Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

OT Credit Damage Question?

Posts

OT Credit Damage Question?

#1

OT Credit Damage Question?

Barry Irby

>My friend is struggling in this economy. Way under employed. He has a Bank Of America credit card that got out of control and had about $5K on it. He is making the payments, but just a barely. Has actually kept it current and nibbled it down from $5K to about $4200. B of A has offered to close the account, canceling the card, cut the interest rate to about 7% and allow him to make $100 payments until it is paid off. (this is less than the current minimum, so he is attracted.)

I suspect they will report it as having been closed under adverse conditions and his rating will go down. I also think it will make it more difficult to get another credit card in the future.

My question is, will this hurt his credit score?

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#2

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

Mark Nowicki

>Future access to credit and effect on the credit score are irrelevant.

The only fact that matters is whether the seven percent rate offered is lower than the current rate of interest.

Mark

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#3

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Rant mode on

Barry - while I have sympathy for your friend, I blanch at the notion that the "credit card" got out of control. It's an inanimate object completely controlled by your friend. He's the one who ran up the charges for things he obviously couldn't afford.

Yes, it will probably be shown on his credit report as an adverse action, BUT if he pays it religiously and makes an effort to make not just the $100 minimum payment, but more than that each month, say $110, his debt will be paid off and he will be able to attach a statement to his report to that effect. Yes, it's going to take several years, but it seems to be an excellent alternative to missing payments and having collection procedures commence. That's not a pleasant thought.

I wish him the best of luck, the economy has been tough on all of us.

Rant mode off.

Doug

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#4

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

Alexander Grigoriev

>I think they are doing him a favor. For most people they pose the dilemma - either close the account and pay it off with the current rate (NOT lower), or continue using it with a higher rate (and pay the existing balance with new higher rate, as well).

It will only affect the credit score as his available credit will be reduced. It'a not a defaulted card, though, so it won't be that bad.

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#5

Financial Peace University *LINK*

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Something that should be mandatory for everyone.

Also your question is a good one to ask Dave himself (either calling live on the radio show or just calling or emailing the question).

Happy Woodworking!


http://www.daveramsey.com/fpu

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#6

Re: Financial Peace University

Doug Ridley

>My thoughts exactly. Contact Dave Ramsey

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#7

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

Brian in Brighton

>Yes, BoA will show the card as being closed by the lender, as opposed to closed by the consumer. It will be a ding, but can't tell how much. Here is something he should consider. BoA can, and probably will, call in the entire amount in short order. They will not wait until he pays it off at $100 a month. This is a well documented tactic they use. If you read the fine print of the card agreement you will see that they can demand full payment at any time. Once the card is closed they have no reason to not call him on it.

Now, if he can get the credit frozen until he pays it off that is a different story. See if he can get charging ability frozen while he pays it down. This is less likely that they will call the bill due in full.

Just some of my experience with myself and friends in the last few years.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT Credit Damage Question?

#8

Yes

Curly Smith

>Any time an account is closed with a remaining balance your credit score takes a significant hit. Additionally, it hurts his score in two other ways:

- first, as previously mentioned, it reduces his "available credit"

- second, if it's a card that he's had for a long time, particularly if it's his longest held card, then the impact will be greater.

But, the real questions are:

- What is the interest on the remaining balance? Is it 11.9% because he hasn't yet defaulted or is it 32.99% because he's perpetually making the minimum payment as has one late payment?

- What other lines of credit does he have?

- Is he going to be making any other credit purchases in the near future (house, car, boat, etc) which will be materially impacted by higher finance charges?

The only way to really answer the question is to evaluate what he's going to "save" by the interest rate reduction and what additional fees he'll be charged by lowering his credit score.