Re: Kubota BX or Deere 2305
Grant in Iowa
>I just went through this and I will tell you what I learned:
Both the Kubota BX2360 and the John Deere 2305 are extremely capable machines. These two are commonly considered the finest of the wide crop of compact utility tractors. If you compare the two (new versions), you'll find that they are pretty comparable in both price and features/ capabilities. I was quoted $14,500 for a new JD 2305, and $13,900 for a Kubota BX 2360..both with a 60" mower deck and a front end loader. It took me 3 trips to each dealership, making it clear that I was considering the competition before I was given those quotes. Even with no interest financing, I was not prepared to spend that amount of money. If I were to buy a new one, it would have been the Kubota, because I didn't like the hydraulic hose kluge that the JD has going on, among other reasons, but your needs and mileage may vary.
So I searched the used market, both for John Deeres and Kubotas. I eventually found a 2002 Kubota BX2200 with a 60" deck and loader that had only 200 hours on it for $8800 and bought it. Other than some minor paint scratches from mowing around trees it looks like new. I have only put about 8 hours on it so far, but it has impressed me completely.
You might consider the used market. There are many of these machines out there with less than 500 hours on them that people no longer need. I guess people complete all of their landscaping needs and then decide they no longer need them. I also highly recommend the private party used market, because dealerships have to charge sales tax.
Some benefits of these machines over heavy garden tractors are:
-Diesel engines are prevalent... more fuel efficiency, more torque, more engine longevity. 18-23HP is PLENTY in a diesel, trust me.
-Bigger, heavier, made to do real work
-"category 1" 3 point hitches allow you to find rear implements at a farm supply store for far less than the purpose made implements that only fit a few models of garden tractors. I was able to find a 48" 550 lb rotary tiller for my Kubota for $650 used. Garden tractors all have proprietary implements, unless you get up into the compact utility price range.
-4WD. Nuff said.
-Comfort, smoothness and sure footedness that only more mass and larger tires can bring you.
-lights that really work
-Heavier build means more longevity, and they are comparable to top of the line garden tractors in price.
I am so impressed with my new (to me) machine that I couldn't be more sure that I have made the right decision. By the way, mine is rated to lift 540lbs with the loader, but it doesn't quit at the rated load, I am sure! One of the best features is my ability to put the loader on with the mower deck in place and do some quick work. It only takes me about 3 minutes to put on or take off the loader, and I have not even completely mastered the process.
I suggest you narrow it down to a few models, then type that model and "reviews" or "problem" into google and see what you can learn.
One final note: Below you will find a great web site that you can use to both learn about these machines, and also find one in your price range. (No affiliation, but that is where I found mine).
Regards,
Grant in Iowa