Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Sandpaper Sharpening

Posts

Sandpaper Sharpening

#1

Sandpaper Sharpening

Howard

>I'm going to try this method, I have a large piece of granite that will work as a flat surface. What series of grits do you use, I am not sure where it is ok to skip a grit. Once I have an idea of the sequence, I will order the paper. Thanks for the help.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#2

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

Neal in San Jose

>The best sandpaper for this is Aluminum Oxide. Silicon Carbide, the common "wet or dry" paper you find in the paint department at the home centers is a fine product for the purpose it is intended for: sanding paint and wood, but it works poorly or not at all for abrading hardened steel.

Remember that an edge is defined as the intersection of TWO surfaces; thus the back is just as important as the front. You will likely only flatten and hone the back once in the tool's life, so do a good job. You will touch it up every time you sharpen the bevel (bezel), but the heavy lifting need only happen once.

As far as a sequence, it is hard to tell you what grade to start with. That will be dependent on the condition of the tool, and what your ultimate goal is. If the blade has deep rust pits, and it is a finish plane, well, you have a long day ahead of you. If it is a scrub plane blade, almost any edge you are able to produce will likely work O.K. So, start as course as you possibly can bring yourself to. Do ALL the flattening and rust removal with the coarsest grit you have. You may have to start at 60 or 80 if the tool in question is in very poor shape. (This makes a good argument for Lee Valley, Lie Nielson or Hock blades, doesn't it?) If the blade isn't too bad, you might get away starting at 120. I'd recommend that you not skip grits, at least not until you get familiar with the process. I know that's a lot of paper, but it really isn't very costly, in the finer grits you will only need one sheet, and your time is worth a lot. The polishing grades from Lee Valley with the mylar backing and up to 2000 grit (I think, I don't have it in front of me) is remarkable stuff and worth every penny. If you are grinding and grinding and don't feel like you are getting any closer to your goal, drop down to a coarser grit.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#3

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

DouginDenver

>I sharpen all my chisels, hand planes, jointer knives and even planer knives this way. Here's what I've learned from my own experience. First, I use 3M spray adhesive to stick the paper. I find it a waste to peel up one grit to use the next. So I bought three sheets of plate (not tempered)glass about 12 X 18. I use half of each side, with two grits per side. So I stick down about a dozen grits or sometimes full sheets of fewer grits and use them until they won't cut anymore. I use the black stuff for grits 220 and up. I use up to 2000, but 1500 will do. The coarsest grit totally depends on how knicked the edge is. After that, 220, 320, 400, 600, 800, are what I use. Over 800 it sort of depends. I'll sometimes jump to 1500. If you do a microbevel about 2 degrees steeper than the main bevel, you can do that with 2000 in a couple strokes without polishing the whole edge to that grit.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#4

It works with the right technique

Forrest Addy

>Sandpaper sharpening works with the right technique (look up "scary sharp"). The sandpaper (wet or dry finishing paper works best) won't last forever and you have to replace it or waste time rubbing on dull abrasive. Over time and at about $0.50 a sheet, replacing paper can get expensive. But it does work and many woodworkers use this method.

So be warned: sandpaper sharpening, or "Scary Sharp," is not an unalloyed solution to the sharpening problem.

Here's my test for a sharpening system: total time to touch up a cutting edge to razor keenness is less than two minutes. That's if the stuff is out and ready to go. Three to five minutes to remove a sizable nick. If your sharpening system takes longer, you're wasting valuable shop time on a maintenance task. The Tormek is about this quick once you get practiced on it. Most stone based systems are about as quick.

Thing is, you don't get quick and efficient unless you practice a little, and that means adopt a system and stick with it. I know guys with hundreds of dollars in sharpening fad equipment and their tools are still dull. I have to go to their shops and show them how to cut dovetails for example, and their saw and chisels are dull. I once saw a beautiful little gent's saw with drywall residue in the teeth.

I got off the subject. So. Yes, sandpaper sharpening is a good system but a little expensive in materials. Stones and a leather strop are generally a better bargain.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#5

JL

Automotive supply place

JL

>I use sandpaper to sharpen my concave spokeshave. I have a couple of turned cylinders that I use for my "base". I got the sandpaper at the automotive supply store (Autozone for me). They had a variety of grits up to 1000 or so. If you feel you need to go beyond that, then you can order.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#6

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

Justin Szeliga

>I get the paper I use from an autobody supply place. A shop that carries auto paint will have paper. I use the paper after grinding, start at 600, then go to 2000, if I have the patience. As was said, 1500 is good.

Peace

Justin

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#7

check the Articles, recommendations

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>there is a comprehensive article on this topic in the WoodCentral Articles.

I don't recommend the granite chunk. I think the handiest system is two 12 x 12 x 1/2" glass plates available from a glass shop. Stick 2 1/2" strips of the various grits on these plates. Two plates will hold the grit series from 80 on up to 2000. This format is easy to handle and store and what ever grit size you need for a job is at hand. .

Many use the black silicon carbide paper. In the coarser grits it crushes readily when abrading hardened steel resulting in short abrasive life. Aluminium oxide or zirconium abrasives are a better choice.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#8

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

john lucas

>I had 4 pieces of flat glass cut about 4" by 10" I glue the paper to them using 3M spray adhesive. I store them in a box built just for them. I use220, 400, 600 1500. It's quick and easy. I just keep a spray bottle handy. I buy the wet/dry paper at my local automotive supply houses.

If I'm trying to restore a blade I use a bench grinder with80 grit white wheel to clean up the edge. If the back is really bad I have a seperate piece of glass that I glue some 120 paper to. That's rarely needed because fresh 220 usually cuts pretty fast.

I tried other sharpening methods but for my shop this has worked well. Replacing the paper is kind of a pain but isn't needed often and it's less trouble than flattening stones.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#9

Low initial cost for good results.

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Let's see, a basic Tormek unit is about $340.00 If sandpaper costs .50 per sheet, I use 1/2 sheet per set up and I use 6 grits of paper and only get one blade sharpened per set of paper, then I would be able to sharpen 226 blades before I equal a Tormek. Since I only have about a dozen blades in my shop that get sharpened that way, and they get touched up about twice a year on average, then I could go about 9 years before equalling the cost of a basic Tormek. How long do Tormek stones last and what do they cost?

In relation to the original question, the Scary sharp technique has transformed my hand tools from instruments of torture to relied upon tools. My hand chisels and planes now see pretty regular use since they cut wood like soft butter.

Lee

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#10

Thanks - I'm Ordering the paper and ........

howard

>I will try this approach. Thanks for all your good advice.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#11

Re: Thanks - I'm Ordering the paper and ........

Michael Caldwell

>One more thing that hasn't been mentioned. Either a very steady hand or some kind of sharpening jig to keep a constant angle as you push the blade around. I have had very good luck with the LV sharpening jig for those times that I really have to work on a blade. Otherwise I just give it a couple light scrapes across the 1500, and I can dry shave my beard.

Good luck to you,

Mike

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#12

Re: Thanks - I'm Ordering the paper and ........

Alex Grigoriev

>I'm using 3M microfinishing film sold by LV. Use spray adhesive to stick 15um film to a glass plate. 5um gray and 0.5um green films stick by themselves to glass, if you just clean it with mineral spirits (watch for bubbles, though). Use a razor blade to remove any sticking particles from the glass. LV sharpening guide makes it easy to change the blade angle a bit for each next grit.

For coarse shaping I've been using 3M black carbide sandpaper (takes too much time), but bought Grizzly low speed grinder recently.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#13

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

Tom MacGregor

>I use light pressure on a $100 Sears 4"x36" belt sander with 60 to 80 grit Klingspor belts to grind the primary bevel. It's easier than a bench grinder for getting it nice & straight without overheating the iron. Then (once you've flattened the back, a one time job) you only need to hone a micro bevel on the sandpaper. You can quickly touch it up many dozens of times before a quick light regrind on the belt again.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#14

Are you getting a keen edge

Forrest Addy

>Are you getting a keen edge in the two minute touch up? I use a worn DMT fine diamond plated stone and a strop.

I didn't separate my comments relating to the Tromek that while expensive performs to specs at low skill level from my cost per edge riff. Sorry. I should have made a more forceful comparison between bench stones Vs Scary Sharp and isplated my remaks about the Tormek which IS expensive for the budget constrained home woodworker.

And Lee is right. The Scarey Sharp method is low initial cost but over time those packs of Merka and 3M wet or dry abrasive sheets add up. And it's more time consuming compaared to a good bench stone and strop given equal skill levels.

I recently bought a Grizzly version of the Tormek wet sharpening system. It seems to work as well as the Tormek but I haven't had a chance to run a side by side trial. Review later.

Re: Sandpaper Sharpening

#15

information on short paper life

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>Before I switched to diamond abrasives I used abrasive sheets. My set up was 2 1/2" x 12" strips of abrasive sheet stuck on glass plate. I could sharpen a plane iron many times before changing paper.

There are two causes of short abrasive life. Silicon carbide has short life in the coarse grits. It is too brittle for hard steel and the particles simply crush. Starting with too fine a grit for the task at hand is a second reason. It you are not done in a few strokes of toll on abrasive, the grit is too small. One might be starting too fine or taking too big a steps in the grit progression.

The price of paper has gone up but when I started a few years ago $30 would buy 10' rolls of every grit needed 80-2000 and that supply would last many years at the rate I used it.