Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

The Worst Project Ever

Posts

The Worst Project Ever

#1

Chet Kloss

The Worst Project Ever

Chet Kloss

>I'm not sure why this project affects me this way, but I think this project from the new (October 2009) Woodwrokers Journal is the worst magazine project I've ever seen. A combination coffee table/bed. Really... Even for utilitarian furniture I think this thing is ugly.

What do you think? Is this the worst project ever - or am I overstating it. If you disagree with me - what do you think is the worst project ever?

.............Chet


img

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#2

Re: The Worst Project Ever

John Luke

>A combination router table and bidet would rate right up there with worst peoject ever.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#3

Handy when your guests won't leave

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>just mention, as you walk out of the living room, that they're welcome to tuck into bed, if they can find it.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#4

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Fred Davis

>I don't which of thousands that might qualify, but whatever it would be, undoubtedly would be made form Particle Board and covered with simulated wood grain ,Genuine Vinyl.

Which term made me always think , could there be a ersatz Vinyl ??

FredD

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#5

ROFL

Dan Mitchell

>Any way you could work a garbage disposal into that design?

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#6

Reminds me of an S. J. Pearlman piece

Howard In Toronto

>He was poking fun at women's magazines by suggesting all kinds of improbable crafts touted as being easy to perform but were reeeeeal dumb....

ZHoward

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#7

She looks OK to me.

Virgil Johnson

>And she compliments the project nicely.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#8

Re: The Worst Project Ever

john lucas

>Chet My first projects back in the 70's were just like that. At the time I thought I was quite imaginative. It was sort of a hippies move from van to home sort of mentality. We needed furniture, sometimes versatile furniture, and I only had a router and jig saw.

However I will agree this is ugly by todays standards but you know if it gets some guy or girl into woodworking it's a good thing. Look where it took me. OK that's not a good idea as invested my retirement money in a shop full of tools. Of course if my kid can sell the stuff as antiques he might have a good inheritance.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#9

Ersatz vinyl

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>It's called contact paper.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#10

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>I'm torn about it. You know WWJ was REALLY, REALLY concerned about it when the entire "From the Editor" column is devoted to "why we did it." They KNEW it was going to get some flack.

I think a large number of woodworkers (I include myself in this category) have come a long way in our WW skills over the last 10-20 years from watching Norm and reading all the WW mags including ones like FWW which used to be the lofty realm of the very few. Many of us forget we started making simple things that may not even have been up to the level of woodworking you see in "Handy" (Handyman Club of America Magazine.

As many of us who are Baby Boomers improved our WW skills, a whole new generation of woodworkers has started coming on the scene, but the magazines primarily stayed with us. Few of the new generation of rookies have ever heard of Maloof or Krenov, nor would they ever consider tackling one of the chairs or cabinets by these icons, if they did.

However . . . . it is frankly still an ugly and poorly designed project.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#11

I can see where it came from . . .

steve mackay

>Many years in Germany taught me that EVERYTHING can convert into something else to save space no matter how absurd or convoluted the "conversion" may appear to us here across the pond. Actually, I'd bet this is a hot seller over there. Over here . . . not so much.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#12

Whoa!! "Handy"?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You've actually SEEN such a magazine?

And here I thought the only things they put in the mail were glue spreaders and pasta strainers.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#13

A True Vinyl Success Story

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The fight to save the rare Corinthean Nauga and halt the senseless killing of the baby Naugas for their hides has been truly inspirational. Indeed the man made substitute is so close to the original that it takes an expert to tell them apart.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#14

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryRU4sWQOIA

>Wow, if it were TV show we might be talking about jumping the shark.

I like the idea of convertible furniture and I have more IKEA stuff in my house than I would like to admit to but why knock them off when you could do something much more creative and interesting with the concept. (could be an idea for a contest Ellis)

I apprenticed with someone who drilled the idea into our heads that if your making furniture do not make stuff that looks like it came from Breuners, which was a low to medium quality west coast furniture chain.

In the words of Fishbone U.G.L.Y. you aint got no alibi

Tom

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#15

But It Would Look Better With Stripes

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#16

Re: The Worst Project Ever - Don't know

North of the Border

>if it's the worst or the second worst project ... to me, I avoid painted furniture projects unless they're for use as in the garage, or outdoors - that's places where people won't judge it as a piece of furniture!

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#17

Steven Antonucci

I'm making one in QSWO and bunkbeds!

steve antonucci

>If you are going to do something, why not over do it? :-P

S

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#18

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>I'm sure it would work but I prefer a Murphy bed. Unfortunately the project is not ugly enough to be interesting.

I asked Sarah if the girl came with it. Sarah said it didn't matter as she would not allow the project in the house. Well, that ended that!

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#19

projects like that may just kill woodworking print

Dick Coers

>

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#20

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Fred Davis

>Hey, Breuners weren't all that bad.

Until the bean counters took over that is.

I did contract work for the fixture company in Sacramento that was doing new Breuners stores, did the last two in Newark and Santa Clara.

Breuners always used to use a existing warehouse for their new stores and then they built the ones in Newark and Santa Clara and the downfall started.

They then formed a alliance with Sattlers appliance in Concord and put a Sattlers in eight of their stores and then couldn't staff them with experienced appliance people fast enough.

Sattlers was close to bankruptcy when that happened and became a financial drain on Breuners.

The last straw was when the bean counters who had already badly damaged Breuners got the bright idea of installing a "Rent a Room" to their stores in competition with stores that specialized in that line of retailing.

Breuners was a old line family owned firm that sold service which was rare in the furniture business.

They carried national brands of furniture and in their heyday ,you could find a piece of Baker Furniture here and there thoughout their stores.

Many people who had done business with Breuners as well as some whose parents had , missed that business when it closed it's doors.

The famous big old building with the clock tower in Oakland was the firm's original place of business and their headquarters.

FredD

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#21

Re: The Worst Project Ever

Thomas S Stockton------WebKitFormBoundaryRU4sWQOIA

>Didn't know that about Breuners good to know. His point was that if your building custom furniture and putting it in shows and galleries don't build stuff that looks like it came from a department store.

Re: The Worst Project Ever

#22

Got to have one!

GalenV in Iowa

>I just really want one, but in John Deer green, not the Allis Chalmers orange! ;>)