Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Posts

Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#1

Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Stephen Kirk in Quakertown PA

>So, I'm finally making a concerted effort to do some dust collection in my shop (besides broom and dustpan). Currently, I have a Ridged Shop Vac. I managed to get this hooked to my planer and jointer and it does an OK job - some occasional clogs and I have to empty it frequently, but it's OK. I recently added a 1 micron filter to the shop vac. I also found some adaptors so I can hook the shop vac to my dewalt ROS. I'm also looking into a large dust collection system, like the Jet or Delta 2 bag rolling base mounted ones.

So, a couple of things:

1) I hear that I should also add the filter bag to the shop vac (if it will accept it). Supposedly, this will really increase the main filter life. Has anyone else done (or not done this) to see the difference

2) Cyclone pre-separators - I also hear that it's good to add a pre-separator to the shop vac to capture the large stuff. Again, any real world experience on this. I see I can buy the lid type ones for 5 gallon buckets pretty cheap.

3) I'm having trouble finding a smaller length of hose for use when sanding. Sure, I can hook the shop vac hose up but it's big, heavy and eventually will pull the fitting free. Anyone ever see hoses like this (aside from Festool - don't wanna pay the price of a tool for a hose)?

Bunch of questions here, so thanks in advance for reading and any replies.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#2

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Bill White

>1. I just use my vac as is.

2. I read mixed reviews on the pre-vac separator.

I have the elcheapo Harbor Freight DC with 1 mic. bags from Highland Woodworking. No probs at all. The bags are "felted" for added surface area. No matter what DC ya use if it will draaw enough air and has good bags.

Bill

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#3

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Barry Irby

>I have been through setting up a DC system in my small shop. I have the Delta on with a 1 1/2hp motor. Put the unit in a closet outside the shop. That was a really good thing. All the dust is out doors, even the part I spill changing the bag. I also made a trash can separator that I use a a preseparator if I am doing heavy planing. Its a homemade rig, but works great. The reason I don't use it most of the time is I have a small shop and it takes up a lot of room.

I bought a shop vac hose kit at the borg and adapted it to my DC and ROS. It has a one inch wand on it and it fits very nicely onto my PC ROS. The hose is small and light. Tends to restrict the air flow a bit but it is much better than nothing.

Speaking of nothing, I can't imagine how I got along all those years without Dust Collection. The difference is astounding. Keep moving in that direction, you will appreciate it.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#4

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

mamc

>Been dare done this, I found a separator reduced the effectivenes of the shop vac which wasn't that great to begin with. I then agonized over whether a 2hp DC would be strong enough for my basement shop if used as a central DC system with 4" PVC.

I finally bought one, installed several gates and runs to all the major stationery tools (TS, Jointer, DP, BS, Planer, Router table )and it works great.

Certainly better then the Shop vac solution and way more conveinient.

If I was to do it over again, financially and efficiency wise , I think I would have been better off if I had stopped investing sooner in the shop vac solution ( filters, separtors, adapters etc.) and moved faster to a larger DC system.

Good Luck

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#5

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Ed Mulligan

>I too was unhappy with the price of the Festool hose ... until I used it. Well worth the cost. I use it whenever possible in place of my Fein and Porter Cable hoses. It hooks up to most of my tools without adapters or duct tape.

For sanding, I drape the hose over my shoulder or lead it to a high spot near the bench so its path is down to the tool and work. A 4' long plank clamped vertically in the front vise is a good way to do this.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#6

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>Stephen. I have a Rigid vac also. It is connected to a ceiling collection system which is, in turn, connected to each tool via a hose and gate. I have a cyclone between the tools and vac which does a good job of separation. I also have a cloth bag, sewn by my daughter, covering the standard filter inside the vac. This has worked well for me for over 10 yrs now. Oh yes, I now have a new Oneida cyclone.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#7

Forget pre-separator

Pat Evans

>I tried the garbage can pre-separator on my DC. Waste of time. When sawdust reaches 3" to 4" deep, the DC just picks it up anyway.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#8

Re: Forget pre-separator

Robert R. Clough - Thorncraft

>Agreed, totally. I have - had - one and just discarded it for a new Oneida. Yes, it worked better than nothing, but that is by no means best.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#9

Dust Deputy Fan Here *LINK*

Joe Pack

>Hi Stephen,

I can't testify as to its effectiveness with a jointer or planer, but I can testify to the tremendous result I have had with a Dust Deputy used in conjunction with a Ridgid 16gallon vac on my radial arm saw and/or drill press. In fact, I just had the same discussion with my son's father-in-law during a visit here last weekend.

The problem in using a shop vac as a dust/chip collector is that the filter clogs almost instantly. I didn't have a problem with the tank filling up so much as the filter clogging to the point that all the vac is doing is making noise. And a standard shop vac filter doesn't stop the dust anyhow, just the larger particles. The 1 micron filter I bought as a replacement for the standard filter stopped most of the dust, but also clogged up almost instantly. A shop vac filter just is not made for this type of work on a regular basis.

I saw an article on the Oneida Dust Deputy cyclone seperator for use with a shop vac, did some research and, after talking with the folks at Oneida, bought a Dust Deputy. I have never been more pleased with a purchase. The Dust Deputy does exactly what it claims to do. The video is no hype, and could have been shot in my own basement shop.

The Dust Deputy is a small cyclone that connects in-line with your shop vac. A hose runs from your tool to the Dust Deputy to the shop vac. The cyclone causes the chips and dust to settle inside the Dust Deputy bucket, not reaching your shop vac. As a measure, and as I showed my son's father-in-law last weekend, the 5 gallon bucket under the Dust Deputy was about 1/2 full of chips and dust while the shop vac had less than 1/2 CUP of debris in the tank. Not bad for one "load" of cuttings from my radial arm saw, but even better when you consider that I have emptied the Dust Deputy a minimum of 5 times since I last emptied anything from the shop vac. And the filter looked all but new.

I'm not saying the Dust Deputy is the end-all for anyone's dust collection needs because it does have its limits, but, for the intended purpose, i.e., any small collection need such as sanders, routers, etc. (remember, I am pushing it with my RAS and Sears dust hood, and it even works there), I can't recommend it highly enough.

I have the blue metal Dust Deputy of a year or so ago. The "new" one appears to be made of a different material, but supposedly works the same, and the price is lower now than what I paid for the metal one.

I would warn that the DD is a bit cumbersome to move around, even with the wheel kit available. Rather than deal with moving the DD and the vac around, I bought an extra length of hose so that I can leave the DD and the vac in one spot and take the 20' of hose to where I need it most of the time. Also, pay attention to inlet/outlet sizes of the DD. Like most other vacs and tools, it seems that "one size fits all" is a foreign concept. Glad the vac folks weren't in charge of pipe thread and bolt sizes.


http://www.oneida-air.com/

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#10

Video Link *LINK*

Joe Pack

>Video link here.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9NXZKYWpMbE

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#11

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bill....

Stuart Hough

>How loud is that DC? I've been looking at one of those, but noone in the store will plug it in and let me listen.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#12

Re: Dust Deputy Fan Here

Barry Irby

>Some times stuff makes my head hurt. Putting a five gallon bucket on the side of a 16 gallon shop vac to avoid getting stuff in the shop vac seems to be missing some sort of logic.

This is like the people that want voice recognition on their cell phone so they don't have to thumb-type there messages and they can text while driving. What about just using it as a cell phone and leaving a voice mail if they don't answer?

Why doesn't Oneida put a small, powerful vacuum motor unit on the dust deputy and eliminate the shop vac altogether? Or mount the little shop vac on the bucket instead of the other way around? Somehow this is like putting a load of fine wood in your pickup and then hauling the pickup on a tractor trailer.

I think the DD is a neat idea, but some how they missed a step.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#13

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Chuck in ND

>Mr Nozzle sells a vac hose kit that you can cut the hose to any length if you wish and twist the ends back on. As far as dust collection goes, there are alot of variables when it comes to what works best for each individual. Budget, space, the tools your hooking them up too, electrical requirments, etc.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#14

Find another store, and let them know it.

Joe Pack

>Any store that will not hook up a potentially noisy item like a shop vac or portable DC should not get one dime of your money for anything, and they should learn that directly from you ASAP.

I bought my 16 gallon shop vac from HD. One reason I bought it was because there was a noise muffler available for it (the muffler actually worked well, with little reduction in suction!) Before I bought it, though, I asked the clerk in that department to plug in the floor model (it literally was sitting on the floor in a display area) so I could hear it with the muffler. He actually said, "There is no plug near here." I suggested the one about 30' away, to which he replied, "I would have to take it out of the display to move it over there."

I didn't argue, just walked to the service desk, asked to talk with the manager on duty and, when she arrived, asked her if she would walk over to the display area with me, which she did. I told her, "I asked your clerk here to plug this shop vac in for me so I could hear how loud it was, but he refused because he would have to move it. I wanted you to watch me while I move it over and plug it in." I immediately began to roll it over to the plug (the vac was on wheels already, just had to maneuver it over a little 1" high 'barrier' around the display.) Before I had moved it two feet, she LOUDLY instructed the lazy clerk to roll the vac over and plug it in, which he begrudgingly did. I switched it on, listened, switched it off, inserted the muffler in the exhaust, then turned it back on...a significant sound reduction. The manager asked if I had any more requests she could help with. When I said, "No, thank you. I appreciate your help. I'll take the vac and the muffler." She then apologized profusely to me for poor service, giving me her name and telling me not to hesitate contacting her if I ever had any other problem at HER store. She even had the sappy clerk carry my vac (in box) to the register for me.

As I checked out, she was walking away with the clerk in tow...one of them was not a happy camper. The other was getting an ear full.

Speak up when you receive poor service. If the clerk won't help, go to the manager. If the manager won't help, go to corporate. It really does work, as call-backs from Sears and Best Buy about my legitimate service complaints have shown. Of course, I don't mind tilting at windmills sometimes...it's fun to play Don Quixote! Especially when you are are a retired old wind bag like me.

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

#15

Re: Dust collection confusion??? Bit long ...

Pete

>I found a used central air vac at a yard sale for $5.00.

I turned it into a cyclone in no time at all. I don't know why folks spend so much money on these incredibly expensive dust systems. Putting this together was *EASY* (with a couple of mis-steps that I'll describe). All you need is a 50 gallon steel drum (with lid), PVC tubing, PVC connectors and PVC glue. For tools, you need a jigsaw with a metal blade (to cut holes in the lid), and a regular saw to cut PVC.

Here is the process:

The basics of the job is to run two pipes into the lid of the steel drum.

- One goes straight down the middle and only extends straight down, just a few inches.

- The second is much closer to the edge of the lid. This one goes in, down a couple inches, then a 90 degree bend.

The first (center) pipe is connected to the vac. The second is split out for your tools. I am telling you, it is easy.

Here are a couple of tips.

- STEEL DRUM - Like an honest to God steel drum. Nothing else will do. I bought a bit aluminum trashcan. Put weather stripping along the lid to provide a good air seal. Crushed it like tin foil. Like I'd stepped on a soda can. Bought one of those heavy heavy gauge cardboard ones. I could lay it on its side and stand on it (230 pounds). The vac just squashed it. Luckily I found a place that brings in flavorings in steel drums and sells them for $17. Even with the steel drum's lid will begin to bow if I close all the seals....

- When running the PVC thru the lid, here is the connection layout. Try to stick with me, cause the description is a bit hard. If you want, let me know, I'll take pictures.

1. Cut two holes in the lid that are the size of the PVC pipe. One hole in the center, one more hole 2 or 3 inches from the edge. I drilled a hole then used a jigsaw. You don't need to make is perfect. You'll seal everything with silicone in the end. But make it pretty close to provide good support.

2. Cut a couple of pieces of PVC pipe that are maybe 3 inches long. These are the sections that will actually sit in the holes.

3. Slide these short PVC pieces into the holes in the lid. On each end place of the short pieces dry-fit / slip on a straight connector (so you will need 4 connectors. 2 for each piece of short pipe). Make certain that these short pieces of pipe are short enough so that when you slide the connectors on each end, each connector can slide all the way to contact the lid. These provide the support that the pipes need.

5. Once you have these dry-fit these, take them apart, apply PVC cement, and put them back together. The lid is nearly done.

6. On the Center pipe, add a 6 or 7 inch section of straight PVC pipe. This will hang down into the center of the drum. All done here.

7. On the Edge pipe, slip a 2 or 3 inch piece of pipe to the connector, and then add a 90 degree elbow. As you are applying the PVC cement twist the elbow so that it runs parallel to the edge of the lid. Not pointed straight way from the center pipe, and not pointed straight at the center pipe. 90 degrees from the center will ensure that as the sawdust is sucked in, it will cyclone around the barrel and fall to the bottom.

8. Just about done. Put the lid on the drum. On the top of the lid, add whatever pipes and make whatever connections you need to get the center pipe to the intake of the vacuum. Make whatever connections, splits, gates, etc. needed to connect the outer pope to your tools.

I ran one along my bench with 3 ports. One for my miter saw, one to clean the bench, one to the floor to pick up sawdust that I sweep at it. I've started one up the ceiling to get to my table saw, but have not finished it yet.

Here are a couple pictures. If you are


img