Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Veneer over solid wood

Posts

Veneer over solid wood

#1

Veneer over solid wood

Bill Earl

>I am building a walnut tabletop and would like to apply a curly walnut veneer to the top surface (and a backer veneer on the underside to balance the slab). I have heard a variety of things regarding veneer over a solid wood substrate. Some say that if the grain direction and species are the same, it should be no problem. Others recommend another layer with the grain oriented 90 degrees under the face veneer.

The core would be glued up from 5/4 walnut boards, air-dried for 5 years, the last three years of that in my shop. It is mostly rift-sawn, with a few scattered tight knots and has dried flat & straight. The finished slab would be roughly 42" x 96" x 1" with the grain running on the long axis. It will be hinged in two places with a Maloof-style wooden hinges to form drop-leaves.

Does anyone have experience with veneer over solid wood on a piece this size?

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#2

Re: Veneer over solid wood

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I made a small table the way you suggest (veneered solid wood ), 15" across the grain. It's approximately 15 years old now with no problems.

I've read the recommendations for a cross-grain base veneer but have never found a stated reason for it. I'd love to find an old source that discusses the thinking behind it.

My usual method for a veneered top is to use mdf for the ground, edge with 1" wide primary wood long grain on the sides and end grain on the ends, then veneer both sides with thick veneer, say 1/16" instead of the tissue paper stuff used commercially. The end grain edging on the ends makes the top look 'solid'. The edging is quite thick. It's easier to handle and clamp that way.

I'm going to keep an eye on this thread and hope to learn something!

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#3

Re: Veneer over solid wood

Bill Earl

>Thaks for the feedback Ed.

One reason I have heard for the cross-grain base veneer is that differential wood movement would tear the veneer apart. But if the veneer and substrate are of the same species and grain direction, I don't see how you could have that much differential in movement.

Another reason that sounds more plausable is that the base veneer will limit any telegraphing of underlying imperfections.

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#4

Re: Veneer over solid wood

paul in AZ------WebKitFormBoundary+isMX5X2paiDYC5e

>I'm curious as to the rationale of using a solid walnut core for the top.

As mentioned, a core of known stability with solid walnut edges and thick veneer over would be the route I'd take.

I have not used MDF as a core but have put thick veneer on a baltic birch core. The biggest piece was a concert sized harpsichord around 7 feet long and that worked just fine.

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#5

Lee Grindinger

Did it often

Lee Grindinger

>I did it often, it solved the edge problem entirely.

Run the veneer grain the same direction as the substrate. Veneer both sides, that's important. It's not important that it's the same veneer but it's vitally important there is a glue line to oppose the glue line on the upward face. Many will say to balance the veneer and that's one way of putting it but it's actually the glue line that needs to be balanced.

I'll include an example of a veneered solid walnut top,

Lee


img

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#6

Re: Veneer over solid wood

Ron Bauman

>A great many of the old round oak tables with figured tops were veneered over a solid core. Make sure to use a non figured veneer on the underside to avoid warping. I found that a lot of these tables used wormy chestnut as the core wood and if the veneer was badly damaged my customers were happy to have me remove the oak veneer and expose the chestnut.

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#7

Cross banding

Howard Acheson

>>>>>> but have never found a stated reason for it.

It's called "cross banding". It was/is used primarily when veneering over a solid wood substrate. It's applied at 90 degrees to the grain direction of the substrate. It's primary function is to reduce the chance of veneer splitting due to unequal wood movement between the veneer and substrate when different woods are used. It also covers any surface defects in the substrate that may telegraph through into the decorative veneer. The decorative veneer is applied at 90 degrees to the cross-banding.

As said, do the same thing to both sides of a solid wood panel.

Re: Veneer over solid wood

#8

Thanks for the feedback

Bill Earl

>This whole project was designed to make use of the wood from a 38" dia black walnut that came down in my sister's yard. However, due to some unfortunately located defects (including a chunk chopped out of the middle due to an embedded clothsline pully), out of some 600 bf, there is not enough clear lumber in 8' lenghts to construct a 42x96 top. That is where the veneer comes in.