We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>Several days ago I posted about making some mortises in table leg/rail connections and testing them to destruction. Wanted to see if long shallow ones were as strong as shorter deep ones. The deeper ones were stronger, but not by much. Kelby asked me to put them back together and pin them with 1/8" dowels. Been busy and finally got to it today. I put the deep on back and put in three pins. This time it held fifteen pounds and started to separate and creek. 20 pounds finished it off. This was a dry joint that had been glued with epoxy, but I drove it back together and pined it. The little pins just basically disappeared. not clear on where they went. the holes through the tenon were still intact, so I drove it back together again and install two more pins (five total) This time it held twenty pounds for a few minutes and then failed. Last time, with the glue it held forty pounds.
>You can see where it broke the first time and how it was slathered with epoxy. Normally, I would clean up better than this, but I did not think it mattered for this test and I wanted to be sure everything was thoroughly covered. The rails is "turned over" so you can see the mitered tenon.
>This is the rail after the leg broke and fell off, leaving part of the inside of the leg behind. This time it held 15 pounds and failed instantly with 20. With just the glue it held 35 pounds.
>Not sure we have learned much at all. As Ellis mentioned, this is such a small test, it does not constitute "Evidence". Its a quick and dirty test that yields anecdotal results.
What I expected was the deeper mortise would be a much stronger joint. It was bad "science" to go into the test looking for a specific result. This leads to subtle "cheating". Thi9ngs like doing a better job of fitting the deep mortise and tenon or perhaps a better job of gluing them. Tried not to do this and was about equally sloppy on both. (I think.)
The deeper mortise was stronger, but not by much of a margin.
I think making the joints out of pine yielded significantly weaker joints than hardwood. I noticed that the tip or corner of the longer tenon was rounded over by being rotated out of the mortise. Harder wood would have resisted the rounding better (I think). In both cases some f the wood broke on the original test with glue only. This seems to indicate the glue may have been strong enough. There was still a LOT of glue surface that failed.
I would like to do this several more times and test several more things. Make up some out of hardwood and with several types of glue. Make up some with pins and some without and with several types of glue.
I was surprised the pins seemed to "disappear". When I broke the first deep mortise with 3 pins, when the joint came apart there were no remnants of pins in the holes in the tenons and the holes were sound. Not at all sure where the bits and pieces went or how they got out of the holes. I redrilled them to clear the remains of the pins out of the holes in the leg and then added two more. I suspect this wallowed out the holes and weakened the joint. These were brand X hardwood dowels bought at Lowes.
So, for now, the deeper mortise was slightly stronger. Not sure, but I think it would hold up better over the long term because it represents less of a cross grain connection. The shallow mortise is 3 1/2" wide and the deep one if 2 1/4". No real way for me to know, but over time the wider tenon might squirm with changes in humidity and moisture content, but I don't know if 3 1/2" is enough to make that happen.
>What I am trying to find is that joint that fails at the exact moment the leg fails. The Vampire falls against the table. The table collapses, the leg breaks, plunging the shard of the broken leg through the vampire's heart, saving me from a fate worse than death.
Barry emailed me his photos and I was able to put them into a web album that is of larger size than the WC photo limit.I'll leave it to Barry to narrate.
>How about a biscuit joint for the leg/apron connection - using
rubber cement rather than glue? Biscuit will slide and the joint will open when any pressure is applied downward. Scarf joint on the leg, rubber cemented together so the joint will slip and open up with any downward pressure.
I'd be concerned about anyone falling on the end of a scarf joint though.