Testing Mortise and tenon joints
Barry Irby
>I was Interested in the mortise and tenon joints that Andy was cutting in the legs of his tables. He has been doing a great job of keeping us posted on his progress. I thought the tenons would work better if they were shorter and deeper, but I did not actually know, so I thought I would test them.
Being cheap, I took and old white pine 2 x 4 that was in the shed and made two legs and two sets of rails. I cut a mortise in them at 90 degrees to each other. On one leg the joints were 3/8 by 1/2 deep by 3 1/2" long. The were the full width of the rails. The mortise intersected at the inside corner.
On the other set, the mortises were 3/8 by and inch deep and 2 1/4 inches wide. Intersecting inside the leg, causing the tenons to have a miter on the ends and leaving 1/2 at the bottom 3/4" shoulder at the top.
I cut the joints with a hollow chisel mortiser and table saw. They were snug, but rough. I slather both with epoxy and let it set for several days.
I clamped the rail in a vice and hung a sling off the leg. I added five pound lead weights until I had 35 pounds in the first one. (long shallow mortises) Before I could pick up the camera the joint failed suddenly and completely.
I repeated the setup with the deeper tenons. It held thirty five pounds and I let it sit there for a few minutes. Then I added a set of drill bits (five more pounds) It held for less than a minute and then crack/boom.
I am disappointed. I thought the glue would hold better. I think this is primarily a glue failure. Some of the wood did break, but there Si a lot of glue surface that failed. Now I am tempted to do it again with better glue. The deeper tennons did hold better and longer, but the difference is not as dramatic as I thought. I think that if you made an excellent joint with better glue that the leg would break/not at the joint on the deeper tenons. I think the top of the leg would fail on the shallow tenons,I have some pictures, but I am not good at posting them. If somebody wants to take them and clean them up and post them I will email them.





