Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

Posts

Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#1

Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

John in NM

>Picked up a few 2x4's to finish some construction (needed a couple more rafters for a small cupola on our "greenhouse"). The 2x4's measure 1 7/16" x 3 3/8". Why doesn't the mill just keep them the same size and charge a bit more? I think I'll have to stick to smaller yards that aren't trying to squeeze the last 1/10th of a nickle out of every load of lumber!

I'm not sure which is worse, a distinct moment when you realize that the overall pride in "quality" just took another little plunge, or having to take a few more steps to correct mis-matches in "dimension" lumber when building.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#2

Another Oxymoron

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>"2x4"

Time was, you got hit with a 2x4 there'd be damage. Won't be long before it'll barely mess your hair.

|;-}}

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#3

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

Brian in Brighton

>Been there,done that. The 1/8 inch less width burned me on some plans for some stuff when I planned on 3.5 inches and didn't measure first.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#4

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I just finished some home renovation on my 1928 house. I had cut out some wall studs and saved them to re-use. I also bought some new 2X4 studs. At one point I recall standing there with an old stud in on hand and a new one in the other. I could not believe the difference! I barely knew I was holding the new 8'- 2X4 in the one hand. Made me appreciate my old house that much more.

Tom

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#5

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

steve mackay

>Every time I pass the Orange Box on my way to the Blue Box it gets easier. The pull of the vortex of poor service and bad quality lessens. Not that the quality of Blue lumber is all that much better but they seem to give a hoot wether I even step inside or not. The Orange Box couldn't care less if I go in there or not as it takes time out of their busy day. Lord knows they sure don't want my money.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#6

I'm feeling very lucky

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>In the county's main town, 10 miles east of us (more or less), I've got a locally owned home improvement center that nearly competes on price with the Big Boxes and beats them all hollow on service (they actually hire people who know something about their products, and are very intent on hiring people who like customers); and a contractor's lumberyard that is happy to work with civilians, and offers very high quality wood.

We do on occasion shop at the borgs, but only when one of these two can't provide what we need.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#7

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

Alex Grigoriev

>I think these are milled while still quite wet (and get such fuzzy surface). When they get drier, they shrink.

The studs in my ca 1978 house were 3 1/4 wide. Go figure.

HD and Lowes sell kiln-dried 2x4 studs, as well. Buy those if you want 1 1/2 x 3 1/2.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#8

older stuff not better in all ways

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>The framing in our 1895 house is full thickness rough 2x4 stock, but back then, rough was taken seriously - they can vary in width over 8 feet by 1/4 inch or more. The studs were held to the layout lines for the siding, with the variation being taken up on the inside with the thickness of the plaster coat (over wood lath). This is not so easy to do with drywall, although the original plasterers weren't masters, so there's a certain amount of unevenness in the original wall finish - which gives me permission to warp the drywall a bit in installing it, to match the original surfaces. At least, that's my story, and I stick to it.

In one or two areas, we've had to shim studs to get a workable alignment on the wall.

After World War II, you could get 2x3s a lot more easily than now, and the work done after the war (laundry, one bath, back entry - and probably what we call the sitting room, which we haven't tackled yet) is almost all 2x3s with rough 1x6s - sold around here as "corral boards" - nailed over them, newspapers glued over the corral boards, and the whole then wallpapered. That part we tend to rip out and replace with 2x4s, which just about equal the previous thickness.

I love the old old wood - not so fond of the postwar wood - but it's not without its own challenges.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#9

Small Biz . . .

steve mackay

>we LOVE 'em !

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#10

Ranting a bit

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Small businesses are not inherently good; large ones aren't inherently bad. But I think the larger the business, the farther executive management is likely to be from the customer and from the front line worker, and the more likely business decisions will be made in an atmosphere free from customer service and quality - and, often, from the purpose of the company's product offerings in the first place.

I spent a minute day before yesterday tracking down the manager (and, as it turned out, assistant manager) of the home improvement store I mentioned, to praise a couple of employees. Yesterday, as I was leaving the store after going again to get a question answered, I ran into the assistant manager shuttling carts in from the parking lot, because it needed to be done and he was out there anyway. That kind of intimacy with the front line serves a retail company well.

Some companies manage, as they get bigger, to keep that connection. That's great when it happens. We talk way too often on the Hand Tool forum about Lee Valley, but I think Rob Lee's openness and customer contact through the internet and other settings has a lot to do with why it's a successful company.

Every intro to econ professor will tell you that the ultimate purpose of a company in a capitalist environment is to make money for the owner/stockholder. But too close a focus on that leads to short-term decisions about product offerings and quality that fail to serve the customer; and companies then fail, or at least fail to thrive.

Anyway...end of rant.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#11

Like 3/16" hardboard instead of 1/4"

Craig Daymon

>1/4" masonite/hardboard is great for jigs, drawer bottoms and router guides, but 3/16" doesn't cut when trying to ride a router bushing against it. Oh yeah, looking for smooth on both sides and tempered too. Doesn't seem like something you should have to special order.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#12

Re: I feel your pain.

Brian in Brighton

>

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#13

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

Tom MacGregor

>A few years ago I did some work on a building in Barre, Vermont, that was built in the 1850's and had always been a commercial space. I wasn't the first one to alter the interior to suit the latest tenant. I found five different size "2x4's". I think the place now has more cedar shingles inside the walls than were ever on the roof.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#14

There's a good yard like that in Roswell...

John in NM

>I just don't get down that way often. If I'm buying a large amount I go there though. Not really a big home center, but an old lumber yard where you can find stuff that's been there for years right next to new units of lumber. Best part I think is that the manager is clearly interested in lumber and finds the best he can get.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#15

Does the wood glow in the dark?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Or is it on the other side of town from Area 51?

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#16

Re: What the Econ professor should have said------

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco------WebKitFormBou

>was that the effort was to build VALUE for the owner. That may or may not be short term. It depends on the owner.

------WebKitFormBoundarycOhroVD+LS4xkc5l

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#17

Re: I'm feeling very lucky

Binen

>As they keep reducing the size of a standard 2X4 it will not be long until they will have to create a new size stud. Maybe they will create a 3X5 so it actually has enough structural strength to support a wall again. I really question the support of a house built out of 2X4s when they become a stud that actually measures 1X3. I also can�t wait until a 4/4 board actually measure a half inch. Making drawer sides will be much easier.

Don

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#18

Re:Manufactured Home Studs

Marvin Horn

>I can't be sure but what you probably bought was studs for manufactured homes of a few years ago. Home Depot was the one place you could get them .

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#19

For what it's worth

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Stick construction is actually overbuilt - you could probably remove every other stud, and it would still stand. As we've remodeled our old house, I've found situations in which, due to rot, a series of studs in an exterior wall effectively had the cross-sections of stacks of quarters, and the wall wasn't sagging. Kind of amazing.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#20

Re:Manufactured Home Studs

Bill White

>You have to remember that the orange borg was founded by men who believed in value, customer service, ethics, and return on investment. Bernie and Art left, and so did their values.

I hardly ever enter the orange bldg. now. It is a shame.

Bill

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#21

There are some exceptions

wilbur

>The Home Depot near my house is very good. Customer service has really picked up over the past 2 years or so. There was a time when it was impossible to find someone to help you there, but now I'm constantly asked if I need any help, which is not a bad thing. This seemed to turn around with a change in the management staff of my Home Depot, along with a remodeling of parts of the store.

The Lowes in my area used to be better in that regard but they have dropped off in the customer service department.

It goes to show that the performance of any given store depends a lot on the manager of that particular store, much more so than whether it is a small business or part of a large corporation. Or maybe I'm just lucky.

On the other hand, borg plywood is still kind of sketchy.

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#22

Not really...

John in NM

>That's actually a very small component of Roswell's makeup, and I think mostly for tourist exploitation. Its more like a cross between a midwest county seat, western cattle town, and Texas oil town.

I know you're joking of course - so in that vein, since I just read about a medical pot dispensary in Sebastopol, I'm going to have to start calling you "duuuuude"!

Re: Another reason to avoid Home Depot!

#23

Apples just aren't selling anymore

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>