Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Mortises,tenons and Shakers

Posts

Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#1

Mortises,tenons and Shakers

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Hi All,

As part of my ongoing project, making Shaker style end tables a private discussion has come about regarding the mortise and tenon construction.

I was following a plan in Woodworking Magazine that essentially advocates a very quick one tool set-up (router & router table) that makes the mortises extend

from the top of the leg down with no upper shoulder.

In a private email I received this note:

�Hi Andy,

Hey, I noticed in the photos that your tenons look to be about half an inch long, if I'm reading the scale of the legs correctly (~1 1/2"?). Typically, on a table that size, the Shakers used tenons that were from 3/4" to 1 1/16" long and about 3/8" wide. Depending on how they meet inside the leg, they would be mitered. There would also be top and bottom shoulders, usually 1/4" to 1/2" on the bottom and 9/16" or so on the top.

This is all just arcana that I felt compelled to spout. Your tenons will probably be plenty strong enough, unless Uncle Festus takes a dive on the table or something. But, I'd suggest some small pegs to reinforce those glue joints.

I didn't want to post this on the board for fear of seeming critical�.

Author of this will remain unnamed, at least by me, as to not rat anyone out. But I will say that this person is very well respected by me and I assume many, many others.

I would like to say that I did not receive or interpret the email as criticism, nor am I offended by it, I would now like to take it as a learning experience and also share it so others may benefit as well.

The legs are 1 1/8� square, mortise is 3/8� w x 3/8� d. Tenons are 3/8�

From Shaker Style End Tables
.

The argument is that the top of the leg being open leaves a small sliver of unsupported material on the inside corners of the legs. In the article in Woodworking Magazine the author, Chris Schwarz explains his rationale as this:

�Of course, the logical objection to a joint like this is that if the mortise is open on one end then the table won�t resist racking. I argue that a properly fitted tabletop takes the place of that mortise wall, constraining the tenon�s edge cheek and keeping it from racking. And, as you�ll see later, you can easily reinforce this joint with a well place peg for added insurance.� CS, Woodworking Magazine, Autumn 2004

Since I am at the point of no return I intend to peg the mortises with a small piece of bamboo rod to help strengthen the joint. I also wonder if the top and bottom drawer guides, which are notched around the legs, will also help to support/strengthen the inside corner.

Thanks,

Andy

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#2

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

John in NM

>Personally, I like more traditionally sized m-t joints, but that doesn't mean what you've got won't work. If you're worried about strength, you could make the drawer a little shallow and put some diagonal blocks across the back legs and joints in question. A well fitted top will be more than adequate to resist racking on a small table, IF it stays tight to the frame.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#3

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

Barry Irby

>I wondered about your M&T joints when I saw them also. What I "see" is on the legs with two mortise, they meat or almost meet at the inside corner and in effect, cut the little inside square free from the leg. This means that pieces will offer very little strength to press the tenon tight to the outer face of the mortise. Also, your tendons are tall (wide?) and that increases the cross grained connection.

I believe the joints would have been MUCH stronger if you had moved the mortises out nearer the outer face of the leg, use 3/8" thick tenons, made the tennons about 3/4" shorter at the top and that same or half inch shorter at the bottom of the rail and then punched them through so that the mortise intersected. Then miter the tenons so they could fully seat.

I am not clear on how the top provides racking resistance. I let the tops of tables float. I am thinking of the racking of the legs. Perhaps this would make sense if we were talking about hold the top of the frame square? Hmmm?

I learned a lot on the few tables I have made with M&T joints. What helps me is to visualise it like this. The tenon registers the position of the leg to the rail. Won't let it move up, down, sideways, etc. what give it the ultimate strength is the resistance the tenon has to be withdrawn or pulled out of the mortise. Think of it as a lever and a fulcrum. The lever is the rail/leg combination, the fulcrum is the flat/butt end of the rail or haunch where there is no tenon. When you try to close the ninety degree angle and Bend or rack the legs under the table, that haunch acts as a fulcrum, crushing the fibers in the leg, but it is the tenon That resists being blanked out of the mortise. I suspect that a tall tenon like yours that runs to the end of the rail lacks the fulcrum and the corner of the rail will crush more easily into the fibers of the leg. Also, your through cut at the top leaves that small piece of the inner side of the leg unattached at the top and unable to resist being pulled out and away.

It might be interesting to make up a couple of samples both ways and test them to destruction.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#4

Constructive Criticism

Tony - Memphis

>To the author of the email and everybody else here, I welcome your constructive criticism! Please don't feel it is offensive. In my mind,that's a large part of what this board is for. I welcome and often ask for suggestions and ideas. Sure, I may not agree and some of your "suggestions" sometimes come across as critical, but that's ok. I am not speaking for everyone, but I hope everyone agrees that one of the major strengths of this forum is that you can learn and swap ideas.

Thanks,

Tony

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#5

I started writing a response but found that Barry

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>had already written down my suggestions.

I, too, would have moved the mortises to the outside, made them skinnier and deeper.

Bruce, who is doing just that on an hallway table as we speak, or type.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#6

Re: Constructive Criticism

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn,MI

>Tony,

That is exactly why,with the author's permission,I posted this here.

I didn't want an excellent discussion/opportunity to learn to just fall onto my ears and wanted to share it.

Andy

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#7

racking

John in NM

>"I am not clear on how the top provides racking resistance. I let the tops of tables float. I am thinking of the racking of the legs. Perhaps this would make sense if we were talking about hold the top of the frame square? Hmmm?"

If the top is small enough, it resists bending that would otherwise occurr when the table is, for example, dragged across the floor rather than picked up and moved. Even with appropriate table top fasteners the top will add to the torsion box effect of the skirt. I'd guess that it wouldn't do as good a job of holding the skirt square though, as there's just the friction between parts to accomplish that.

Should work just fine for a small table, and with it successfully built, I bet the builder will feel more comfortable tackling methods that can also be applied to larger tables. Don't you think that's what Chris Schwarz had in mind with this design?

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#8

I hate it when that happens....

Barry Irby

>I just reread my own post. While I am not critical of other peoples misspellings and mangled syntax, I really hate my own. Wonder why it is that when I proofread the post before I post it, the errors don't leap out like they do when I read it later?

As far as being critical, I was not. The mortises on the legs Andy posted probably will work well the way they are. I actually don't KNOW. Knowing is different than thinking or assuming. I do believe my suggestions would make stronger joints, but Andy's joints may be plenty strong.

I am impressed by Andy's project of making eight tables. Wish I were that industrious.

When I was making my table, Ellis suggested making the mortise bigger and deeper. My legs were 3" square, so I had plenty of room. Used 1/2" thick tenons (Biggest bit I had for my mortiser) and made them 2" deep. Had the table upside down and gave the legs a shake. (Highly scientific test know to all wood workers) I was amazed. I had made the rails relatively narrow because it was a dining room table and wide rails might have been uncomfortable for those sitting around it. Even with only four inch rails with three inch mortise the legs felt as if they had been absolutely fused to the rails. So, thanks Ellis for the advice, and I thought I would pass it along.

The idea I tried to explain of how I thought the joint worked may be simple and obvious to others, but it was an epiphany for me. The little light bulb went off.

I still don't think the top contributes much tot he strength of the leg/rail connection but even if it is floating it does provide some overall strength to the table.

I come to WoodCentral to learn about woodworking and everything else that we discuss. I also come here to share what I have learned and what I know from life's experience. If I offered any criticism, it was meant to be constructive and I accept them in the same vein.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#9

Re: I hate it when that happens....

jan derr

>here here! we all come to woodcentral to learn.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#10

I know what you mean...

John in NM

>Can you believe I still have to google "tenon" to spell it right?

It can be a touchy area, critiquing anothers project, then others critiquing the critique, and all while trying to do with out tone or body language that would normally communicate so much. At any rate, I only mean to point out that there is a place for just about any construction method that will work to suit the requirements of the job. Its very easy to forget that, and I do it all the time.

The only reason I know the joint will be fine is that I've done similar ones, ages ago. First table I made, I even used slinding dovetails instead of stub tenons. Even weaker, but I didn't know that yet. At a guess, I'd say that these methods will last a lifetime or two under normal use, but they won't end up antiques (say 200+ years) like a proper M-T might.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#11

Ellis Walentine

How strong is strong enough?

Ellis Walentine

>The strength of a mortise and tenon joint has a lot to do with the amount of glue surface where mortise meets tenon, the gluing properties of the woods involved, and the strength of the glue itself. The rack resistance is further enhanced by the long side shoulders of the rail, which register the rail tightly to the leg. Also, the mechanical strength of a deep tenon in a close-fitting mortise with integral wood all around it further helps the cross-grain, mortise-tenon glue joint resist fracturing at the glue line by keeping the pieces stationary relative to each other. All these vactors, along with the structural strength of the tenon and the soundness of the mortise piece (the leg, in the case of a table apron), add up to the overall strength of the joint. If you play with any of the variables, you change the overall strength.

There is a continuum of strength from a shallow stub tenon joint to a beefy, full M&T joint. The stub tenon has much less glue area on the cheeks than a deeper tenon and would be significantly more prone to failure under abnormal stresses, such as someone leaning against the table at an angle. Deep tenons with mitered ends, housed in four-walled mortises, would add mechanical strength and rigidity to the equation.

In the case of the Shaker tables in question, I understand the rationale of the article, that here is a really quick and easy way to join legs and aprons that will be strong enough for all but the roughest use. There's no right or wrong to this design decision. Look at all the cabinet doors in this world that are held together by glued cope-and-stick joints. So, in the interests of being practical, I'd say go ahead and build the tables this way, but be careful with them. Structurally, they aren't going to be nearly as strong as they would be with conventionally tenoned rails.

Ellis

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#12

there is an easy fix

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It makes no sense to devote time and material to a flawed design. What you have is an unacceptable joint for a table leg. They will fail in use and the pins will not add significant strength to begin to compensate for the short tenon. If this joint was sound you would be seeing everyone use it.

But, what you have is the start of a haunched M&T joint. Step in 1/2" or so from the top and deepen the mortise to some depth that will provide some strength. The strength of a M&T joint sharply increases with increasing tenon length. I make the tenon in these applications of a depth that comes just short of meeting from each side.

I would also add a corner brace or block, depending on the table design, because the haunch part is deeper than normal.

All this is from the perspective of someone that builds with the hope that the piece will be useful for generations.

Re: Mortises,tenons and Shakers

#13

Re: I know what you mean...

Fred Davis

>John , you were onto a good joint when you made the sliding dovetail.

I have two matching Ash end tables with a drawer , the legs were 2x2 at the rail connection and I used a 3/4" dovetail bit to slot the leg.

This made a joint that the smallest part was a full 1/2" thick and drew the rail into the leg with near crushing force.

This joint in my opinion is far stronger then a "stub Tenon" with the additional advantage of the mechanical lock the dovetail provides.

The tables are nearly 35 years old and nothing has moved, not the least tiny crack in the finish at the joint.

With care in cutting the rail ends this joint gives automatic square fit to the frame.

FredD