Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Henger owners...question

Posts

Henger owners...question

#1

Henger owners...question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I have borrowed an old Henger 18" scroll saw to cut some intricate fret work. I am new to this machine and fret work. I have it securely fastened to a 3" thick work bench top. The machines table vibrates a distracting amount for this delicate work. If I put a coin on the table it moves around some but doesn't fall off the table in any short time. If I suspend a bag of lead shot from the top frame near the back I can kill the vibration.

Is this amount of vibration normal. Any suggestions for eliminating it. Any scroll saw you prefer?

Re: Henger owners...question

#2

Re: Henger owners...question

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hello Bill,

I've never even thought about owning a Hegner, or other top name scroll saw. My Dad bought me an old Delta in 1950 before he died, and that worked well and without significant vibration. I wish I had it back. My current one, an old AMT 16"er parallelogram design, satisfies a need which seldom occurs. Good thing. I hate scroll work. It bounces all over the place like my grandkids. I keep an iron grip on the stock and move slowly. Its me or it. Fortunately I can blame mistakes on poor eyesight.

George

Re: Henger owners...question

#3

Re: Henger owners...question

mike van pelt

>I worked for Hegner and sold many scrollsaws. They are the best in my humble opinion. The saw is smooth and vibration free. I believe that the trouble might be caused from the way you have it fastened down. Try sitting it on another table such as your tablesaw and see if it still vibrates. If it does you might have a bent arm or a bad bearing. Call Advanced Machinery and ask them for help. Good luck, Mike

Re: Henger owners...question

#4

Re: Henger owners...question

jcousins

>all i can say is wow. i've used the 22" hegner for years and it has been solid - steady - no vibration at all. so what you are describing is very unusual. if the setup with the table does not make it better then i too suggest you call the advanced people.

jerry

Re: Henger owners...question

#5

Re: Henger owners...question

Fred Davis

>When I was considering replace a old Delta 16 inch Scroll saw , I was impressed with Hegner , but was put off by what I thought was overprice tool for infrequent use.

Then I talked to Jan Manuel , who demostrated Dewalts new machine for Highland hardware for a time and she felt the Dewalt had the edge in design and certainly was priced reasonable, by half as much.

I bought one at the next woodshow in Kansas City for my wife and never have been disapointed.

Elaine has small hands and a grip to match so the Dewalt was a fit for her.

FredD

Re: Henger owners...question

#6

Another vote for DeWalt

Jim in N. Va.

>A good friend has a Hengner. I couldn't justify the $ for my needs, so I bought a DeWalt. It runs far smoother than my friend's Hengner and blade changes are easier. I'm not a scroll saw expert by any means and maybe something on his machine needs fixing or replacing. Just my experience.

Re: Henger owners...question

#7

Re: Another vote for DeWalt

AZ, Colorado Springs

>I have a Black & Decker. Got it new in 2002. Great saw. Not much vibration.