Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Wasting Wood

Posts

Wasting Wood

#1

Wasting Wood

charlie belden

>Wasting Wood

Let me begin by paraphrasing a line in roninkokomo�s post on the death of James Krenov:

The goal of a woodworker is not to make a piece that will last 500 years - and still be ugly.

As woodworkers, be it carvers, turners, cabinet makers or solid wood furniture makers, we often fall into a trap that James Krenov and a few others successfully avoided - specifically - �not wasting wood�.

To many of us, especially those early in the journey, wood is a relatively expensive and somewhat precious thing. So there�s a tendency try to minimize the amount of waste/scrap. There�s even software that will optimize the use of boards and ply sheets. Given a Cut List, the software will determine the minimum number and size of the boards or ply sheets needed to make the specified parts, generate Layout Diagrams and even cutting sequences diagrams. Some of this software even includes grain direction and �show face� as a nod to aesthetics. But the emphasis is not on the creation of an aesthetically pleasing WHOLE piece. The emphasis is on not �wasting� any wood.

The �common knowledge� for estimating stock requirements based on a Cut List recommends allowing 15% for �waste� and up to 25% if you�re a new woodworker.

The mindset �If it ain�t in the finished piece - it�s wasted� seems to be the implied message - and - �wasting� wood is �not efficient�, something to be avoided as much as possible.

The problem with this idea is the definition of the word �waste�. We�re not playing with a homogeneous material and it�s not only the dimensions of the components and how they are joined together that�s important. Wood has grain and figure and color and feel - each board unique. What we�re after is not only a well proportioned, well constructed piece, but also a visually coherent, pleasing piece.

Sacrificing �coherent� and �pleasing� for the sake of not �wasting wood� - IS a waste if the end result is merely good proportions and construction. The piece may look OK and meet the functional criteria of the design, yet, to a greater or lesser extent, wasted all that wood.

Getting the most out of what we start with shouldn�t mean using �everything but the squeal� (to quote a �hog processing factory� boast).

Perhaps the �wasted wood� thing starts with where you start. If you do sketches, then scaled drawings, then a parts list and a layout diagram - the dimensions of the finished piece and its parts all determined BEFORE getting to the wood - by the time you actually get to the wood - it�s just �stuff� to make the piece out of. An existing straight edge of a piece of stock becomes THE reference for a part�s width - rather than �I want THIS grain, in THIS direction for this part - that has to be this long and this wide - how can I get it - out of this nice board, or any of the other boards I�ve got?�

But if you start with the wood on hand and an idea or two for a piece - then work backwards towards a suitable shape and form THEN the size, based on what you have - or can acquire . . .

Of course, this approach takes a bit longer (ok, so it can take a LOT longer) and can involve getting out a lot more wood and doing a lot of flipping and turning and slipping and sliding, maybe some chalk lines and more than a little mental gymnastics to visualize what will go where and how - and usually �wastes� more wood and may involve modifying the design or the scale. In the end, the results can take a nice idea for a piece up several notches. And sometimes the results can exceed your initial expectations - a piece this tall, this wide and this deep - with (fill in the details of your choice) - becoming a �I can�t believe I made this!� (as opposed to �I can�t believe I made THAT.�) piece. And if you end up with �What WE did turned out pretty damn nice.� the next piece will likely be as good If not better.

This wasting wood thing is nowhere more evident than in turning, where 80 to 90% - or more - of what you start with ends up around your ankles - and maybe up to your knees A newbie goes after �biggest� out of a chunk of wood rather than �best�. Want a bowl? Turn the biggest cylinder the blank can accommodate, round the bottom a bit - and cut out the inside �til you get to the wall thickness you�re comfortable turning - DONE! But a smaller, much nicer piece might have been the end result - IF - a better mounting orientation had been selected and the grain of the wood examined FIRST and then again as the turning progressed.

I think one strategy for getting around the Don�t Waste Any Wood is to disconnect, or reduce the connection between, the wood and the price paid to acquire it - to make the wood an important design consideration and reduce /forget its price per board foot significance.

I�m a wood hoarder who comes acrossed deals on wood I have no current or foreseeable use for. But if the price is right, the wood nice enough, and I have, or can find room for it, I�ll buy a hundred board feet or two. That�s enough for anything I�m ever likely to build - and then some. And if and when it comes time to use some or most of that wood, I�ll have long forgotten what the past or current dollar value is of a board or boards. Without the distraction of What Did THAT Cost, I can focus on finding and using what�s needed rather than how much I can get out of each board.

So when a project comes up and I�ve got parts sizes in hand I can start hunting in the Stash for my components. With a pair of large framing squares clamped together at a part�s size - and a piece of chalk I can begin The Search, which may begin with candidate boards lined up along a wall or leaning against the bench, Best Face towards me. With the framing frames to Frame candidatesI can start chalking out my parts - ignoring existing edges and just seeing what�s inside the Frame.

The process is very much like solving a puzzle - if I use this part of this piece, I won�t be able to use that part of this board for this other part . . . Except on pretty dark woods, chalk lines fortunately are fairly easy to erase. That�s good since there�s often a bit - or - a lot - of erasing to do.

The Don�t Worry About Wasting Wood thing is really important when a part requires joining parts of two boards - for a door panel or the sides of cabinet or the top of a table. Nothing will overwhelm even the best designed, best made, piece like a large very visible flat area - with mistmatched or downright �unpleasing� grain or figure. Here �Penny Wise and Pound Foolish� is spot on. And if there are side by side doors, succumbing to the tempation to get the most out of every piece of wood will probably, in hindsight, be recognized as a Big Mistake.

To be clear, I don�t spend hours and hours selecting just the right parts of just the right board - for things that will never been seen - by any normal human being (implying that, when it comes to furniture - or wood turnings - that wood workers WILL probably look, or feel, under and inside a piece - and may go as far as removing a drawer to check the back of it).

So what�s YOUR views on �wasting wood� and if you�ve liberated yourself from significant concerns about �cost per board foot� in your projects how�d YOU do it?

Re: Wasting Wood

#2

I doubt any one bests my frugality with wood

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>To briefly summarize your lengthy communication: don't spoil the appearance (or integrity) of a piece or furniture by using wood with inappropriate grain or defects. I could not agree more for that would be a bigger waste. However, I also believe that wood is a precious resource that must not be wasted. These two goals are not necessarily mutually exclusive.

It is possible to achieve this goal and utilize all of a board. I do it on every project. It requires a large amount of lumber to select from and the experience to efficiently make and use cuttings. Most people buy lumber just for a project at hand because they can't afford to buy a quantity, they don't have room to store a quantity of lumber or they don't understand why buying a large quantity ahead of a need is useful. Among the many advantages of buying several hundred feet of a species you intend to use for projects is the ability to select lumber for a project that meets the aesthetics without waste.

Then there is the experience factor. It takes some experience to efficiently make cuttings. And it takes experience to use lumber that is less than perfect without sacrificing the appearance or construction of a piece. It takes motivation to not waste wood to achieve this experience. I like to relate the tale of how I used a 4' x 12" piece of walnut with a 1+" warp in a table top. It took some experience forcing this way less-than-flat piece into submission. (jacks from the glue clamps to the ceiling joists for example) But in the end the rescue was successful. This is just one of a great many examples of where I have rescued a piece of less than perfect lumber to a successful end.

There will be some wood that just doesn't measure up to being seen. For me this stuff gets utilized in drawer bottoms and other less visible parts.

Re: Wasting Wood

#3

Good "paper".....I may be #1 in frugality

Terry Alexander

>You paper read almost like an English assignment. That is truly meant as a compliment and not criticism. Mainly....because I was afraid I was going to be the only person in college with 180 hours and still needed to pass Freshman English. Oh how I struggled with the written word (and still do!).

As for the thesis and "frugality"..... I save everything. However, in building a new house, cabinets, vanities, shelves, and anything else made from wood, I have a need and use for the smallest of pieces....whether it be a piece of mahogany or some 3/4" plywood.

I am humbled by the works of a lot of participants in this forum. I don't think I have reached the artistic "point" where I look at a piece of wood for character, figure, grain, etc......but......I'm working on it and I'll get there.

Thanks for the post.

Terry Alexander in West Texas

Re: Wasting Wood

#4

Efficency isn't always waste

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I utilize a cutting optimization program for most of my projects and I buy lumber for a given project rather than stock piling larger quantities. I also select the pieces I want to use for assemblies that show and then use my optimization progams to give me the best utilization of material. I typically end up with less than 5% waste on a dresser type project and even those pieces hang around and get used for other projects or for test cuts. I will run my optimization program several times during the course of a single project. More than once it has saved me a trip to the lumber yard by showing me another way to cut pieces I need from the lengths that I have.

Learning to look at the pieces in a glue up is a trait that comes with experience and the helping hand of a mentor.

Lee

Re: Wasting Wood

#5

you raise another point (more philosophy)

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It seems that many modern furniture makers are relying on the wood's appearance to make their statement in the piece, and not the design. I see a lot of plain as dirt design gussied up with figured wood or striking contracting wood colors. The classic furniture was mostly about design and ornamentation through carving, turning and molding- things a lot harder to execute than picking out a foreign wood with some striking visual feature. I have wondered if these woodworkers are substituting wood selection for skills like turning and carving?

Re: Wasting Wood

#6

Amen

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Wasting Wood

#7

Re: you raise another point (more philosophy)

charlie belden

>Well at least they're not using carved plaster of paris under gold foil gilding to spruce up an otherwise ho-hum Louis XIV (or was it XVI) piece.

The trend seems to be towards I'm Weird - Look

At Me! (and buy me). If furniture follows turning, pieces will be wire brushed, charred, chainsawn,

painted, bleached, dyed and patinated, . . . And if I could figure out a way to do it, they'd move too, elegantly of course ; )

But based on a few custom solid wood furniture makers I know, there are people who will pay for pieces done well, in understated ways, using good wood that you can live with year in and year out.

Oh - and as for throwing wood away - I was having trouble doing that - before I got into turning. And if I get into segmented turning - little if any wood will be wasted. Hell, I've got large ZipLok bags of curlies from turnings of african blackwood, boxwood, yellow heart, blood wood, mahogany . . . I'm trying to figure out how to use - in a Presence of the Abscence of Presence of Abscence in the Presence of the Abscence piece Bill Hunter did a year or two back. (used to be called negative space when you made holes or pierced stuff out of a piece but he invented "the presence of abscence" (and I probably spelled abscence wrong). I guess what I'm looking for is an artsy word for plugs and holes fillers.

But to your point - actually throwing away wood that could be used somewhere inside a piece is a good and proper thing to go for. This stuff doesn't grow on trees you know. Wait.

Re: Wasting Wood

#8

Thank you, Thank you, Thank you

Mike Caldwell

>It's forum chats like this that make me a better woodworker. To be able to hang out with all of folks is priceless. Thank you so much for you tips, conversations, generousity, and care.

Mike Caldwell

Re: Wasting Wood

#9

Steven Antonucci

Does this qualify me as "cheapest ever"?

steve antonucci

>Primarily a woodturner, I made this vessel out of sawdust and glue. Safe to say that I might be the only person here using his sawdust too... :-)

S


img