Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Provisional Patent Advise

Posts

Provisional Patent Advise

#1

Provisional Patent Advise

Rick Christopherson

>I am working on a couple of woodworking-related provisional patent applications, and even though I am fairly savvy with legal documents, I am looking to get some advise on the specific requirements and pitfalls for this type of application. I have spent a fair amount of time reviewing the process, but it seems that much of the information out there is either geared toward taking your money, or replicating the same wording as the USPTO website.

I learn best by example, so I would like to find several provisional utility patent applications to review, but these seem pretty hard to find. Yes, an approved patent it a good place to start, but it is nevertheless different from a provisional application document.

I have drawings that are properly formatted, and that is not a problem. However, one thing I am confused about is that a provisional application has no claims, so I am not specifically calling out any numerical items in the drawings, unless I misunderstand where these references are located in the document. I thought that you were not supposed to reference drawings in the description, which is the prime part of the provisional patent, so these numerical callouts have no reference (which is a no-no). (i.e. All items referenced in the document must be called out, but if an item is not referenced, then it cannot be called out in the drawings.)

Aside from that, I am not comfortable with knowing what the major subject headings should be, or if there are any specific pitfalls to avoid with a provisional application that would cause problems if/when I file a non-provisional application.

Please don't tell me to see a lawyer, as I already know this, but regardless whether I finish this myself or with legal counsel, I want to get as much of this completed by my self. 12 months from now, for the non-provisional application, I know I must have a lawyer, but for now, I need to complete this on a tighter budget.

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#2

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

Rob Lee

>Rick -

Firstly - I'm not a lawyer, but do have some experience with the odd patent or two.

A provisional application is a placeholder, to get you standing in line at the patent office. It also starts the clock running on filing the formal patent (you have a year). It offers you no protection beyond establishing the filing date. Of course - a regular patent also offers no protection until issued either...

Reason for a provisional - it gives you the chance to test market a product, before comitting to the expense of a utility patent, and it gives you the chance to revise and extend your claims. Well worth doing, as the costs are very reasonable.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#3

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>Rob is absolutely correct here. What he did not mention is the extreme backlog at the patent office. The media has finally caught up with this disturbing story and given it some publicity.

The moral here? Get in line NOW!

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#4

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

William H. Falberg

>Do you have a copy of David Pressman's "Patent It Yourself"? It's all in there. I might still have cpoies of my original provisional around but it probably wouldn't help with yours. PM if you want to talk about it. Good luck, BTW.

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#5

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

Brian in Brighton

>Buy the book. Patent it Yourself. I used it for my patent and it was very helpful.

Keep in mind that you can only use the PPA submit date if you make no NEW claims on your utility patent. You can make LESS claims, but not any new ones. You can make new claims, but the date will be shifted to the UP submit date, not the PPA date.

Brian in Brighton

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#6

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

William H. Falberg

>You don't make any claims in a provisional patent application. However, when you later file your utility patent application, the "material" introduced in your PPA is the only material that will enjoy the protection of the earlier (PPA) filing date. The claims in your Utility Patent App. can introduce new "matter", but in the event of interference, new matter is not considered in date priority. In other words: throw the kitchen sink into your provisional. Don't hold back, no matter how fanciful. You can take things out in the UPA filing, but you can't add new "matter" in later and expect your prior filing to hold water.

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#7

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

Rick Christopherson

>This is one area where I was getting conflicting information. The PPA doesn't need claims, but a person I was speaking with today told me that I should include all claims as they can't be added to the PA later.

Hopefully my wife is bringing "Patent Pending in 24 hours" from the library tonight, as this is a book I have seen highly referenced.

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#8

Re: Provisional Patent Advice

William H. Falberg

>The first thing I would do is read the book. I'm not familiar with the title you're getting and can't comment on that, but David Pressman's book IS the "standard", however, having gone through numerous editions over the years. The second thing I would do is stop talking to your friend. He's obviously un-informed. The third thing you should do is Google "Inventors Education Forum" and post your questions there, where the lawyers (and David Pressman himself), hang out.. ..........................Once again:There are no claims in a Provisional Patent Application. Fourthly, I no longer believe in The Patent Fairie and urge you to think carefully before wasting time, money, and energy chasing a dream that was legislated out of effectiveness decades ago. There are better, more effective ways of protecting IP and profiting from it.

Re: Provisional Patent Advise

#9

Re: Provisional Patent Advice

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>A lot of good advice and info in this thread. Most examples I have seen are very brief- check Pressman's book(s)and online, you'll find plenty of examples. There is no format to a PPA. It is only good for a year, can not be renewed, but . . . if you make substantial changes to your design, you can file a new PPA, but the clock restarts. I filed my PPA's online, cost only $110! I probably provided too much info. Frankly, if you don't have an IP lawyer you will be lucky if you are able to successfully get a patent. As has been said the PPA sets a marker, but also (like a full utility patent application) allows you to legally use the term "Patent Pending."

If you plan to market and license your design, potential manufactures want to know if you have a provisional or a utility patent and will usually pay a higher percentage for patented ideas. But the pitfall is if you try to file a full utility patent yourself it can cost anywhere from $5-10K on the VERY low end up into the tens and even hundreds of thousands of dollars- AND there is no guarantee a patent will issue, and no refund. The USPTO is terribly backlogged, a friend (a recognized maker of woodworking machine accessories) just got informed one of his applications has been approved and a patent will issue soon- over 3 years after he filed his PPA and over 2 years since filing a utility patent application!

I licensed my latest design. I only filed a PPA, but my manufacturer will not likely file a patent due to cost. He is going to wait and see how sales go. If you have documentation of your efforts that is almost as good as a PPA.

You are not required to do a patent search for a PPA (or a utility patent application) but it can save you a lot of money. It is truly amazing what is already in the "public domain" (and therefore not patentable) or already patented. The problem with a patent search, is that you can not search PPA's, so someone can still ace you out in the long run. Frankly, I think the whole system is broken and needs to be fixed. PPA's were just a Clinton era bandaid, but the cut has gotten bigger.