Chuck, I see what you are doing and you have done a nice job, but could you explain why?
In response to one of your previous posts I mentioned I made a preseparator out of a roll around trash can. Works great for heavy duty pickup like huge stringy shavings off the lathe and chips from the planer. The stringy stuff from the lathe tends to get hung up in the impeller and in my case, the trash can is easier to empty than the bag on the DC. But, I have a small shop and the trash can gets in the way. I seldom use it.
I am assuming the final set up will be to have a filter bag or bags on the other side of the machine. Or a filter bag at the top and a debris bag at the bottom. What benefit do you get from your modification?
>Well there are several bennefits. As you mentioned about the wood shaveings cloging up the impeller when not useing a seperator. I had the same experience awhile back when I was cutting treated lumber for a garden arbor I was building, the wet stuff almost glued itself to the blower fins. Before this DC I had a standard type DC and had a store bought garbage can lid seperator, I never used it much because my shop is also our garage, so everything gets wheeled out, then setup, and at the end of the day tore down and put away. The garbage can seperator was just another thing to setup and then tear down at the end of the day. There is less of a mess in DC hose and elbows with this setup then there is with a garbage can lid seperator. I guess in a nut shell, this setup involves less setup time, takes up less space, and is more efficient. I'll be useing the stock bags, 1 micron bag ontop, and the plastic bag on the bottom.
>Most of the trash can lid seperators I've seen only have one single 4" inlet. I cut in a 5" inlet into the barrell that I can use, or add the factory Y that came with the DC, and have two 4" inlets. I believe that the steel drum is a thicker gauge, and that the lid with the band clamp seals better then a trash can.
I have two suggestions. Find another barrel or a trash can for the bag to sit in. In my case, I use a 32 gallon trash can. My original bags wore out and I got replacements that were larger in diameter. They get fat and hard to get out from the frame of the machine. They get torn. Put a canister in there that will protect the bag, keep it smaller in diameter and make it easier to remove and handle. I empty my bags into a compost pile and reuse them. The container makes it much easier and much less chance of damage to the bag. (My DC is in a closet outside my shop. You should have seen the mess when I put a bag with a hole in it back on the machine.)
The other suggestion is to find a way to put a "full" indicator on you drum. I have seen plans for some on this and other forums, but they involved gadgets inside the drum. I was worried about fire. I would suggest some holes in the side of the drum to allow you to check the contents without opening the drum. Line them with soft, clear, tough plastic. They will get dirty and you won't be able to see through them, but you could touch them and see if the hole is covered.
>I hear that the bags are expensive. If I remember correctly I thought I heard somewhere that bags can be bought for a little less from another company who's machines use about the same size So I'll agree, thats a valid concern. Let me throw this at you. How about another steel drum like the one I'm useing, and connect it with something similar to one of those garbage can skirts from Woodworkers supply. As far as knowing when the seperator is full, with the clear bag it probably isn't a problem, when the bag starts takeing in more dust than usual, the seperator is probably full. If I were to replace the bag with another drum, then thats were a site window should be installed. Or make a container out of perferated steel sheet to hold the bag. I don't know that I'd want to take a chance of a leak at the seperator drum by installing a site window there and lose incomeing CFM. Interesting points you brought up, I'll have to think a little more about it.
>Chuck, part of my problem is I don't want a dust collector, I want a dust disposer. I find the chore of changing the bags to be onerous. I would rather be woodworking. I feel like I go through life "But First". I will take a trip, but first, I have to change the oil and rotate the tires. I will do some planing, but first I have to empty the bag on the DC.
I made a couple of mistakes early on. I had about four bags for the DC. I would fill one and set it aside. Until I felt like making the trip up the hill to the compost pile. Turns out Polyethylene degrades in sunlight very quickly. A day or two of exposure and the bags fall apart. The end result is that the original bags "went away" and a friend gave me some larger, heavy duty bags. Those were fatter in diameter. They would expand in the DC and lock themselves into the frame. The shed the DC sits in gets a little water in the bottom sometimes. If the bag got a toe down on the floor, the sawdust would soak up thousands of pounds (seemed like) of water. Try dragging a sodden bag of saw dust out from that tiny space.
So, the trash can was a major improvement. Its about four inches lower than the ring on the DC and I can see when the dust has reached the top of the can, If I remember to check it.
The emptying the bag process is messier than I thought, especially if the bag is over full. If I spill saw dust in the shed, I have to drag the shop vac out there to recollect the sawdust I had already collected. If I could, I would blow the crap out into the woods and return it to Mother Nature. The neighbors would probably object.
You are right. In your case, you should be able to tell when the over flow is going into the bag. If you are paying attention. I have had the drum fill up and the machine continue to blow stuff on up into the filter bag. What a mess.
>I've heard people complain before about the price of the stock plastic bags. Another thought is if a guy could find a white poly drum about that size, cut the top off and drop the bag in there and hook it up to the DC. With most white barrells you can generally see the level of the contents inside.
>That's a thought. Let me know if the white barrel works for you. I find the plastic bags get so dusty it is necessary to touch it to see where the dust level is.
I think if your separator works you will find it takes a very long time to fill the plastic bag. I would think that about ninety percent will drop out in the drum. OTOH, I think you will find the fine stuff that makes it to the bag is surprisingly heavy. I tore up several of mine when they were heavier than I realized.
I use my bags over and over. If you are throwing them out with the trash, maybe a nice clean bag every time would make it easier to see the level of the dust.
>At the price of those bags, I seriously doubt that I'll be replacing them everytime, unless I win the lottery. And like you said, emptying the bag shouldn't be very often at all if I keep an eye on things.
>I tried the band clamp that came with the DC to fasten the plastic bag. I gave up and went back to the internal ring. The band clamp has 4 notches to hook the band, the second notch is too loose, and the third notch is so tight it won't clasp.
>If I thought it would pay the bills, or atleast one, I'd be allover it. But anyway, I shouldn't need such a contraption, I empty the DC after every days use for fire reasons. I rarely ever cut that enough lumber in a day to fill it, and if I feel I am on any particular day, I'll just keep an eye on the clear DC bag to make sure it isn't filling with stuff that it shouldn't be.