Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

oak...to fill, or not to fill...

Posts

oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#1

oak...to fill, or not to fill...

Gary

>that is the question!

I'm building a bath vanity, out of oak. I've never bothered to fill the pores before, using a glaze to highlight the pores. I'm not really wanting to glaze the vanity, (although I'm sure I could be talked into it)...which leads me to this question:

when do you fill pores on woods such as oak? what makes the determination, and what will be the result?

Thanks,

Gary

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#2

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Gary,

I believe filling the oak pores is a matter of personal choice. Well filled pores do provide a great "look", whether or not you choose to contrast or match the oak's final color. It also results in a smoother surface while retaining the oak texture, at least visually. Personally, I don't fill oak--or ash. I like it unfilled. Either way is fine, but I am sometimes amazed at how many of our dinner guests leave in a huff because I didn't fill the pores of the oak in our dining room! :<)

George

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#3

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

Fred Davis

>Like the Colonel said , your choice .

But........ from a sanitary perspective in a bath room , filled Oak will accept a film finish that is more resistant to dirt collection then a unfilled one. Think smooth , you really only need the top flat surface filled anyway.

FredD

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#4

how I decide

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I think filled oak looks more formal so I fill when the design of the piece is more formal.

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#5

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

Kneale Brownson..Awaiting return to CO snows

>You sure your hording of the beer mugs has nothing to do with it?

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#6

Fill the Mugs, not the pores :

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: oak...to fill, or not to fill...

#7

Re: how I decide

Howard Acheson

>I agree. It's a matter of the "look" you want or the "look" you want to match. A filled, perfectly flat surface is considered more formal while an unfilled, "feel-the-grain" finish is more casual and natural.

That said, there can be reasons to need a filled surface. A bathroom, kitchen or other surface that will get frequent cleaning will tend to need a filled, smooth surface.