Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

OT - Digital SLR

Posts

OT - Digital SLR

#1

OT - Digital SLR

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>My Kodachrome is gone.

My beloved OM-1's meter is shot and the flash is toast.

Going to make the jump to digital. So . . .

Questions for those with experience:

Full-frame sensor or smaller?

If I'm not printing over 8x10 but will close crop, is there any real advantage over 12mp?

Looking a 2 Canons, 50D and the D5/Mk2 as well as the Nikon D700. Anyone with experience with these please comment pros/cons.

TIA

mm

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#2

Re: OT - Digital SLR

Chad Pearson

>I just bought the D5 mark II about two weeks ago. I went for the full frame camera mostly for the enhanced depth of field ability. Not sure yet if it really is significant enough to justify the added expense but it's the story I'm sticking to if swmbo asks.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#3

Re: OT - Digital SLR

Ken Krawford

>Hi Mark,

I just bought a 50D a couple of months ago and am still getting used to it. It has some amazing features that I love and others that I may never get to. I started with a 24-70 f2.8 L series lens and have gotten some great pictures.

Email me when you are ready to pull the trigger and I can give you some leads on where to buy for a great price.

Ken

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#4

Full-Frame

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'm tending that way as I do little tele work, and am more likely to shot mid-range portrait or wide and then crop.

Thanks

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#5

50D

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I just "funded" one with an 18-200 f3.5 for my son's honeymoon. Nice camera. Don't have use for the pop-up flash, and the lens is a bit slow for my taste, But seems like excellent value for the price.

Thanks

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#6

Re: OT - Digital SLR

Jerry Nicholson

>I have Nikon's D-70 and D-80. I have been happy with both of them but in the fast moving digital world they are almost antiques now. I feel that the "half frame" sensor is adequate unless you plan to make big bucks with your camera. Remember that even that sensor size is several times that of the typical "point and shoot" camera and "point and shoot" cameras can be capable of excellent results. Anything more than 8 megapixels just leads to a degraded signal to noise ratio and, in my experience, resolution is not the limiting factor in cropping or enlargements. Looking at negatives and slides from way back in the past, I think I am getting better results with my Digital SLRs than I did with my Leica and my film Nikons although in theory my Leica lenses were far superior to the typical digital camera lenses of today. One might conclude that the limiting real limiting factor is a nut loose on the shutter release.

Lenses for digital SLRs are generally slow, unless you have lots of money. Nikon, Canon, both take great pictures.

Jerry

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#7

Slooooow

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Yes, I'm seeing a lot of that compared to my film lenses. Seems they're relying on the electronics and ISO values rather than the glass. I can see an advantage since the old "fast" lenses lost some sharpness. But having examined the noise resulting above the 1600- 3200 rating, I'd like a bit more lens capability instead.

Thanks. Things seem to be pushing toward the D700.

mm

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#8

Re: Slooooow

Jerry Nicholson

>That should be a great choice - way more capability than my D70 and D80.

Jerry

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#9

Re: Slooooow------WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bbhbAAlFJG *LINK*

Chad Pearson------WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bbhbAAlFJG

>I think the D700 is getting a little long in the tooth. . Nikon will need to update the D700 to keep pace with its competitors. (video etc.)

Here's a nice explanation of the advantages of full frame:

------WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bbhbAAlFJGTv

------WebKitFormBoundary0g+FRZu7+qWOVsgi


Full frame advantage------WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bb------WebKitFormBoundary0g+FRZu7+qWOVsgi

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#10

Re: WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bbhbAAlFJG

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>All links go nowhere or to a Dead page.

???

D-700 "long in the tooth" because?? This is just out, new unit

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#12

Re: OT - Digital SLR

Jim Dillon

>Mark,

The OM-1 has bit the dust? The horror, the horror! Sell it to an astrophotographer! Broadly speaking, if you are not printing over 8x10, then going over 12 MPx is overkill; some would say going over 6 MPx is over kill fcr that size print. Regarding DX vs FX, it kinda depends on what your lens collections looks like. DX is super for those who like to get extra reach with a telephoto because of the 1.5X sensor factor. If you are starting from scratch with a lens collection, then PERHAPS a full sensor MIGHT be the way to go. BUT, the weight and size of the lenses might be a consideration, as well as cost. Your question has come up a lot on the Nikonians web site, and the conclusion depends so much on how deep your pockets are, and what you present lens collection consists of. Right now, my gut feeling is that the DX presents a much better value for the money, and the image quality is SUPERB. What the future holds is anyones guess. To make matters a bit more complicated, you can get a lot of DX lenses on Ebay now form folks who are "upgrading" to FX lenses. But keep in mind, photographers are a bit crazy too, with having to have the latest and greatest.

Jim (owner of a a Nikon D300, and loving it)

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#13

Nikon v. Canon

Chad Pearson

>Sorry for the bad link. I find it difficult to post from my Mac. I need to dig up my old PC to make woodcentral work correctly for me.

I realize the D700 isn't all that old in months but my photographer friend thought it was eclipsed by competing brands in terms of features. Just repeating what I heard when I was making the same decision two weeks ago. It was very close between the D700 and the 5D. I was interested in the ability to shoot video in HD quality. It's use will be rare but it was a point of difference. There was also the fact that Nikon uses Ashton Kutcher in its ads. I can't stand those ads!! ;-)

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#14

Re: WebKitFormBoundaryZDD+bbhbAAlFJG

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>The D700, like the D3\D3x and the D300 are pro bodies. That's why they don't have video and so on. For that (video) you need a consumer body.

The D700 is an awesome camera. It's not long in the tooth by any stretch.

Check the D700 section at NikonCafe.com

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#15

D700 etc

Chad Pearson

>I agree the D700 is a great camera,... I very nearly went that way. I was under the impression that it was really the direct competitor to the D5 from a product line perspective and the D5 seemed to have a little larger feature set.

I'm very interested in hearing your thoughts as between the two.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#16

If you loved your OM...

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>why not check out their E-series. I am pleased with my 520 and there's a new 12 mp version, the 620. Olympus lenses are what sold me, as well as the price and in-camera image stabilization.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#17

Re: D700 etc

Joe in a Cleveland Suburb

>I can't offer an opinion of the 5D. I am a Nikon user. Have been since the mid 70's. Had I gone Canon then, I would have been stuck a few times with obsolete lenses. I can use my Nikkor glass from the 70's on my current digital Nikon bodies. Canon has the tendency to change mounts obsoleting current lenses.

They are both great cameras. Although, the D700 is newer technology, has a larger LCD, higher usable ISO, faster flash sync, much better (user opinion) ergonomics, is WEATHER SEALED (very important imo), built in sensor cleaner (works quite well) blah blah blah ... the biggest advantage is the D700 uses Nikon glass! :D

All of my stuff is Nikon and/or Nikkor glass. I do have a Canon P&S camera that is very nice too.

I've handled a number of Canon DSLR bodies, and I am one of those people who doesn't care for the "feel" or ergonomics of the Canon bodies. For people on the fence, from what I've read, that is what pushed them over to Nikon. Of course that's subjective I guess.

I don't enter debates on which camera is better. It's splitting hairs - both Nikon and Canon make very nice equipment. Both are capable of producing awesome images.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#18

Hold On To Those Pixels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Canon just announced their new 7D.

Full Frame 18mp sensor, 8fps burst, 1080p HD video, 100% viewfinder, 19pt AF, all for under $1,700 body only.

I was about to put the trigger on a D700, but I think I'll wait a month or two to see how things shape up.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#19

Ooooommmmmmm

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Actually looked at them first, but, while the glass is great, I didn't care for the bodies, especially the 4/3's sensor / lens system that digital Olympus uses. Not that I print posters, but I do wide angle and also crop heavy from time-to-time, so I've committed to the full frame cmos sensor platform.

I'm told I should find an astronomer to buy my old kit as the OM-1 remains a favorite for that use.

Re: OT - Digital SLR

#20

Rats

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I was told it was a full frame sensor (rather than a crop body), but that's the one detail my informant got wrong. Price difference would have been very nice. Back to the full-frame Nikon.