Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

stiles and rails

Posts

stiles and rails

#1

stiles and rails

Bob in Green Bay

>I have a cabinet almost complete as a TV stand. It is all cherry and I even have the nice book matched inset panels for the front doors. I was anticipating just end butt stiles and rails for the front doors but have now decided to use a thin strip of walnut on the inside of the stiles and rails to accent the inset panel.

This will be a challenge with the two types of wood using this method. Going to a 45 degree miter makes this easy, but I have always considered this a weaker joint.

Any comments on ease of assembly? Pocket screws from the back? (I don't have that jig but may get one for this). Visual of the miter vs the butt joints?

There is also no center rail on the case so I am interested in comments on visuals regarding this when the front doors are closed. I was thinking of some black rubber tubing on one edge to conceal the "see through" when closed. Also will I have trouble opening if they are too close together? should I back miter the meeting edge a bit with my block plane? There will be no knobs on the front (pull from the bottom edge)

I respect the group at large here to I appreciate suggestions.

I need to do all my fine sanding outside before it gets too cold. I like to keep as much dust out of the basement as possible when I can.

First area frost 2 nights ago, but not at my house.

Thanks

Bob

Re: stiles and rails

#2

Re: stiles and rails

Dick Coers

>For the walnut trim piece, why not just add it like a mitered trim after the door is glued up? You could leave it proud of the face and trim or sand it back. Maybe I didn't see that the panel is flush. If so, set up a template and rout in a groove after the glueup, and inlay the walnut.

Re: stiles and rails

#3

Re: stiles and rails

Fred Davis

>As stated you have a nice appearing Cherry cabinet , so I think pocket screws would look kinda like mud flaps on a Cadillac, when the doors are opened.

For the doors closing on each other , you could easily rabbet the leading edges of each door so you would have a half lap joint when closed.

A strip glued down the back of one door and forming a stop for the other door would do the same thing , but not near as nice.

A splined mitre should be strong enough for the door frame joint, I would not hesitate to use a biscuit in the joint, that would not degrade the appearence of the door.

Only suggestions mind you.

FredD

Re: stiles and rails

#4

Ellis Walentine

Couple options

Ellis Walentine

>The walnut feature strip is the key to this dilemma. Ordinarily, I'd tell you to take the plunge and get a cope-and-stick router bit set and make the frames that way, but it won't render the walnut strip the way you want. A straight miter joint is no doubt the easiest, and I would definitely reinforce it with a biscuit as Fred has suggested.

If you want to get really into this, you might want to consider the visual proportions of an equal-width frame around your panels. Normally, the lower rail is wider than the other rails for visual balance. You can't do this with 45° angles, and if you vary the angels to get the effect, it messes up your walnut feature strip joint at those lower corners.

So, my suggestion would be to try a "mason's miter" joint. This is a low tech joint that doesn't require a cope-and-stick router bit or shaper set, and it serves your purpose perfectly.

The mason's miter is essentially a mortise and tenon joint with a little miter just to the bottom of your walnut feature strip. We use to make this joint with either integral tenons or loose tenons (usually the latter).

I'm not at my home terminal right now, so I can't readily illustrate this joint for you. Perhaps someone else would be so kind, otherwise e-mail me later and I'll follow up with you.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: stiles and rails

#5

Re: stiles and rails

Bob in Green Bay

>Thanks Fred.

I have considered the rabbet method for the front door. It is certainly more elegant than the strip on the back. My concern there is that each of the rails, where the two doors meet in the middle, will be cut from one board to best match the grain. I am still trying to determine if I can rabbet and still match it up.

As for the spline, believe it or not, I have never done that. I have always been a dowel or just glue guy. Since I do want the walnut strip, I am leaning toward the miter so a spline it may be. slow and careful first time through should be ok.

Bob

Re: stiles and rails

#6

Here's a reference to a mason's miter..

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>It's in the Shop Shots

Re: stiles and rails

#7

Should have added this:

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>Here's a picture from Wikipedia.


img